Brian's Reviews > Guardians of the West

Guardians of the West by David Eddings
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jun 26, 12

bookshelves: fantasy, epic-or-high-fantasy, reviewed, favorites
Read from May 21 to June 10, 2012 — I own a copy

This book is the first of 'The Mallorean' series, a sequel to Eddings' 'Belgariad' series, and as such includes all the major characters of that previous series albeit several years later.

The plotline is surpringsly similar to the first series (even to the point of it being commented upon by one of the characters in the book itself), and as such I found it hard in the beginning to justify rating this book more than 3 stars due to that similarity. In the end I gave it 4 stars because as a book (and series) the story is fresh enough to stand on it's own, regardless of any propping up it may be receiving from its 'older brother'.

I decided to go back and re-read (and review) this book (and series) as it was a much read and loved favourite from my teen years. I probably read and re-read this series more than a dozen times between it's release and my 21st birthday, and it is probably one of the primary reasons for my love of the epic/high fantasy genre.

Over 20 years later, and with a much broader experience of various writing styles and genres, I can identify numerous things that differentiate Eddings' style from the more 'Epic' styles of Tolkein or Robert Jordan, or even George R.R. Martin.

One of these faults is that, although set richly detailed world, the characters sometimes seem bland and one-dimensional. Another is what many consider to be the now cliched use of prophecy as a vehicle for the plot.

These 'faults' may prevent others from categorising the story as Epic Fantasy. However, this is a book (and series) which I still truly believe sits square in the 'Epic' or 'High' fantasy genre.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Guardians of the West.
sign in »

Reading Progress

06/03/2012 page 108
show 1 hidden update…

No comments have been added yet.