Wendy Darling's Reviews > Necromancing the Stone
Necromancing the Stone (Necromancer, #2)
by Lish McBride
by Lish McBride
Wendy Darling's review
bookshelves: 2012-publication, henry-holt, young-adult, pn-zombies, macmillan, ala-2012, september, pn-ghosts, pn-shapeshifters, hilarious, male-pov, read-2012, 2012-favorites, too-many-povs
Jul 21, 12
bookshelves: 2012-publication, henry-holt, young-adult, pn-zombies, macmillan, ala-2012, september, pn-ghosts, pn-shapeshifters, hilarious, male-pov, read-2012, 2012-favorites, too-many-povs
Read from July 12 to 14, 2012
Win an ARC of Necromancing the Stone over at The Midnight Garden! Open internationally through 7/30.
4.5 stars At long last, it's here! This review contains some spoilers from the first book, so proceed at your own risk.
After killing the evil necromancer Douglas Montgomery in last year's hilarious Hold Me Closer, Necromancer, Sam LaCroix has not only inherited Douglas' seat on their town's supernatural Council, but he's inherited his huge house, his shapeshifting cat butler James, and a small army of angry jam-loving gnomes as well. Just as he's settling into his new position as head of a very unusual household, however, his sister gets a nasty threat delivered to her door, and a sudden death changes everything. One thing a necromancer should always keep in mind, after all, is that just because someone's dead doesn't mean they stay that way.
It feels like we've been waiting for this sequel forever, and I'm so pleased to report that catching up with Sam and his crew is even more fun the second time around. Necromancing is more tautly plotted, faster, funnier, and full of even more madcap moments than the last time around.
Fun Necromancing Madness
A vengeful undead enemy? Check.
A werebear best friend? Check.
A harbinger of death who uses a Blackberry? Check.
A pointy-toothed, beef jerky-loving pygmy cupacabra? Check.
Stupidly entertaining gnome names like Chauncey the Devourer of Souls or Gnoman Polanski? Check.
Deceitful companions who just might be enemies? Check.
Aside from the zany one-liners and good-humored characters, there are also surprising moments of gravity that I really appreciated. Okay, so they happen to involve a sad zombie panda and throat-cutting, but still! I also got the wish I expressed in my review of Necromancer, which was that the antagonist would be more fully developed and nuanced. I loved the way the author explored his back story, and the climax and resolution felt properly serious and satisfactory, without being too somber for a book like this.
If I were to nitpick, I do wish a little more had been done with the awesome secondary cast. While I really liked the werewolf politics involving Sam's girlfriend Brid and her pack, I would love to have seen more done with the werebear, gnomes, etc. Right now they're mostly there for comic relief, while there was such a great opportunity to utilize them in the action and interpersonal scenes. I'm also not sure that James, the cat shapeshifter, also need to have a second form (view spoiler) since he doesn't really use it and it's so different from his other two forms.
I am, however, very glad that the book mostly loses the extraneous POVs that made the first book so disjointed. Necromancing the Stone focuses on two primary characters and allows us to get to know and appreciate both. Still, a third POV is inserted very late into the book at page 161, and then again at pages 278 and 296--and being that all of them total 11 pages, it seems as though the book would be much more streamlined and would have flowed much better if those parts had been reworked somehow.
But none of that really matters in the end, because jeez, this book is just so much fun. It's awesome when a sequel is even better than the original, and I'm hoping this means we'll not only see a trilogy, but that the third book will be the best book of all. If you enjoy humor with your young adult urban fantasy, this is a series that's not to be missed.
This review also appears in The Midnight Garden. An advance copy was provided by the publisher.
P.S. Waffles make an appearance on page 50. Just in case you were wondering.
4.5 stars At long last, it's here! This review contains some spoilers from the first book, so proceed at your own risk.
After killing the evil necromancer Douglas Montgomery in last year's hilarious Hold Me Closer, Necromancer, Sam LaCroix has not only inherited Douglas' seat on their town's supernatural Council, but he's inherited his huge house, his shapeshifting cat butler James, and a small army of angry jam-loving gnomes as well. Just as he's settling into his new position as head of a very unusual household, however, his sister gets a nasty threat delivered to her door, and a sudden death changes everything. One thing a necromancer should always keep in mind, after all, is that just because someone's dead doesn't mean they stay that way.
It feels like we've been waiting for this sequel forever, and I'm so pleased to report that catching up with Sam and his crew is even more fun the second time around. Necromancing is more tautly plotted, faster, funnier, and full of even more madcap moments than the last time around.
Fun Necromancing Madness
A vengeful undead enemy? Check.
A werebear best friend? Check.
A harbinger of death who uses a Blackberry? Check.
A pointy-toothed, beef jerky-loving pygmy cupacabra? Check.
Stupidly entertaining gnome names like Chauncey the Devourer of Souls or Gnoman Polanski? Check.
Deceitful companions who just might be enemies? Check.
Aside from the zany one-liners and good-humored characters, there are also surprising moments of gravity that I really appreciated. Okay, so they happen to involve a sad zombie panda and throat-cutting, but still! I also got the wish I expressed in my review of Necromancer, which was that the antagonist would be more fully developed and nuanced. I loved the way the author explored his back story, and the climax and resolution felt properly serious and satisfactory, without being too somber for a book like this.
If I were to nitpick, I do wish a little more had been done with the awesome secondary cast. While I really liked the werewolf politics involving Sam's girlfriend Brid and her pack, I would love to have seen more done with the werebear, gnomes, etc. Right now they're mostly there for comic relief, while there was such a great opportunity to utilize them in the action and interpersonal scenes. I'm also not sure that James, the cat shapeshifter, also need to have a second form (view spoiler) since he doesn't really use it and it's so different from his other two forms.
I am, however, very glad that the book mostly loses the extraneous POVs that made the first book so disjointed. Necromancing the Stone focuses on two primary characters and allows us to get to know and appreciate both. Still, a third POV is inserted very late into the book at page 161, and then again at pages 278 and 296--and being that all of them total 11 pages, it seems as though the book would be much more streamlined and would have flowed much better if those parts had been reworked somehow.
But none of that really matters in the end, because jeez, this book is just so much fun. It's awesome when a sequel is even better than the original, and I'm hoping this means we'll not only see a trilogy, but that the third book will be the best book of all. If you enjoy humor with your young adult urban fantasy, this is a series that's not to be missed.
This review also appears in The Midnight Garden. An advance copy was provided by the publisher.
P.S. Waffles make an appearance on page 50. Just in case you were wondering.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Necromancing the Stone.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-50 of 61) (61 new)
message 1:
by
Wesley
(new)
-
added it
22 mar. 13:34
can't wait for this one!
reply
|
flag
*
Yay Wendy! Missed you on this site. How have you been? (lol sorry my comment has nothing to do with the actual book)
:) Thanks Chelsea! I'm trying to ease back into the swing of things. Hope you've been reading lots of good books!I don't know how this reading experience could be anything other than fun, Laura. ;)
Julia, have you read the first book, Hold Me Closer, Necromancer? It's very fun, too. In both of the books, each of the chapter titles is a lyric from a song. :)
I have not! I hadn't even heard of it. Sounds very exciting, though. I put it on my TBR list :) Are the lyrics they use recent? I was just thinking how much money it would have to cost to publish a book with song lyrics in it.
It's a good combination of humor and raising the dead, hah. The first book has some rough spots but is still very enjoyable; this one seems much more polished.The lyrics are fairly recent, yes. But it's just one (unattributed) line from each song, so I doubt they had to pay anything to use them. Probably falls under fair use.
I learned in my Creative Writing class that if the person hasn't been dead more than 70 (I think) years then the writer must pay a publishing fee for their lyrics/poetry/quotes. Isn't that crazy? I think the fee is pretty light (unless it's some big named pop star, then maybe the price goes up). One of my friends was stressing because she used a Jimi Hendrix lyric, ha. I'm basing this off my professor told me -- I have no intention of publishing a book with lyrics in them so I haven't really explored it thoroughly to be sure of the length of death or price or accuracy. Just a bit of random information, hah. ;)
Well, I love a good, ol' humorous tale of raising the dead! I look forward to starting it. :)
Hm, I looked again and it does look like most of the song titles are probably a bit older--and there aren't any "used with permission" bits in the beginning of the book. Still, the quotes are so short that I would be surprised if they were actually charged for them, as I think they'd be considered a short phrase. e.g. "Hello darkness my old friend," "Another one bites the dust," etc., rather than a whole line. Although I'm not an expert on this stuff at all!
Either way, I hope you enjoy this series if you start it. :)
Oh, those sound rather universally used, though! Haha, I doubt he'd be charged for something so well know. I was thinking of a full blown lyric where "/" signs are appropriate. Well, now I simply must start it. I added to it my TBR shelf after all! :)
Yeah, I don't think so either, Julia. I wasn't very clear in saying "lyric" though, I should have indicated it was more of a snippet/song title. I'm glad you're going to give the first book a shot!Thanks Jen. :) I am so behind on my emails responding to people, but I truly, truly appreciate the note you sent me.
Eep! Wendy! You've read this one already? I'm jealous! I miss Sam! LOL! Glad to know this one is even better than the first book! Looking forward to your review. :)
Wendy Darling wrote: "Yeah, I don't think so either, Julia. I wasn't very clear in saying "lyric" though, I should have indicated it was more of a snippet/song title. I'm glad you're going to give the first book a shot!..."AWWWW! I'm so glad you got it. I wasn't sure if you were checking messages at all, but I'm happy to know that you did see it even if you weren't responding or coming online.
It's so much fun, Eunice! I think anyone who liked the first book will have a great time with this one. :)And yeah, I've been checking messages off and on, Jen. The flood of comments and emails and tweets and such have been pretty overwhelming, though, so I'm still kind of slowly answering when I can wrap my brain around stuff now and again. The drama is obviously nowhere near ending, of course, which is just...awful.
I have tried to comment as little as possible with the drama because whoever is behind it is probably loving how actively everyone is discussing it. I wish there were some legal thing that could be done to put an end to it.
I agree, all of this is for attention. I thought long and hard before commenting in that other thread, but honestly I couldn't stay silent and not voice support when so many people have stuck up for me in the past. Aside from which, I'm sure I've already got a target on my back anyway.
I did, the Macmillan rep was very amused at the little squeal I gave when she handed it to me! I have a zillion reviews to write, but the ones for fun books like this are easy and the review is pretty much just gushing.
Jennifer wrote: "Do you think we'll ever truly know who is behind it? :-("I have a pretty good idea. The syntax, attack style, and content are pretty similar to the author who did the "scandalous" expose on me a few weeks ago. (Not to mention similarly delusional.) But who knows, maybe she has some real life indie author friends involved with it this time, too.
That's what I keep seeing in the commentary I've been reading, that it's her. If it's all just one person pretending to be several different people collaborating on the blog, that's just...crazy!
YAY! Wendy's back. I don't comment much, but I do enjoy reading your reviews - as both an author and a reader. Glad to see you're okay, first of all, and more so that you're getting back in the swing of things. Welcome back, Wendy - I hope you don't have to weather anymore storms like the last one.
Josin, thanks so much for the lovely comment. I haven't responded to all the messages and such from the past month yet, but I sincerely appreciate the comment you left on my blog, too. It means a lot to have authors speaking out against this sort of behavior in general, and it certainly means a lot to me personally as well. I strongly suspect there's still a target on my back, but it's encouraging that most people who are taking a stance on this agree that the cyberstalking and tantrums are abhorrent.Jennifer, Wicked--I would be surprised if it wasn't her.
And yay! I don't think you'll be disappointed in this one, Camille and Wendy. This has been the year of mostly excellent Book Twos. :)
The title caught my attention on this one. I look forward to your review. I marked the first one on my to read list. :) thanks!
If you like this kind of humor, Renetta, I'm sure you'll enjoy it! Let me know what you think of the series when you get around to reading it.Wendy, there is a cat butler. And mischievious gnomes. :D
Eeek! Better than the first book?!? I LOOOOOOVED Hold Me Closer! Can't wait to hear what you thought, Wendy!
Oh yeah--you won't be disappointed, Kelly. :) It feels like I've been waiting for this book forever!The punny title is fun, Molly. :) I confess that I was a little less enthused about the first title because it put "Tiny Dancer" on a loop in my brain non-stop, hah.
And YES, better than the first book, Jen! You'll love it.
"Chauncey the Devourer of Souls" is pretty amusing, but I've got to say, "Gnoman Polanski" takes the cake.
I'm pleased that you had fun with this, Wendy. You're right, it's nice realizing the sequel is as good, if not better than the first.
I'm pleased that you had fun with this, Wendy. You're right, it's nice realizing the sequel is as good, if not better than the first.
Oh, you'll have such a good time with this, Helly!And it's so rare when a sequel/sophomore book is better than the first book, Leanne. There are tons more funny gnome names, but I limited myself to including just two. ;)
Yeah! I've been so excited about this book since I finished the first. I'm glad to see that it's even better than Hold Me Closer, Necromancer, and I am relieved to know that waffles make an appearance, I was worried! Fantastic review, Wendy!
Wendy Darling wrote: "Oh, you'll have such a good time with this, Helly!
And it's so rare when a sequel/sophomore book is better than the first book, Leanne. There are tons more funny gnome names, but I limited myself ..."
Oh, do tell! Please, just one more. ;)
And it's so rare when a sequel/sophomore book is better than the first book, Leanne. There are tons more funny gnome names, but I limited myself ..."
Oh, do tell! Please, just one more. ;)
I was waiting for those waffles, Ruby. Just waiting for them. :)Okay, one more gnome just for you, Leanne: The Darkness Known as Mittens. :D
Thanks Carina! I'm sure if you enjoyed the first book, you'll have a great time with this one, too.
Good to hear that you liked it! I owe this series to you! I'm looking forward to reading this next one!
Yay Pricky! It always makes me happy when people tell me they enjoyed Necromancer. I'm sure you'll enjoy this one, too!












