Jessica's Reviews > Persepolis 2: The Story of a Return

Persepolis 2 by Marjane Satrapi
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
97631
's review
Sep 30, 14

bookshelves: graphic-novel
Read in June, 2008

** spoiler alert ** Persepolis the First was touching. Persepolis the Second was not. The teen-aged Marjane is sent to Vienna where she is bounced from place to place by both circumstance and her own big mouth. Marjane, abandoned and isolated, turns to drugs and questionable friends and lovers to get through this time. Though she is apparently bright, she barely gets through school. After she catches her boyfriend cheating on her, she spends three months on the street and then returns to Iran. Once in Iran, it really gets jolly and fun. Marjane is depressed. She attempts suicide. There are some ups, but a lot of downs. I won’t list them all and spoil it for everyone else, but REALLY!

All of this bad, sad, and terrible stuff is going on, and I didn’t feel anything. Nothing. Maybe it’s because a lot of the sadness was caused by her own actions. (It should be noted that I generally have a low tolerance for stupid teenagers.) Maybe it’s because it was told in a detached way. Maybe it’s because I’m heartless. In any case, it didn’t feel personal. It didn’t feel as though the events in the book happened to the author. I didn’t relate to Marjane, and I didn’t sympathize with her. Also, the graphic element in this book didn’t really add anything for me. I don’t know. This book just left me cold.

A couple things did work for me, though. Marjane turns to reading at lonely times in her life, and remarks that “one must educate oneself.” True. True. One other item rang true to me: when Marjane gets to Austria, one of her first purchases was scented laundry detergent. It wasn’t available in war-torn Iran. She mentions that even today she keeps a dozen or so boxes of scented detergent in her house.

I wish there had been a few more of those personal moments in the book.
19 likes · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Persepolis 2.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Adrianna I agree with your review - I was really disappointed by Persepolis 2 because I loooooved the first one. Persepolis 2 seemed too verbose and melodramatic. I don't think she did too great of a job describing the prejudices she faced as an Iranian in Austria and "European" in Iran. Like you said, she did run her mouth too much and it really disturbed me when she got the one guy arrested while she was worried she'd get in trouble for wearing make up.


message 2: by Dan (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dan Hey how about a spoiler alert?


Jessica Good call. I did hide this with the spoiler option.


message 4: by Rusalochka (new)

Rusalochka (a.k.a Zashen) While I agree that this part wasn't my favorite as the first part was, I need to say that it IS relatable if you are a person who has moved to a different country with different customs. I am not sure about your experiences, but I can tell you from mine and my family's, these events ARE believable AND relatable.


back to top