Gail's Reviews > Bringing Up Bébé: One American Mother Discovers the Wisdom of French Parenting
Bringing Up Bébé: One American Mother Discovers the Wisdom of French Parenting
by Pamela Druckerman, Abby Craden
by Pamela Druckerman, Abby Craden
I've purposefully shied away from so many parenting books on the bookstore shelves these days. It seems like most of those geared toward pregnancy put you in a mild panic about all the things that could go wrong. And the rest? They induce a sense of fear, guilt and inferiority that, book lover though I am, I don't want to gravitate toward as I enjoy this stress-free pregnancy of mine.
BUT...I'd heard a lot of discussion about this particular book and I have to say, if it ends up being the ONLY book on parenting I read in the lead-up to my child's birth this fall, I'm better off for having made the choice.
For some quick background, the author is an American who finds herself living with her British husband in Paris at the time of their daughter's birth. Experiencing motherhood herself, Druckerman witnesses firsthand the differences in how the French families around her are raising their children and the ways in which she's drawn to the modern-day, American style of parenting she's most familiar with.
But that's the thing—this modern version of American parenting? ATTACHMENT parenting, as they call it? It's the antithesis of the way the French do it and, I believe, the way Americans USED to parent, 30 to 40 years ago. (In short, I think it's all a bit nutty).
I borrowed a library copy of this book but intend to purchase my own, as I dog-earred so many pages (a guilty habit of mine!) that I want to review it again in full at my own leisure.
Some wonderful parenting concepts explored inside the book, a favorite being this idea known as The Pause, or letting your infant child lay in his/her crib for 5-10 minutes and fuss before stepping in to see if there is a wet diaper or empty belly as the root cause of the problem. As the French have learned (and Druckerman provides research to support), infants need to teach themselves to fall back asleep—it's a learning process. But because Americans are so quick to jump in and intervene, it's a key reason why they set their children up to be unable to sleep through the night at 8, 9 or 10 months old.
Other major takeaways touch on the emphasis the French put on establishing a "cadre" or framework of discipline and responsibility for their children; the importance of manners (it's not just please and thank you but hello and goodbye for the French); instilling a child's independence (ie, not hovering over them on the playground) and teaching them how to behave at the dinner table, all the while eating food that vastly trumps our "chicken tenders friendly" U.S. kids' menus.
Some may balk at Druckerman's writing or the book's subject material, but I couldn't help but fall madly in love with these concepts. I've grown SO accustomed to seeing American children be the center of their parents' universe (constantly interrupting them in conversations, engaging their parents in their meltdowns at the dinner table) that it was a refreshing change of course to read about a culture where THAT kind of behavior is abnormal. A culture unafraid to teach its children patience ("You must teach your children frustration" is a French parenting maxim that I whole-heartedly endorse). How little of that is happening in America these days. And, as a result, not only do we have a nation of ill-behaved kids, but one for which overstressed parents are paying the price.
I am so determined not to join that rat race style of parenting — and so this is a book I intend to come back and consult in the years to come.
BUT...I'd heard a lot of discussion about this particular book and I have to say, if it ends up being the ONLY book on parenting I read in the lead-up to my child's birth this fall, I'm better off for having made the choice.
For some quick background, the author is an American who finds herself living with her British husband in Paris at the time of their daughter's birth. Experiencing motherhood herself, Druckerman witnesses firsthand the differences in how the French families around her are raising their children and the ways in which she's drawn to the modern-day, American style of parenting she's most familiar with.
But that's the thing—this modern version of American parenting? ATTACHMENT parenting, as they call it? It's the antithesis of the way the French do it and, I believe, the way Americans USED to parent, 30 to 40 years ago. (In short, I think it's all a bit nutty).
I borrowed a library copy of this book but intend to purchase my own, as I dog-earred so many pages (a guilty habit of mine!) that I want to review it again in full at my own leisure.
Some wonderful parenting concepts explored inside the book, a favorite being this idea known as The Pause, or letting your infant child lay in his/her crib for 5-10 minutes and fuss before stepping in to see if there is a wet diaper or empty belly as the root cause of the problem. As the French have learned (and Druckerman provides research to support), infants need to teach themselves to fall back asleep—it's a learning process. But because Americans are so quick to jump in and intervene, it's a key reason why they set their children up to be unable to sleep through the night at 8, 9 or 10 months old.
Other major takeaways touch on the emphasis the French put on establishing a "cadre" or framework of discipline and responsibility for their children; the importance of manners (it's not just please and thank you but hello and goodbye for the French); instilling a child's independence (ie, not hovering over them on the playground) and teaching them how to behave at the dinner table, all the while eating food that vastly trumps our "chicken tenders friendly" U.S. kids' menus.
Some may balk at Druckerman's writing or the book's subject material, but I couldn't help but fall madly in love with these concepts. I've grown SO accustomed to seeing American children be the center of their parents' universe (constantly interrupting them in conversations, engaging their parents in their meltdowns at the dinner table) that it was a refreshing change of course to read about a culture where THAT kind of behavior is abnormal. A culture unafraid to teach its children patience ("You must teach your children frustration" is a French parenting maxim that I whole-heartedly endorse). How little of that is happening in America these days. And, as a result, not only do we have a nation of ill-behaved kids, but one for which overstressed parents are paying the price.
I am so determined not to join that rat race style of parenting — and so this is a book I intend to come back and consult in the years to come.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Bringing Up Bébé.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-12 of 12) (12 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Lynn
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Feb 15, 2012 07:35am
I've read some mixed reviews about this one, but it is intriguing. I just wonder how much research the author did and how many nuggets of wisdom are to be found. There's no doubt that Americans, in general, are raising a lot of ill-mannered little brats. I applaud the idea of teaching children patience and discouraging that now-now-now expectation most have. We seem to be a culture that's petrified of our kids and immediately try to placate them to keep them quiet.
reply
|
flag
*
Lynn, I couldn't agree more. When I see the way some people in my life parent (and I'm being bold & saying this includes some family members), the thought of having a kid scares the bejesus out of me. And yet, it's people I see who DO stick to parenting beliefs that line up with the ideas I skimmed in this book, when I think, "Ahhh...So THAT'S what being a parent is SUPPOSED to be like." (and I have some like this in my family, too). It's funny, I remember my mom being fairly hands-on growing up but more than that, I remember being on my own a LOT. She let me and my imagination roam, be it outside, playing "house," drawing or, as I got older, reading. I think it's one of the best gifts she could have given me.
This isn't French parenting. It's marketing combined with common sense parenting methods used by adults with healthy boundary issues who aim to foster emotional intelligence in their kids. Don't get me started on the helicopter parenting/my kid needs an iPad to learn phonics-style of parenting that is popular right now.
Jules, I couldn't agree more with you. The key is it seems more and more there is a disproportionate number of parents who fail to understand the concept of "healthy boundary issues". And working at a university (my day job) means I see firsthand the helicopter parenting effect. We've had to adopt a parent portal for parents who are so eager to check up on their kids that they've demanded such access -- it's a growing trend in higher ed. PS - I know it's like, 85 percent marketing with this title, but I really think the name and cover of this are cute.
Haha! Well, if it gets people to buy it and teaches them ways to raise healthy children, then that's good. :)I've heard of universities now forcibly removing parents from campus on the first day of school. Between that and the 400 toys per child, we are raising a lost generation incapable of being bored or living w/o some sort of stimulation.
p.s. Sorry if I came across like a lunatic in my first comment. I see so much of what you described in real life that the top of my head blew off. These poor kids.
I was JUST reading about that whole "We don't want our kids to be bored" sentiment somewhere the other day (I think it was part of an article about how we are ALL overstimulated, courtesy of gadgets and the Internet)PS - You definitely did not come off like a lunatic. No offense taken ;)
As someone who has spent the last seven years in private elementary education, I have had more than my fair share of run-ins with helicopter parents, and let me tell you, those people are doing their children (not to mention their teachers) no favors. Ugh.
have you read "French Kids Eat Everything"? It also sounds like it has very good advice: http://joannagoddard.blogspot.com/201...
Erin wrote: "As someone who has spent the last seven years in private elementary education, I have had more than my fair share of run-ins with helicopter parents, and let me tell you, those people are doing th..."Erin, I couldn't agree more with you! I work in higher ed myself and I know all too well how those parents can be! SO not healthy!
Linda wrote: "have you read "French Kids Eat Everything"? It also sounds like it has very good advice: http://joannagoddard.blogspot.com/201..."
Linda, I saw that post on Jo's blog today too. GIven that she gave such a great recap of the book, I don't think I'll read it. I really liked this book because it didn't just focus on food (though there's a whole chapter that pretty much states the same things as "French Kids Eat Everything") but also incorporated so many other aspects of French parenting–from their lack of guilt at having their own lives to how they get their kids to sleep and behave (manners, etc.). It's a great read!

