Kaila's Reviews > White Cat

White Cat by Holly Black
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Apr 05, 2016

liked it
bookshelves: 2012, fantasy, young-adult, urban-fantasy
Read from February 28 to 29, 2012

Not much information is given as to the nature of the magic in this book, and even by the end I was still a little fuzzy on it. Basically there are some special people in the world, around the lines of 1% of the population if I remember correctly, who are able to "Work" certain types of magic if they can touch you or an object. A Luck Worker, for example, can touch you (only with fingers as far as I know) and cause either bad or good luck. Because of this, gloves are all the rage and you're basically required to wear them. It would be like not wearing pants if you don't have gloves on. I like this idea but then she mentions even infants have to have gloves on because otherwise they could Work accidentally and that left me with a strange and vaguely uncomfortable feeling. Nevertheless, the concept is great and I was interested from the get go, but it ended up falling a little flat for me.

I'm not familiar with Holly Black's work but the writing and characters are pretty strong in this, and according to other reviewers on Goodreads, this is a huge improvement over her past novels. I was intrigued from the beginning for where the story was going to go. Time has been kinder to my opinion than I was upon immediately setting it down - now all I remember is that it was fast paced and action packed, but my notes belie those emotions. I was rather bored by the sides characters and the constant act of questioning a memory for realness or not grew exhausting.

There's something about running elaborate cons that I obviously find intriguing because whenever there's a conman in a book nowadays I always love him. Maybe because I'm a terrible actor and too honest for my own good? Sure, let's go with that. At any rate, the cons were always hilarious and I loved that she came up with them.

Overall, I'm left with a pretty "meh" feeling about this one. I really wanted to like it, but it was just ok for me.
1 like · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read White Cat.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

04/05 marked as: read

Comments <span class="smallText"> (showing 1-3 of 3) </span> <span class="smallText">(3 new)</span>

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Leslee (new)

Leslee I heard Holly Black was actually a fanfic writer before she got published a la Cassandra Clare, and in fact was the one who got Ms. Clare discovered. I read some of Clare's fanfics back in the day but haven't read any of her novels because I heard they were a bit of a retread of her earlier fanfic work. I wonder how Holly Black's novels compare to her earlier fanfics.

Kaila Oh my, I didn't know that. Well everyone has to start somewhere right! From what I read while writing this review it sounds like her writing has improved enormously.

message 3: by Leslee (new)

Leslee Yeah, I don't mind the humble beginnings, in Clare's case it's more mining fics she'd written before to create her 'original' works, the idea of that turns me off. I have a couple of holly black books that someone passed to me, I'll give her a shot.

back to top