s.penkevich's Reviews > Threats

Threats by Amelia Gray

by
6431467
's review
Mar 16, 12

bookshelves: death_and_decay, jeepers_creepers, the_jn-m-reading_list
Recommended to s.penkevich by: Joshua Nomen-Mutatio
Recommended for: Fresh fruit for rotting vegetables
Read from March 07 to 12, 2012

I think the word ‘you’ has been linked with the more devastating sentences than any other in the English language
I recently became infatuated with the writings of Amelia Gray while reading her innovative first book, AM/PM. That slim, impressive volume contained the roots of a fresh new voice, ready to break through the pages and blossom. I watched her tend to her growing charm with the short story collection, Museum of the Weird, which glowed in near equal value. There I found an ethereal elegance in her formation of tone and emotion in the longer stories and felt that she could really dazzle once she stretched out her legs in a full-length novel. Here is that first novel, and the prose is certainly blooming. Threats is a haunting tale that flourishes in a vile world of rot and decay drenched in a mournful tone that drips from each page.

The first half of the novel is nearly suffocating as Gray immerses the reader into an obfuscating haze of swirling surrealism as they piece together the fragmented mind of the tortured protagonist. They must float through ambiguous passages, flowing along in a broken order, as David tries to reconstruct his life and sanity, which were shattered and scattered by the abrupt death of his wife. All the while he is plagued by grief and paranoia, which grow increasingly imminent as the story progresses. Staying true to her short, abrupt style, the chapters in this novel as are very brief and it is the cohesive effect of these seemingly random episodes and memories that build to create an impressive structure fitting to a psychotic break. Each short chapter is brimming with imagery of rotting food, a disgusting build-up of trash, decaying flesh and a decaying life. Gray has a masterful art of delivering a potent tone, and it is the oppressive and gloomy tone of this novel that really drives it home. It is no wonder that one of her many motifs is the feeling of being swaddled, as she swaddles the reader in her menacing words. At times she even mixes the grime and rot with sentimentality, elevating the creepy feel even more as it manages to seep into the soft spots of your heart:
David sat next to his wife for three days. They leaned against each other and created a powerful odor. In that way, it was like growing old together.
Beauty can even be found in the stench of a corpse in Amelia Gray’s world.

This novel threatens your senses, from churning your stomach to sending shivers down your spine. The threats, while not being the most threatening or aggressive notes ever, serve the anxiety-ridden tone perfectly.
I WILL GATHER YOUR OLDEST FRIENDS AT MY HOME AND WE WILL HAVE A CONVERSATION. YOU WILL HEAR US TALKING BUT WHEN YOU COME INTO THE ROOM WE WILL STOP TALKING

There is a constant feeling of something being off, but not being able to quite place what it is. There is something going on that only you are not privy too. There is something crouched in your peripherals that vanishes when you try to face it head on. The novel also invokes a feeling of helplessness, as the world is shown to be threatening and slowly slipping into decay, yet any attempts to stop it are futile. David and Franny both are employed in a fight against decay, David against tooth decay, and Franny against the decay of the flesh. Shelly just wants to keep clothing clean and not let them succumb to filth. David has nothing but the best intentions and only wishes to alleviate the fears of decay from his patients, to make time still, yet he cannot and loosing the battle with rot has severe consequences. We must watch loved ones fade, and, as he points out, even the mind must rot. We are made to crumble and to hurt and to be ‘a lifetime of plans, dissolved.’

For me, the second half of the novel didn’t quite stand up to the first half. This may be attributed more to my hopes for what was to come and that the novel took up a different path than the second half actually being a letdown. However, the ominous tone that I so loved, and the cloud of confusion begins to disapate and are replaced by bizarre occurrences instead of bizarre emotional effects. As David seems to level out, the rest of the characters began to appear weak and the agglomerating motifs start to fray. There are some great ideas, the application of a doppelganger, the massive amounts of pica and building a nest of paper much like the wasps that inhabit his garage (who were once carnivores just like us), but many just don’t seem to come full circle and their purpose is rather vague. It made me often wonder if some of it was just weirdness simply for the sake of weirdness. Initially, I was a bit troubled by this. After giving it some thought, this may be the point. A boy cannot find his sought after Sugar Cereal and is told ‘It doesn’t really matter where the Sugar Cereal is does it….if you think about it, it doesn’t really matter’ (if you haven’t noticed, food plays a major role in this novel). The ideas are there, and maybe it doesn’t matter because it added to the mystery and the surreal feel. The idea was to be vague. ‘Everything gains significance if you put it on an alter’. This novel is an enigmatic game where you must seek and apply significance as you will, much like life, something to pass the time before we all decay. My only other qualm was that she tied up a few things too tightly, such as revealing connections between characters. The links would be hinted at, allowing the reader to infer the connection, but then later they would be stated point-blank and it felt rather unnecessary. The novel does come together rather well in the end though,

Amelia Gray is a new voice that should not be missed. She has shown she can deliver a strong confident prose, convey powerful and often ghastly emotions, and preform with grace through a variety of innovative story forms. Threats is a story of loss and love and the ominous touch of decay that will keep you turning pages for more as the paranoia grows. My thanks to Josh for introducing me to the works of Amelia Gray, and for our excellent discussions of this novel. You should read his exceptional review
3.75/5

Each mind dies solitary
Remember the time we remembered
Remember the steaming crack in the earth
Remember lust, and if you do
Remember me


Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Threats.
sign in »

Reading Progress

03/08/2012 page 38
14.0%
03/08/2012 "My love for this is like my love for that scene in Eraserhead with the chickens. It's like that, but oozing love for this book and not... ooze." 2 comments

Comments (showing 1-32 of 32) (32 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Joshua Nomen-Mutatio Can't. Fucking. Wait. Pre-ordered this a while back. I know this is going to be right up there with the other two amazing releases of 2012 (i.e. Blueprints of the Afterlife and The Flame Alphabet). So much good fiction to read..


message 2: by s.penkevich (last edited Feb 04, 2012 10:25pm) (new) - rated it 3 stars

s.penkevich Me either, and I'm still waiting for AM/PM in the mail. Just pre-ordered this as well. I saw FSG is publishing it, and they are one of those publishers that I enjoy so having her novel put out by them puts it up pretty high for me. I just hope I get my next two novels out of the way before then so I can read it the day it comes out. Journey to the End of the Night may have to get pushed back.


Joshua Nomen-Mutatio AM/PM is definitely doable in one sitting. Each of her books has been through a different publisher so far and they've all been good outfits. Featherproof and Fiction Collective 2 (FC2) are both great. I'm assuming FSG is, too.


s.penkevich Yeah, I'm going to read that this week along with another Mitchell novel, then try to squeeze in Journey before Threats. I've only read the first few pages of AM/PM on amazon preview and the stories from preview on Museum of the weird and I'm already a fan.
FSG published my Flannery O'Connor books and Hamsun (one of my favorites), and they always have nice essays included. It seems like with them as a publisher she will be stepping into the spotlight a bit more. You'll be able to say, 'I knew her way before!'


message 5: by Cait (new) - added it

Cait I'm looking forward to seeing your thoughts on this. I'm number one on my library's hold list, but with my luck they won't actually get any copies in for another month or four. I'm still waiting for Chaon's Stay Awake. They don't have AM/PM or Levin's Hot Pink at all, so it looks like I'll be ordering those. Damn I wish I had unlimited book buying funds.

Joshua - I don't know you, but I found FiveChapters because of a comment you made that showed up one way or another on my feed. I can't thank you enough! Short stories are a favorite of mine, and that website is cool as shit.


message 6: by Joshua Nomen-Mutatio (last edited Mar 08, 2012 11:47am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joshua Nomen-Mutatio I'm happy to help spread the word. I've been pretty smitten with short stories over the last couple of years. Some favorites aside from Amelia Gray:

The Littlest Hitler by Ryan Boudinot
Unclean Jobs For Women and Girls by Alissa Nutting
Sum by David Eagleman
Everything Ravaged, Everything Burned by Wells Tower
Girl in the Flammable Skirt by Aimee Bender


s.penkevich CaitSo far it is really good. It's caked in it's menacing tone and offers nothing truely concrete thus far giving it such a surreal feel. I think you would enjoy it. How have you liked Museum of the Weird.

Josh Awesome, I actually just ordered Unclean Jobs for Women and Girls before reading this comment. I've never read an author from my home state so I think that should be cool. I want to pick up that book by Bender as well, but I only seem to find her other collections in stores. Perhaps I'll try one of those first. Have you read any Gogol by chance? There's a few of his short stories that are favorites of mine.


JSou Okay, now I just checked out FiveChapters because of this thread. Let me just say: !!!!!!!!!! Thanks s.penkevich/Fleshy/Cait! I love you Goodreads peeps!

I'm reading Hot Pink right now and have Blueprints of the Afterlife ready to go next.


s.penkevich Nice, Hot Pink is the hot book this week, it pops up constantly. I may need to pick that up, how are you liking it so far?


Joshua Nomen-Mutatio Haven't read Gogol. I've heard great things, though.


message 11: by Cait (new) - added it

Cait Wait, Josh = MFSO? I feel like I just got done watching The Usual Suspects for the first time! Thanks so much for the recommendations. I picked up The Littlest Hitler on the way to my daughter's orchestra concert last night and read the title story while we were waiting for the show to start. Is it too early to love Boudinot already? Because I do. I loved the line, "I pity the foo who kills all the Jews." Crazy to think I'd never heard of him before Thursday.

I have the Aimee Bender and Wells Tower books here at home. I have yet to hear one negative thing said about Everything Ravaged, Everything Burned, and I kick myself every time someone mentions it because I've been meaning to get to it for so long. Bender's Willful Creatures is a favorite of mine, so I'm sure I will like The Girl in the Flammable Skirt. Sum and Unclean Jobs look great too.

S - I really liked Museum of the Weird. I admire the hell out of anyone who can tell a compelling story in only a page or two and man, Gray nails the flash fiction. You should definitely give Bender a try at some point, she and Gray actually remind me of one another.

Jess - I've been meaning to tell you, I wear my Flannery O'Connor button everyday. You are the best!


s.penkevich Cait wrote: "Wait, Josh = MFSO? I feel like I just got done watching The Usual Suspects for the first time! Thanks so much for the recommendations. I picked up The Littlest Hitler on the way to my daughter's..."

You have a Flannery O'Connor button? That is AWESOME. Jealous.

I almost bought some Bender the other day but the only one I had heard about was Girl in the Flammable Skirt and that was the only one they didn't have, but not that you've said Willful Creatures is a favorite I'll return to get that this week. Especially if she is like Gray. Glad you liked Museum, I thought it was really cool, although I did slightly prefer AM/PM. Was it just me or did Museum seem to be very obsessed with food ha, it seemed like every story somehow revolved around eating (whether or not it was actually food)


message 13: by Joshua Nomen-Mutatio (last edited Mar 10, 2012 08:50am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joshua Nomen-Mutatio Cait wrote: "Wait, Josh = MFSO? I feel like I just got done watching The Usual Suspects for the first time! Thanks so much for the recommendations. I picked up The Littlest Hitler on the way to my daughter's..."

Yep, it's me, Keyser Söze! If you love Boudinot after the title story you'll love the rest. Glad you picked it up!


message 14: by Joshua Nomen-Mutatio (last edited Mar 10, 2012 08:56am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joshua Nomen-Mutatio s.penkevich wrote: "Was it just me or did Museum seem to be very obsessed with food ha, it seemed like every story somehow revolved around eating (whether or not it was actually food)"

I also slightly prefer AM/PM. Another reader picked up on the food obsession and made a list of all the food mentions:

http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...

I noticed a bit of a fixation on food in Threats as well. I was going to mention it in my review as a possible symbol for a intimacy. Eating a meal with someone can be pretty intimate; it's something universal to all living creatures. The idea is pretty vague, which is probably why I left it out of the review.


s.penkevich Joshua Nomen-Mutatio wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Was it just me or did Museum seem to be very obsessed with food ha, it seemed like every story somehow revolved around eating (whether or not it was actually food)"

I also slig..."


Oh wow, yeah that is quite a list. I've been noticing that in Threats too, and I think it may have some connection with him having been a dentist, although I'm still too early in the novel to try and bind the ideas together. I like the idea of intimacy, which makes a lot of sense so far. When Franny isn't around he is eating the remains of whatever is left, despite various stages of freezer burn and decay (another theme that you expanded on well), without going out for new food much in the way he is looking for ways to hang onto her. There seems to be a lot of themes that she leaves vague, which I feel plays on the tone of the novel.


Joshua Nomen-Mutatio I thought the dentistry thing was an effective symbol, too. As well as Franny being an aesthetician. Both professions fight against decay and aging. They're also both intimate in a technical way; dentists are literally looking inside people, touching their mouths, etc; aestheticians are touching people's faces, trying to improve their self-esteem, help them fend off the feeling of aging/the fear of death, etc.


Joshua Nomen-Mutatio I really wanted to talk about this kind of interpretation stuff in my review but didn't manage to fit it in for whatever reason(s). Maybe I'll stop until you've finished it.


s.penkevich Joshua Nomen-Mutatio wrote: "I thought the dentistry thing was an effective symbol, too. As well as Franny being an aesthetician. Both professions fight against decay and aging. They're also both intimate in a technical way; d..."

Oh nice, I didn't think to spread that to Franny's profession yet other than when David makes the comparison and she laughs at him. Examine away, I'm nearing the 3/4th mark so I should be done soon anyways. I can't put it down. That's the trouble with reviewing, I get all these theories and ideas, and then loose them in keeping up with the flow of the review. Especially the ones that are half-developed or the ones I feel are too much of stiff-arming an opinion. You're review was rather flawless in its own regards though.


s.penkevich Wow, quite a book. I'm going to chew this over today, there's so many vague threads running through this that were really powerful. Paper eating and all.


Jenn(ifer) This was the best 'Threats' review I've read yet! (sorry other gr friends, and myself, just personal preference). Loved this: "Beauty can even be found in the stench of a corpse in Amelia Gray’s world."


message 21: by Steve (new)

Steve Another great review, Penky. Kudos, my friend. Next time I'm in the mood for grime, rot and sentimentality, I'll remember your wise observations.

Maybe it's a function of where I hang out, but does it seem like the JN-M sphere of influence has made its mark on quite a few reading lists lately? From my experience, that's as it should be. Your own favorites, S., are on my list, too, but they need to be spread out. Too much Dostoyevski and Hamsun in too short a time may do damage to a fragile brain like mine.


s.penkevich Jennifer wrote: "This was the best 'Threats' review I've read yet! (sorry other gr friends, and myself, just personal preference). Loved this: "Beauty can even be found in the stench of a corpse in Amelia Gray’s wo..."

Thank you very much! Ha, that part made me teary it was so sweet, but about spooning a rotting body! Gross.


s.penkevich Steve wrote: "Another great review, Penky. Kudos, my friend. Next time I'm in the mood for grime, rot and sentimentality, I'll remember your wise observations.

Maybe it's a function of where I hang out, but..."


Gracias. Yeah, JN-M has been a big influence on my lists lately. I have a book coming in the mail right now he and Jennifer recommended me.

The Dirty D (as I've come to call him) and Hamsun are so good, but yeah, you can definitely overdose on them. Doing so causes an existential coma and an impulse for strong drink.


message 24: by Megha (new)

Megha Steve wrote: "Maybe it's a function of where I hang out, but does it seem like the JN-M sphere of influence has made its mark on quite a few reading lists lately?"

Stephen M dubbed it 'the Joshua reading list' on some comment thread yesterday.


message 25: by Steve (last edited Mar 15, 2012 08:16am) (new)

Steve s.penkevich wrote: "The Dirty D (as I've come to call him) and Hamsun are so good, but yeah, you can definitely overdose on them."

Good advice! In my experience, existential comas and impulses for strong drink are tightly coupled. Wiser men than me advise avoiding both -- words you may wish to consider as you begin your Dublin odyssey.


s.penkevich Steve wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "The Dirty D (as I've come to call him) and Hamsun are so good, but yeah, you can definitely overdose on them."

Good advice! In my experience, existential comas and impulses ..."


I'll try, but all that Dublin makes me want some irish whisky ha. How are you coming along through it so far? I've been enjoying it, but moving slow as I haven't had much time to read it and I fear reading in small slow pieces is the worst way to go about this novel.


s.penkevich Megha wrote: "Steve wrote: "Maybe it's a function of where I hang out, but does it seem like the JN-M sphere of influence has made its mark on quite a few reading lists lately?"

Stephen M dubbed it 'the Joshua ..."


I like that, I should make that a 'shelf'


message 28: by Steve (new)

Steve s.penkevich wrote: "I'll try, but all that Dublin makes me want some irish whisky ha. How are you coming along through it so far?"

I wouldn't say that I've thrown in the towel, but I am taking a break from it. Maybe I'll discover later that the Irish whisky is the key to doing it right.


s.penkevich Steve wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "I'll try, but all that Dublin makes me want some irish whisky ha. How are you coming along through it so far?"

I wouldn't say that I've thrown in the towel, but I am taking a..."


How far into it are you? Perhaps join back in once we catch up or do you need a longer wait ha?
I test our Irish whisky theory tomorrow for St. Patty's Day in honor of Mr. Joyce.


message 30: by Steve (new)

Steve I don't have the book with me, but it was roughly page 120. In the meantime, Mr. O'Penky, do enjoy your full Irish literary/libational experience!


message 31: by Ian (new)

Ian Graye Did she write that poem at the end?


s.penkevich Yeah, except it wasn't broken up like that. There is one chapter wich is just a letter written in a long unbroken stream. I took some liberties with it, lo siento Ms. Gray.


back to top