Jon's Reviews > The Lord of the Rings Movie Tie-in 2003 Boxed Set

The Lord of the Rings Movie Tie-in 2003 Boxed Set by J.R.R. Tolkien
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
160267
's review
Jun 29, 07

Recommended for: Everyone
Read in January, 1985

LOTR has its faults, yes: it can be excessively descriptive; female characters (even the important ones) aren't as fully fleshed-out and realized as male characters (Arwen spends most of the books making a flag); Gandalf annoyingly and constantly points out how everyone else's decisions are wrong; the refusal to interweave chapter-by-chapter the stories of Frodo & Sam with the stories of everyone else results in literally hundreds of pages going by without mention of the majority of the main players' names; the Tom Bombadil section (as much as I like it) has literally nothing to do with the last four-fifths of the trilogy (yes, I realize it's actually a hexalogy, but most people haven't the slightest clue what that means); and I could probably go on for quite some time.

Why, then, do I give this book five stars? Quite simply, it's perhaps the single most read, reviewed, and revered fantasy novel since the genre was invented. The list of authors who have been directly influenced by LOTR would stretch longer than the space given me in this text box, and it's virtually impossible to publish any novel of high fantasy in the modern era without being compared to Tolkien (try it: just go to your local bookstore and start plucking books off the shelf in the Fantasy section--I'll bet you a dollar that within thirty seconds you'll find one with a review that compares it to LOTR). Plus, it's one of the few books (I purposely group them together here for purposes of simplification--plus, my copy has all six books plus appendices in one massive paperback-bound edition) that I've read more than ten times, and every time I read it, I enjoy it more than the last. For all of its faults, I wouldn't change a word of it.
11 likes · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Lord of the Rings Movie Tie-in 2003 Boxed Set.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Barbara Weber Great review. I apprecitate the thought and clarity reflected in your review.




Bobby Mitchell hexology- six books.


back to top