Danielle McClellan's Reviews > You Deserve Nothing
You Deserve Nothing
by Alexander Maksik (Goodreads Author)
by Alexander Maksik (Goodreads Author)
I read this novel with no background information and loved it. Intelligent, reflective, beautifully written, excellent characters. Came on over to Goodreads to write my rave review and for the first time saw other reviews that reference the fact that this is based on a true story (view spoiler). Spent a bit of time mulling the matter over before deciding that this new biographical information does not change my assessment of the novel. Martin Amis once said that “fiction is the only way to redeem the formlessness of life,” and even if it is true that scenes and characters in this novel correspond closely to those remembered and reconstructed by others, this author has ultimately transformed a disparate series of events into something more, something with shape and substance. (Mr. Amis is a great example of an author I find fairly distasteful as a human being, but whom I deeply appreciate as a novelist.)
Life is messy. I can understand why the ex-students are angry. The novelist may or may not be a jerk. However, I believe that an artist should be allowed to use just about everything at his or her fingertips in order to create art. The real issue for me is whether this novel, taken on its own merits, asks interesting questions and does so in a compelling way. The answer here is yes and yes. I highly recommend it without reservations.
Life is messy. I can understand why the ex-students are angry. The novelist may or may not be a jerk. However, I believe that an artist should be allowed to use just about everything at his or her fingertips in order to create art. The real issue for me is whether this novel, taken on its own merits, asks interesting questions and does so in a compelling way. The answer here is yes and yes. I highly recommend it without reservations.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read You Deserve Nothing.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Emma
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jun 19, 2012 12:43pm
I totally agree. He paints the lead character as (as you put it) a jerk. The fact that he is that man makes it all the more poignant, in my view.
reply
|
flag
*
Emma wrote: "I totally agree. He paints the lead character as (as you put it) a jerk. The fact that he is that man makes it all the more poignant, in my view."Thanks for your note, Emma. I agree that the main character was deeply flawed and that added a great deal to my appreciation of the tensions in the novel.
Totally agree with the Marin Amis comment. I sometimes feel guilty for reading his books because I disapprove of him so much. With regards to the real Will. Do you think his final act - not denying the affair or arguing for his job - was a nod to the fact that he believed he deserved nothing?
With regards to the real Will. Do you think his final act - not deny..."
Thanks for your comment, Marie. I sensed a lot of ambivalence coming from Will about his affair and his private life in general. He seemed incredibly passive and I think that we were supposed to see him as somewhat shell-shocked. Your suggestion may hit it right on the head. I also wondered whether the title was partly a nod to the privileged life that so many of those students had and the idea that they had to move beyond those expectations to grab hold of a more meaningful life.

