Tim's Reviews > Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed

Collapse by Jared Diamond
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Apr 29, 2012

really liked it
bookshelves: science, history, enviro
Read from February 29 to April 25, 2012

Diamond's previous book Guns Germs and Steel was for me (and lots of other people, I think) a real eye-opener. There were 5 or 6 ideas in that book that I had never even heard mention of before reading, but that seem so elegant and obvious upon reflection. To give just one example, the way the east-west orientation of the Eurasian continent facilitates travel and the spread of crops and ideas, in contrast to the north-south orientations of Africa and the Americas, which hinder that spread. Regardless of whether you fully buy into his overall argument, it was a masterpiece of popular science writing.

Collapse continues that high-level of quality, although the tenor of the work is different. Rather than a collection of diverse ideas supporting one theme, Diamond applies a set of 5 factors to explain the collapses of several ancient civilizations -- Easter Island, Pitcairn/Henderson, the Anasazi, the Classic Period Maya and the Norse in Greenland. This gives the book more of a repetitive feel than Guns, but the romance of ancient civilizations and his beautiful explanations are more than enough to keep you glued to the pages.

The second half of the book addresses collapses in the modern world (Rwanda, Haiti) or current societies that are probably unsustainable (China, Australia). In these sections you can sense that Diamond is a little out of his element. The chapter on China is an especially deadly litany of environmental statistics offered with little real insight into the complexity of that country. He closes the book with a generally interesting discussion of sustainability in the modern world.

Like its predecessor, Collapse is a synthesis of a very large body of scientific work, which naturally means that it is not the last word on any of these topics. He alludes briefly to some of the controversies found within the scientific communities that study these civilizations. The book has also spawned some pushback in the form of a collection of essays -- Questioning Collapse. I don't think it's a big knock on a work of popular writing, but it's important to note that there are other perspectives out there on these complicated questions.
1 like · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Collapse.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Lynda Hi Tim,I really enjoyed the book..Cleary had Jared Diamond for a professor..she loved his lectures

message 2: by Tim (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tim Hi Aunt Lynda! Yeah, I really enjoyed Guns Germs and Steel so I'm looking forward to this also. That's cool Clearly had him as a prof - I can imagine he'd be really interesting...

back to top