Reynje's Reviews > This is Not a Test
This is Not a Test
by Courtney Summers (Goodreads Author)
by Courtney Summers (Goodreads Author)
Reynje's review
bookshelves: arc-egalley, books-that-linger, held-me-captive, face-punch-endings, read-2012, welcome-to-the-apocalypse, young-adult, favourites
Aug 06, 12
bookshelves: arc-egalley, books-that-linger, held-me-captive, face-punch-endings, read-2012, welcome-to-the-apocalypse, young-adult, favourites
Read from February 02 to 04, 2012
[Edited, because ZOMBIE NAILS. See below]
4.5 stars
This is not a zombie book.
This book has zombies in it. But it’s not about zombies, as such.
It’s about so much more than that.
Call them a catalyst, a threat, an inciting event – the zombies are an ominous presence that set off a chain reaction of events and lurk unnervingly around the corners of the book. But this is not even so much a book about survival, although that’s certainly one of the themes threading through the story.
For me, deep at its heart, this was a book about will. The will to live versus the will to die. And how sometimes, for some people, this is not an unconscious, involuntary response to each day as it arrives, but a choice and a fight every moment.
This Is Not A Test is an incredibly intense and psychologically gruelling novel to read. It had me in a stranglehold from the first page, from Sloane’s opening words, which almost echo with the emptiness carved out by her sister's absence. While her pain bleeds through the pages in places, there’s also something detached, cold, about her narration. Because her mind has been made up. She’s resolved. Until the morning the world shatters.
In depicting her vision of the zombie apocalypse, Summers uses restraint to masterful effect. The horror of the undead is rendered more powerful by the suggestion of their presence, like the sound of them hammering against doors in their hunger, as opposed to always placing them in the limelight. Similarly, by barricading six teenagers into a school, it’s the constant fear of a breach that stretches the nerves to breaking point, rather than an endless gore-fest. Which is not to say that This Is Not A Test doesn’t contain disturbing images of violence or pay homage to the genre of zombie horror – it does – but the effectiveness is amplified by the enormous amount of tension that has been wound up in the plot.
The scenario of six people thrown together, under siege by the rabid infected and forced to make snap judgements with life or death ramifications, makes for a mental battleground. The dynamic balances on a knife-edge, allegiances and motivations threatened by accusations, guilt and desperation born out of the desire to live (or die). At work beneath the more obvious conflicts are the character’s own internal battles, and the larger questions of what it means to take or save a life, and at what cost do they preserve their own. Who is the real enemy - the undead, or the darker side of human nature?
This Is Not A Test almost defies categorisation. It’s a hybrid of sorts, and the brutal emotional honesty is not sacrificed in order to continue ratcheting up the tension. It sounds strange, but the juxtaposition of the contemporary elements with the horror premise work exceptionally well. The parallels between the internal and external fight to survive are powerful, and there is a depth and relevance to this story in it’s insightful portrayal of pain, loss, grief, and ultimately, choice.
In Sloane, Summers has created a character and a story that hit me right in the chest. I felt an almost relentless ache for her, for what had compelled her to make her decision. And yet never does the writing feel gratuitous or melodramatic. It feels painfully realistic, all the more powerful for the things that are left unspoken, the profound silences between the scenes.
I was exhausted when I finished This Is Not A Test. I felt mentally, emotionally, physically (because I stayed up so late to read it) wrung out – and the haunting final scene of the book lingered with me days afterwards.
I’m a little bit in awe of this book.
And I’m going to start sleeping with a cricket bat under my bed.


4.5 stars
This book has zombies in it. But it’s not about zombies, as such.
It’s about so much more than that.
Call them a catalyst, a threat, an inciting event – the zombies are an ominous presence that set off a chain reaction of events and lurk unnervingly around the corners of the book. But this is not even so much a book about survival, although that’s certainly one of the themes threading through the story.
For me, deep at its heart, this was a book about will. The will to live versus the will to die. And how sometimes, for some people, this is not an unconscious, involuntary response to each day as it arrives, but a choice and a fight every moment.
This Is Not A Test is an incredibly intense and psychologically gruelling novel to read. It had me in a stranglehold from the first page, from Sloane’s opening words, which almost echo with the emptiness carved out by her sister's absence. While her pain bleeds through the pages in places, there’s also something detached, cold, about her narration. Because her mind has been made up. She’s resolved. Until the morning the world shatters.
In depicting her vision of the zombie apocalypse, Summers uses restraint to masterful effect. The horror of the undead is rendered more powerful by the suggestion of their presence, like the sound of them hammering against doors in their hunger, as opposed to always placing them in the limelight. Similarly, by barricading six teenagers into a school, it’s the constant fear of a breach that stretches the nerves to breaking point, rather than an endless gore-fest. Which is not to say that This Is Not A Test doesn’t contain disturbing images of violence or pay homage to the genre of zombie horror – it does – but the effectiveness is amplified by the enormous amount of tension that has been wound up in the plot.
The scenario of six people thrown together, under siege by the rabid infected and forced to make snap judgements with life or death ramifications, makes for a mental battleground. The dynamic balances on a knife-edge, allegiances and motivations threatened by accusations, guilt and desperation born out of the desire to live (or die). At work beneath the more obvious conflicts are the character’s own internal battles, and the larger questions of what it means to take or save a life, and at what cost do they preserve their own. Who is the real enemy - the undead, or the darker side of human nature?
This Is Not A Test almost defies categorisation. It’s a hybrid of sorts, and the brutal emotional honesty is not sacrificed in order to continue ratcheting up the tension. It sounds strange, but the juxtaposition of the contemporary elements with the horror premise work exceptionally well. The parallels between the internal and external fight to survive are powerful, and there is a depth and relevance to this story in it’s insightful portrayal of pain, loss, grief, and ultimately, choice.
In Sloane, Summers has created a character and a story that hit me right in the chest. I felt an almost relentless ache for her, for what had compelled her to make her decision. And yet never does the writing feel gratuitous or melodramatic. It feels painfully realistic, all the more powerful for the things that are left unspoken, the profound silences between the scenes.
I was exhausted when I finished This Is Not A Test. I felt mentally, emotionally, physically (because I stayed up so late to read it) wrung out – and the haunting final scene of the book lingered with me days afterwards.
I’m a little bit in awe of this book.
And I’m going to start sleeping with a cricket bat under my bed.


Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read This is Not a Test.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-40 of 40) (40 new)
date
newest »
newest »
YES.DOITDOITDOIT.
I mean... uh... do what you want.
*retreats into the shadows*
ps. p-plans? Like.... real life plans? Who are you?!
By "plans" I meant watching Downton Abbey and eating cereal directly from the box in my pyjamas. Because I know how to have fun.Cillian - I am so excited I'm basically jealous of myself :)
Oh, I adore summers and she's sounds as delightfully brilliant, unnerving and mesmerizing as always. I seriously cannot wait for this bookYour review is just fab. I was nodding along should reading it. Even though I haven't read the book yet :)
Thanks Nomes :) "Unnerving" is a great word for it. I'm going to track down her previous books and give them a go because I just loved her writing in this. Can't wait to hear what you think when you get to this one!
Some Girls Are is her most intense book out of her other three, soo good, I swear I had chest pains while reading itI can't pick my fave of hers, maybe Cracked Up To be - but only as it was my first of hers and it made md such a fan girl, so I feel eager nostalgic when I think back to it :)
does it haven an open ending or more of a conclusion? i hate open endings and cliffhangers, unless they are justified in some way and make sense.
Awesome review Rey. So glad you liked it! Feeling wrung out is the perfect way to describe the feeling after finishing this book :)
"Who is the real enemy - the undead, or the darker side of human nature?" Niiiice...and
"By "plans" I meant watching Downton Abbey and eating cereal directly from the box in my pyjamas. Because I know how to have fun." Yes, you do! But for me, its usually a bowl of pasta caked with melted cheese on top.
Thanks Jasprit and K (you're giving me ideas!) ;)Leyoh, it's pretty amazing. Hope you get the chance to read it soon.
It's five in the morning and I just finished reading this book.I bow down to your review because it is perfect. Perfect in that it describes the way I ache right now... and I don't know whether its a good ache or bad, but my goodness do I just want to bawl my heart out! Come back to me characters! I'm not ready to be parted from you!!!
Thanks Yara - I felt the same way when I finished it too. It was such a powerful book. I really need to read more of Courtney Summer's work!
Wow, wow, wow, wow, wow, wow, wow. What a beautiful review. As I came scrolling down goodreads, browsing my friends reviews of This Is Not A Test, I saw yours coming up. I thought you'd have enjoyed it and was surprised (but happy) that you ended up loving it as much as you did! Just wanted to pop in and say thanks for selling me on this book, before I was hesitant (because let’s be honest, zombies are freaking freaky) but now I’m really interested to get my hands on a copy! :)
Rebecca wrote: "Wow, wow, wow, wow, wow, wow, wow. What a beautiful review. As I came scrolling down goodreads, browsing my friends reviews of This Is Not A Test, I saw yours coming up. I thought you'd have enjoye..."Thanks Rebecca! This one definitely left an impression on me, and I hope you get to read it soon :)
I can't not comment on this because those nails are AMAZING. Sealed with a top coat, perfect for any zombie apocalypse. I think dressing for success is the key part of ANY survival plan. ;) So. Cool.
Great review. I agree with you about how this book is about the will to live versus the will to die. I just finished this book a few minutes ago, and my reaction to the ending was just . . . wow. I think the open-ended ending was perfect for this book.






*eats braaaains*