Odo's Reviews > Blue Remembered Earth

Blue Remembered Earth by Alastair Reynolds
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
M_50x66
's review
Feb 16, 12

Read from January 18 to 27, 2012

(Originally published on http://sentidodelamaravilla.blogspot.... )


Blue Remembered Earth was the first pick of our twitter book club (you can find us by searching for the hashtag #cifituits). During the joint reading, someone asked whether we considered this to be a typical Reynolds's novel. The short answer is, unfortunately, no. The long answer is a bit more complex.

Although many of the topics that are usual in the works of Reynolds (space travel, genetic modifications, brain implants, artificial intelligence...) also appear in Blue Remembered Earth, almost none of them are explored with the depth that we have come to expect from the Welsh author. Instead of being elements that help moving the plot forward, they are limited here to being part of a setting that is not even as attractive as, for example, the one in the Revelation Space series. There are exceptions, like the wonderful visit to the underwater city of Tiamaat but, alas, they are few and apart.

The story is not much better than the world-building. We follow Geoffrey and her sister Sunday while they investigate a series of clues left by their grandmother Eunice Akinya, a space exploration pioneer and founder of an interplanetary empire. This quest will take us to explore all the mid-twenty-second century Solar System, from Africa to the Moon, from Mars to the asteroid belt.

This could have made a very entertaining story but it is weighted down by some problems. The action is very slow to take off (pun intended), with nothing especially significant happening until well into the second third of the book. About 40% into the novel (I read it as an ebook so it is almost impossible to give concrete page references) things seem to begin falling into place and the reader starts figuring out what can be expected of the novel. Until then, however, there have been too many scenes that, while not boring, have little or no relevance to further development of events.

But the main flaw of Blue Remembered Earth is its almost complete lack of tension. Surprisingly, Reynolds fails this time to create a mystery that grabs the reader, something that he had perfectly achieved in many of his previous works (Pushing Ice and Diamond Dogs being two of the most notable examples in this respect). Moreover, the action is set in an utopian society in which, due to the almost constant and universal surveillance, violent acts are practically impossible. This lack of consequences, as was the case in Down and Out and in the Magic Kingdom by Cory Doctorow, makes many of the confrontations among characters quite dull.

On the positive side, there is a clear evolution in Reynolds's prose. Despite being quite a hefty tome, Blue Remembered Earth is a quick read. In fact, the mid part of the novel is really fun and works very well as a light-hearted space adventure. The ending, although fairly predictable, is closed enough and the novel can be read as a stand-alone but everything (including a quick removal of some superfluous elements) is set in place for the next installment in the Poseidon's Children trilogy.

Blue Remembered Earth is not a bad novel by any means, but it is not a typical example of the work of Alastair Reynolds. Perhaps his most similar book is Terminal World, which was more focused on characters and plot than on heavy world-building, but Terminal World is a more fun, intriguing and balanced novel than Blue Remembered Earth.
1 like · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Blue Remembered Earth.
sign in »

Reading Progress

01/19/2012
10.0% 6 comments
01/23/2012
59.0% "#BRE #cifituits Much more interesting now"
01/25/2012
78.0% "#BRE #cifituits"
show 4 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Justin Not as good as you'd hoped?


message 2: by Odo (new) - rated it 3 stars

Odo Sadly, no. I always have high expectations with Reynolds. Not a bad novel, but not up to his usual standards, imho.


back to top