I really was happy when I got my hands on this book early. Lost Voices was pretty good and I thought this book was even better. I enjoyed reading about how Luce was very independent yet caring about her fellow mermaids and humans. The story brings together her life, love, and even hurt that she must struggle through to survive. The only part that I believed lagged on a bit was later in the book when she got swept away in the winter and ended up at the island. I won't go into detail because I don't want to spoil the story, but overall I thought the book was very well written and satisfying. Can't wait to read the 3rd book to see the climactic conclusion. If you love mermaids and a good love/hate story then this book is for you.