Scott's Reviews > River of Smoke
River of Smoke (Ibis Trilogy, #2)
by Amitav Ghosh
by Amitav Ghosh
Jan 27, 2012
Read from January 17 to 26, 2012
This was the second in the Ibis Trilogy (following Sea of Poppies). I liked it, but a few of my favorite characters and story lines from Sea of Poppies were replaced by ones that did not grab my attention quite as easily. The story takes place just a few months later, but this time most of the action is in Canton. Because of this I find myself comparing River of Smoke with James Clavell's Taipan - both are historical fiction, both are set in Canton/HK circa 1840 and both revolve around the opium trade. But they come from opposite perspectives. Taipan lionizes the opium traders (one in particular) and turns them into heroes that you want to root for despite yourself. In contrast, River of Smoke regularly highlights the injustice and hypocrisy of the opium trade. At times it is a little overbearing, but it certainly must be the fairer representation. River of Smoke also has more of a historical feel, i.e. it's not as fictional. Ghosh incorporates several true historical persons and gives them dialogue that would be true to the character by researching and relying heavily on historical documents, e.g. newspaper articles, journals, speeches, etc. It was a nice touch and one that I did not realize until reading the acknowledgments at the end. It made me feel like I got a little more out of it, i.e. I learned a bit and that's never a bad thing.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read River of Smoke.Sign In »