Shannon (Giraffe Days)'s Reviews > The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency

The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency by Alexander McCall Smith

by
395599
's review
Dec 29, 08

bookshelves: 2008, favourite, mystery-suspense
Read in December, 2008

I'm no fan of mystery, crime or detective books - the bore me, generally, though I loved Kerry Greenwood's Phryne Fisher books in high school and Agatha Christie's Ten Little Niggers gave me chills (since renamed And Then There Were None, for obvious reasons - but I've got an old edition).

The No.1 Ladies' Detective Agency is a real gem, however. I absolutely loved it. Wise, funny, intelligent, insightful and blushing with vigour and a heartfelt love of Africa, I'm not in the least surprised this series - of which this is the first book - has done so well.

Set in Botswana, it features thirty-five year old Mma Ramotswe, a cunning, content and large (in the "traditional" way) woman who, after her father dies leaving her many head of cattle, sells up and opens a detective agency. Hired to track missing husbands, cheating husbands and thieving husbands, as well as daughters, sons and witch doctors, Precious Ramostwe has her hands full. Woven amongst the cases are beautiful descriptions of the land, insights into African culture in all its myriad forms, the life of her father, a miner in South Africa, and her own disastrous marriage which ended many years ago, and a sweet offer of love from one of her best friends, a successful mechanic.

What is especially intriguing about this book, for me, is its seemingly chaotic structure. It follows no neat format, employs chapters within chapters, retells the past without incorporating it into the plot, shifts perspective between characters (though Mma Ramotswe has the focal perspective) whenever desired, and could sometimes be mistaken for short stories. And it all works, superbly so. It's new and refreshing and extremely well written, every word and sentence and paragraph there for a reason, the small plotlines and overarching plot spun out with perfect timing and deft handling. It is serious and wise and thoughtful when it needs to be, and light and ironic at other times. I kept thinking "this'd make a great tv show!" only to find that the BBC have already jumped on that bandwagon - shame it hasn't made it to Canada.

Mma Ramotswe is a fantastic protagonist, a woman who stands up for herself and loves Africa despite its problems. I'm always interested in reading books set in Africa - the continent fascinates and intrigues me, its beauty draws me, and its the closest place to Australia, in terms of landscape and climate, that there is, which makes me feel like it's a kindred spirit. There are many places there that I would love to visit.

I could go on for ages highlighting all the great things in this book - I have absolutely nothing negative to say or complain about, and it was wonderful to read a book with proper English spelling intact (except, at one point, the word "humour", which was very odd). The proof-readers should be careful about looking for wrong dialogue punctuation though - end quotation marks before a paragraph break within someone's speech. I'm seeing it occur in almost all the books I've been reading lately, it's very shoddy.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-15 of 15) (15 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lee (new) - added it

Lee Thanks for the great review Shannon. I've been wondering about the appeal of these books.


Shannon (Giraffe Days) I honestly didn't think it'd be as good as people raved about - but it really was!


message 3: by Wendy (last edited Dec 30, 2008 11:46am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Wendy I have read the entire series and recommend it heartily.
One of my favorite phrases, used by the author to describe Mma Ramotswe: "a traditionally built woman"


message 4: by Lee (new) - added it

Lee Okay, you've convinced me. I'm going to give the first one a try.


message 5: by Barbara (last edited Dec 30, 2008 03:03pm) (new)

Barbara This is another great one to do with an audiobook. Recorded Books does an excellent production with Lisette LeCat as the narrator.


message 6: by Lee (new) - added it

Lee Great idea Barbara! i'll see if I can get it in audio.


Shannon (Giraffe Days) Oh yes! thanks Barbara, you're right, they'd be perfect as audiobooks!


Charly I found this book a clever twist on the crime and mystery theme and it was very entertaining. I think I picked it up because so many had read it on Good Reads.

Thanks for the always insightful review Shannion


AnJilleen Agatha Christies book was called Ten Little Indians first.


Wendy AnJilleen..

It was published in 1939 under the title Ten Little Niggers, which came from a nursery rhyme of the same name. The title eventually was changed to Ten Little Indians, then to And Then There Were None.
I know. Its hard to believe !


Shannon (Giraffe Days) It's interesting, tracing public perception and social politics through a changing book title! Thanks for the info Wendy :)


message 12: by Dawn (new)

Dawn Great review, thanks! I've enjoyed the No. 1 Detective Agency books, but I loved your analysis. You put it so well. I think the first one is still my favorite.


Shannon (Giraffe Days) Dawn wrote: "Great review, thanks! I've enjoyed the No. 1 Detective Agency books, but I loved your analysis. You put it so well. I think the first one is still my favorite."

Thanks Dawn :) I have two more on my shelf but I haven't got around to reading them yet. I found and loved a similar style book, Baking Cakes in Kigali which I highly recommend if you haven't already come across it. It's set in Rwanda after the genocide and the female lead isn't a detective but she becomes involved in lots of people's stories and helps them, so it's almost like she was! Have you heard of it?


message 14: by Dawn (new)

Dawn Shannon wrote: "Dawn wrote: "Great review, thanks! I've enjoyed the No. 1 Detective Agency books, but I loved your analysis. You put it so well. I think the first one is still my favorite."

Thanks Dawn :) I ha..."



No, but I'll have to check it out. Thanks!


Silentdreamer I read your review after reading the book :) I agree with your assessment! :)

I now like it a lot that I went to the library and borrowed the next 4 books in the series!

I did notice (same as you) the punctuation errors and got me confused in some parts!


back to top