GoldGato's Reviews > Death Or Glory: The Legacy Of The Crimean War

Death Or Glory by Robert B. Edgerton
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6401606
's review
Apr 14, 12

bookshelves: history, war, year-round
Read from February 12 to April 14, 2012

For a decent primer on the why-how-what-when of the Crimean War, this is a good book to have on the shelf. One of the most puzzling wars ever fought is explained thoroughly, even down to the games and sports the soldiers preferred...when they weren't trying to halve the opposition with cannon.

However, it seems to be written as a thesis project, because out-of-the-blue there will be references to the American Civil War. While I understand the title of the book includes the word "legacy", it doesn't seem to really provide a path to that legacy. Thus, the constant references to the Civil War, that had not yet been fought, is rather a pain. In one instance, there is an exceptionally long paragraph that suddenly ends with one sentence about the Yanks and Confederates. Weird.

In any case, I suggest you do NOT eat before or while reading this book. The gore is well explained, as the various sides do their best to kill each other in a war that solved absolutely nothing. It did, however, bring about an understanding of military medicine as more men died of disease in the Crimean War than of gunshots and sabres. The Charge of the Light Brigade is also here, with an explanation as to why the fools did what they did. And yet the stupidity of the military leadership in the Crimea was still there sixty years later in WWI. We never learn.

Book Season = Winter (so you can feel the horrific conditions these men felt)
likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Death Or Glory.
sign in »

Reading Progress

02/21/2012 page 45
15.0%
show 11 hidden updates…

No comments have been added yet.