Phoebe's Reviews > A Confusion of Princes
A Confusion of Princes
by Garth Nix (Goodreads Author)
by Garth Nix (Goodreads Author)
Phoebe's review
bookshelves: science-fiction, space-opera, young-adult, intergalactic-academy-reviews, loved-it
Mar 23, 12
bookshelves: science-fiction, space-opera, young-adult, intergalactic-academy-reviews, loved-it
Read on March 23, 2012
Full review at The Intergalactic Academy.
Like a lot of people my age, I dig anime. Girly anime, mostly–Sailor Moon and Cardcaptor Sakura. My affinity for odd Japanese children’s series has often left me craving a written equivalent. Manga are great and all, but I’m a book girl at heart, and have never really found anything in American YA that satisfies in quite the way that an episode of my favorite shojo might. Magical and often surreal, these shows take the typical universal experience of growing up and wrap them in vivid science fiction or fantasy trappings. But because the narratives are created outside the American cultural sphere, they have a fantastic freshness to them. They feel strange, unexpected–they make your brain work to uncover the mystery of the world even as you follow the main character’s narrative. For example, I recently began watching Revolutionary Girl: Utena, and became immersed in the strange setting (an isolated school with a floating castle out in the woods) and central plot (a student council fight duels and the victor gets to own a girl) as much as I was entertained by the spunky main character.
So I was excited when I read the blurb for Garth Nix’s A Confusion of Princes. I got a strong whiff of “anime story!” from the declaration that “being a Prince in a vast intergalactic Empire isn’t as great as it sounds. Princes may be nearly superhuman, but they are always in danger.” And really, this novel exceeded my expectations. It’s exactly what I’ve been hoping for: inventive as any anime, with strong science fictional worldbuilding, and the distinctive characters that make Western YA novels so lively.
Before you dive in to A Confusion of Princes, you should know that this is an incredibly dense, strange book, at least at first. Within the first hundred pages, we’re introduced to Prince Khemri, who was stolen from his parents (who were either killed, or mind-wiped) in order to become an intergalactic Prince. He spent the first decade in some sort of biogoop, where he had three types of “tek” implanted into him–mektek, bitek, and psitek. These terms are dropped in without explanation, and it took me most of the novel to work them out from context clues. Super strong, with psychic abilities and access to the knowledge of the Imperial Mind, Khem was raised alone with virtual tutors. But at last he’s set free, given a dozen servants, and allowed to join Princely society–where he is, in short order, killed.
(That’s not a spoiler, by the way. We’re told in the first sentence that this is the story of Khem’s first three deaths.)
This is truly challenging science fiction. Khem is not human, least of all in his view of the world. Nix doesn’t do much hand-holding here. We’re plunged into this new, strange universe in a manner more common of adult sci-fi. It’s absolutely fascinating, and I was so excited to discover the mysteries underlying his world that I just kept reading, finishing the novel in one sitting.
It wasn’t until I was about a third of the way through that I realized that aside from Khem–strongly voiced, wryly humorous, absolutely honest–there weren’t really any characters in this book, especially not at first. But I really almost didn’t notice. We’re swept along from one intriguing science fictional situation to the next and, if you’re anything like me, you’ll be so preoccupied by figuring it out that you won’t really miss people.
And then Nix pulls the rug out from under us at roughly the halfway point, when Khem meets Raine and begins to slowly take on the mantle of humanity. It’s a fascinating process, and a fascinating move in a novel such as this one. In some ways, this marks a transformation into a more typical upper-YA narrative. But Khem’s journey continues through lush environs and at a sprightly pace–and by the time he started to feel for Raine, I’d begun to feel for both of them. Sure, Nix sacrifices a little bit of the novel’s strangeness, but he exchanges it for tenderness. It works, and works well.
I really adored this book, and would imagine that it would have broad cross-over appeal–not to middle grade audiences like some of Nix’s books, but rather to adult science fiction fans. They’re likely to appreciate the rich, strange world here, even as their younger brothers and sisters enjoy the coming-of-age narrative at its core. In that way, it’s a lot like anime–and precisely what I’ve been waiting for.
Like a lot of people my age, I dig anime. Girly anime, mostly–Sailor Moon and Cardcaptor Sakura. My affinity for odd Japanese children’s series has often left me craving a written equivalent. Manga are great and all, but I’m a book girl at heart, and have never really found anything in American YA that satisfies in quite the way that an episode of my favorite shojo might. Magical and often surreal, these shows take the typical universal experience of growing up and wrap them in vivid science fiction or fantasy trappings. But because the narratives are created outside the American cultural sphere, they have a fantastic freshness to them. They feel strange, unexpected–they make your brain work to uncover the mystery of the world even as you follow the main character’s narrative. For example, I recently began watching Revolutionary Girl: Utena, and became immersed in the strange setting (an isolated school with a floating castle out in the woods) and central plot (a student council fight duels and the victor gets to own a girl) as much as I was entertained by the spunky main character.
So I was excited when I read the blurb for Garth Nix’s A Confusion of Princes. I got a strong whiff of “anime story!” from the declaration that “being a Prince in a vast intergalactic Empire isn’t as great as it sounds. Princes may be nearly superhuman, but they are always in danger.” And really, this novel exceeded my expectations. It’s exactly what I’ve been hoping for: inventive as any anime, with strong science fictional worldbuilding, and the distinctive characters that make Western YA novels so lively.
Before you dive in to A Confusion of Princes, you should know that this is an incredibly dense, strange book, at least at first. Within the first hundred pages, we’re introduced to Prince Khemri, who was stolen from his parents (who were either killed, or mind-wiped) in order to become an intergalactic Prince. He spent the first decade in some sort of biogoop, where he had three types of “tek” implanted into him–mektek, bitek, and psitek. These terms are dropped in without explanation, and it took me most of the novel to work them out from context clues. Super strong, with psychic abilities and access to the knowledge of the Imperial Mind, Khem was raised alone with virtual tutors. But at last he’s set free, given a dozen servants, and allowed to join Princely society–where he is, in short order, killed.
(That’s not a spoiler, by the way. We’re told in the first sentence that this is the story of Khem’s first three deaths.)
This is truly challenging science fiction. Khem is not human, least of all in his view of the world. Nix doesn’t do much hand-holding here. We’re plunged into this new, strange universe in a manner more common of adult sci-fi. It’s absolutely fascinating, and I was so excited to discover the mysteries underlying his world that I just kept reading, finishing the novel in one sitting.
It wasn’t until I was about a third of the way through that I realized that aside from Khem–strongly voiced, wryly humorous, absolutely honest–there weren’t really any characters in this book, especially not at first. But I really almost didn’t notice. We’re swept along from one intriguing science fictional situation to the next and, if you’re anything like me, you’ll be so preoccupied by figuring it out that you won’t really miss people.
And then Nix pulls the rug out from under us at roughly the halfway point, when Khem meets Raine and begins to slowly take on the mantle of humanity. It’s a fascinating process, and a fascinating move in a novel such as this one. In some ways, this marks a transformation into a more typical upper-YA narrative. But Khem’s journey continues through lush environs and at a sprightly pace–and by the time he started to feel for Raine, I’d begun to feel for both of them. Sure, Nix sacrifices a little bit of the novel’s strangeness, but he exchanges it for tenderness. It works, and works well.
I really adored this book, and would imagine that it would have broad cross-over appeal–not to middle grade audiences like some of Nix’s books, but rather to adult science fiction fans. They’re likely to appreciate the rich, strange world here, even as their younger brothers and sisters enjoy the coming-of-age narrative at its core. In that way, it’s a lot like anime–and precisely what I’ve been waiting for.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Confusion of Princes.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 03/23/2012 | page 3 |
|
1.0% | "Ah, much better." |
| 03/23/2012 | page 103 |
|
31.0% | "Only 100 pages in and already this is some of the most inventive SF and weirdest YA I've ever read. My brain is incredibly happy." 5 comments |
Comments (showing 1-12 of 12) (12 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Experiment BL626
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mar 23, 2012 12:10pm
Wow, you got ARC? How enviable.
reply
|
flag
*
I've always liked Garth Nix. The book sounds a little more intimidating than his other novels but I kind of want to read it anyways.
Experiment BL626 wrote: "His death? Is a story about afterlife or something?"Nope! He's of a race with more than one life (think Time Lords, only not).
Cassi, it's a very dense novel, but worth diving in. Hope you enjoy it. :)
I am so excited for this book, especially when you said that this is more like a manga/anime. I love how strange and creative mangas can get.
I love Nix and manga already and you tell me this is like fusion of literature and the best of japanese comics?! I love ya! XD
Garth Nix and space seems pretty one of the most awesome literary combinations possible. Oh, and if you're interested in more fantastical novels reminiscent of animes, I'd definitively recommend The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms by N.K. Jemisin. The setting takes place in the sky, where gods are enslaved by the ruling class. The author's a self-professed anime fan, too. =)
Just out of curiosity, have you ever read The Dresden Files? It is an epic series! They even have comics/graphic novels out for it now. It reads like like a fast paced comic book as well. Garth Nix is one of my favorite authors so I definitely have to check this out! I have a weakness for great space adventures such as Firefly, Star Wars, Outlaw Star, and Doctor Who of course.
Jake wrote: "Just out of curiosity, have you ever read The Dresden Files? It is an epic series! They even have comics/graphic novels out for it now. It reads like like a fast paced comic book as well. Garth Nix..."I've heard good things about the Dresden Files, Jake. I'll take a look, thanks! Hope you enjoy this.
That sounds fasinating: especially the comparison to anime, which I've really only just gotten into, and only a bit. But what you've described about the 'freshness' of it...I may have to add this book. Agh! so many! :D

