td Whittle's Reviews > Tom Is Dead

Tom Is Dead by Marie Darrieussecq

by
6051061
's review
May 21, 13

bookshelves: td-whittle-reviews
Read in January, 2010

No plot spoilers here ... but then, if you are reading for plot, best look elsewhere. This is a quiet but trenchant meditation on the death of a loved one; in this case, the four year old son of the narrator, a woman whose name we never learn. Her personal circumstances are revealed to us bit by bit, filtered through her complex grief, so that reading the book feels as if we are intruding on someone's private journals or personal letters to a close friend. The writing parallels the narrator's emotional experience in its tone, vacillating between numbness, detachment, guilt, longing, rage, and raw anguish. I felt as if I were having to hold on tight through this, sensing but never knowing why the child died, right up to the denouement, where the circumstances of the boy's death are described in words as ordinary and spare as his life.

This was my introduction to Marie Darrieussecq and I came away from it wanting to read more of her work. Tom is Dead is a beautiful book. I couldn't put it down, by which I mean that I read the first few pages initially, and then went out for a few hours, after which I returned home and read straight through until 5.00 a.m. My university French abandoned me some time ago, so I had to read an English translation by Lia Hills, but I think it is a worthy one. Best read with a bottle of red, I think!

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Tom Is Dead.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Steve (new)

Steve You've made another compelling case for a story that no doubt deserves the accolades. Your writing is like crystal -- clear and expertly crafted.

I do have a question, though. Would you suggest a Bordeaux or something more along the lines of a Burgundy?


message 2: by td (last edited May 22, 2013 07:43pm) (new) - rated it 5 stars

td Whittle Thanks, Steve, that's quite a compliment and I plan to relish it with a generous portion of wine in a crystal clear goblet. It's important to celebrate the little pleasures in life, oui? Saisir le vin!

As for Burgundy or Bordeaux, either should be fine so long as it's authentically French - or a worthy translation.


message 3: by Ian (new)

Ian Graye You've made another compelling case for a French wine that no doubt deserves the accolades.


message 4: by td (new) - rated it 5 stars

td Whittle Ian wrote: "You've made another compelling case for a French wine that no doubt deserves the accolades."

I'm here to support you in your dissipation :) And it definitely does deserve the accolades.


back to top