Kelly's Reviews > Girlchild
Girlchild
by Tupelo Hassman
by Tupelo Hassman
The disjointed narrative, made up of flashbacks, legal documents, court proceedings, and bits of the present, didn't work for me in this book because it never allowed Rory to have a voice. And while the fact she doesn't have a voice makes sense in the story, I couldn't connect with her for a long time and couldn't put together the pieces of why she was so broken, hurt, and silenced. I found the Girl Scout story line thinly developed until the end when it suddenly had a lot more page time.
That said, the ending was fantastic. Rory got what she deserved and did so in a way that felt redeeming and almost hopeful. I just wish more of Rory would have come through sooner in the story so the payoff would have made me cheer a little harder and I would have rooted for her a little more throughout. As it was, there were too many secondary, unimportant threads running through to really allow her story to work for me. It tried a little too hard to be literary and sacrificed other elements because of that. It ultimately wasn't that literary, either.
The setting in a trailer park was unique and a well-executed setting that didn't come off as convenient nor contrived (which it could have easily done).
That said, the ending was fantastic. Rory got what she deserved and did so in a way that felt redeeming and almost hopeful. I just wish more of Rory would have come through sooner in the story so the payoff would have made me cheer a little harder and I would have rooted for her a little more throughout. As it was, there were too many secondary, unimportant threads running through to really allow her story to work for me. It tried a little too hard to be literary and sacrificed other elements because of that. It ultimately wasn't that literary, either.
The setting in a trailer park was unique and a well-executed setting that didn't come off as convenient nor contrived (which it could have easily done).
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Girlchild.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 03/03/2012 | page 55 |
|
25.0% | |
| 03/05/2012 | page 175 |
|
78.0% | "Not as impressed as I hoped I'd be. The disjointed style isn't working for me and Rory lacks a good voice. Also the Girl Scout thing is so minor I'm surprised it makes up a big part of the flap copy." |
Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Sarahfnm
(new)
-
rated it 1 star
Mar 31, 2012 06:29pm
I agree! I read your review before I started this book and wanted to prove you wrong, but...you're right.
reply
|
flag
*

