Dave Harrison's Reviews > The Family Corleone
The Family Corleone
by Edward Falco (Goodreads Author) , Mario Puzo
by Edward Falco (Goodreads Author) , Mario Puzo
Like any guy, I'm a big Godfather fan. I've never read any of Puzo's books, though, so I was really interested when I heard that Falco was writing a prequel based on a screenplay Puzo had written.
I found the book to be lacking, however - it's not the author's fault, really. It's just strange to follow the Corleones in text. It took some getting used to -imagine the scene in Godfather 2 when Michael sits alone in the boathouse, silently brooding on the order he gave regarding his brother Fredo. There's no dialogue, no sounds - just the music feeding the atmosphere. It's hypnotic and powerful. Now imagine that the scene was narrated:
"Michael sullenly considered what he had done. Was killing his brother justifiable? Could there be another alternative that he hadn't thought of?"
Not great.
The story has its moments. It revolves around how Sonny learns about his father's business and how he enters the Don's employ, and also introduces us to a young, monstrous Luca Brasi, who terrorizes the ruling families. All the main characters are there, including Clemenza and Tessio, and even Frankie Pentangeli. But the final effect of the book doesn't leave the same taste in your mouth as the films do. Maybe it's unfair to compare them, but it's unavoidable.
I found the book to be lacking, however - it's not the author's fault, really. It's just strange to follow the Corleones in text. It took some getting used to -imagine the scene in Godfather 2 when Michael sits alone in the boathouse, silently brooding on the order he gave regarding his brother Fredo. There's no dialogue, no sounds - just the music feeding the atmosphere. It's hypnotic and powerful. Now imagine that the scene was narrated:
"Michael sullenly considered what he had done. Was killing his brother justifiable? Could there be another alternative that he hadn't thought of?"
Not great.
The story has its moments. It revolves around how Sonny learns about his father's business and how he enters the Don's employ, and also introduces us to a young, monstrous Luca Brasi, who terrorizes the ruling families. All the main characters are there, including Clemenza and Tessio, and even Frankie Pentangeli. But the final effect of the book doesn't leave the same taste in your mouth as the films do. Maybe it's unfair to compare them, but it's unavoidable.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Family Corleone.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Justin
(new)
Feb 18, 2012 01:28pm
is Ira making you do this?
reply
|
flag
*
Not at all. I'm a big Godfather fan, and I've never read one of these books. It's a prequel. It's not bad so far, though not the best.
I'm a huge Godfather fan too, but have been disappointed by everything but the first 2 films. We'll see if Paramount is successful in blocking publication ...
I can't believe that you have not read the first book. It will only make you appreciate the 1st 2 films more. Over the years I have found nuances that that can only be decerned AFTER! READING the novel. Furthermore, I saw Puzo say on Charlie Rose a couple of years before he died that this was the story he longed to tell: the story of Sonny's tranformation from kind hearted boy to relentless, stone killer. Finally, the Winegarten books sucked!!!!!!(characters all wrong) ignore them the way most fans do the last film.
@ Dave I think you really need to read Puzo's original book, The Godfather. It is excellent, which is one of the reasons I picked up this book to read since it was based on a screenplay by Puzo. I have read one of Winegardner's novel, but wasn't as impressed as reading this one. I agree with Gregory that I can't believe you haven't read his first book. It was this novel that convinced me to read most of his other Sicilian-based/Mafia-based novels. I think the only novel of his I haven't read might be The Unfortunate Pilgrim.
