Charity Kountz's Reviews > Red Mist
Red Mist (Kay Scarpetta, #19)
by Patricia Cornwell (Goodreads Author)
by Patricia Cornwell (Goodreads Author)
I have been a longtime fan of Patricia Cornwell's work, particularly her heroine Kay Scarpetta. The series depicted her as a strong, capable, confident, and committed to a work few people would be willing to do. Her commitment was admirable. However, in this book, this characterization has begun to unravel at the seams.
For some reason I cannot quite understand, Cornwell has changed Scarpetta from a focused scientist to a self-absorbed, unconfident, vindictive and paranoid character who is extremely difficult to enjoy. Even worse, Lucy's character has become a rogue "hacker" who does whatever she wants, whenever she wants, regardless of the law or who it might hurt. Marino has been reduced into a self-doubting former cop experiencing a mid-life crisis. Benton, when he appears is simply a prop for Scarpetta which Cornwell uses liberally to wax poetic about various topics to the reader.
The antagonists in the books are barely seen or considered. Usually you have a clear dislike for the bad guys but in this novel the bad guys are so convoluted it's hard to know which ones to hate so you end up simply feeling sorry for Scarpetta.
That being said, there are some redeeming qualities for the book. If you are a big fan of the characters you'll likely be satisfied by the story. There is some intrigue and suspense as Scarpetta works to solve three murders.
Not a significant amount of forensic science in this book but a heavier dose of mystery and detective work. The science seems forced and throws around industry terms and new technology without any substance behind it.
All in all, I have given this a generous three stars mainly because die hard fan will enjoy this addition to the series, it was entertaining on a basic level, and I don't regret reading it. I was disappointed that the story wasn't better but it was mildly satisfying.
For some reason I cannot quite understand, Cornwell has changed Scarpetta from a focused scientist to a self-absorbed, unconfident, vindictive and paranoid character who is extremely difficult to enjoy. Even worse, Lucy's character has become a rogue "hacker" who does whatever she wants, whenever she wants, regardless of the law or who it might hurt. Marino has been reduced into a self-doubting former cop experiencing a mid-life crisis. Benton, when he appears is simply a prop for Scarpetta which Cornwell uses liberally to wax poetic about various topics to the reader.
The antagonists in the books are barely seen or considered. Usually you have a clear dislike for the bad guys but in this novel the bad guys are so convoluted it's hard to know which ones to hate so you end up simply feeling sorry for Scarpetta.
That being said, there are some redeeming qualities for the book. If you are a big fan of the characters you'll likely be satisfied by the story. There is some intrigue and suspense as Scarpetta works to solve three murders.
Not a significant amount of forensic science in this book but a heavier dose of mystery and detective work. The science seems forced and throws around industry terms and new technology without any substance behind it.
All in all, I have given this a generous three stars mainly because die hard fan will enjoy this addition to the series, it was entertaining on a basic level, and I don't regret reading it. I was disappointed that the story wasn't better but it was mildly satisfying.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Red Mist.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 12/28/2011 | page 245 |
|
48.0% |
Comments (showing 1-9 of 9) (9 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Gayle
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
01. Januar, 22:05 Uhr
Although I did ejoy reading the latest, I agree with Michelle . I'm hoping that this "ending" brings our crew of characters back to the science.
reply
|
flag
*
So glad to hear it wasn't just me! I would hate to be a "book snob" lol. I believe in entertainment value books as much as more serious literature but sometimes we authors stray a little.
I too have felt this way for the last few books. Am on page 139 but I get tired of hearing how the secondary characters are all trying to hide stuff for Scarpetta's "Own good"
You read my mind! I was just sitting down to write a review, but you wrote exactly what I was going to! Glad to see I'm not the only one who feels she is going downhill.
Yes, I too, have been taken aback by how bitter and paranoid Kay has become -- makes me wonder why everyone so admires her -- especially her husband, who also seems like a cold fish.
I am a big fan of Cornwell's Kay Scarpetta series, but as I followed all her books, every new one its just seems like she slaughtered the characters.I couldnt agreed more about your opinion on how Cornwell turn all her characters into annoying and egoistic idiots.
I have not yet read this latest book but I agree with your comments. The novels seem to struggle with the inner problems of the main characters more than with the traditional Cornwell story of solving the mystery with science and detective work. I will likely buy and rad it though as I am a sucker for these novels despite each of the main characters having gone from great to characters struggling just to get through life despite all their psychological problems.
You said almost exactly what I did in my review. Glad to see I'm not alone in my disappointment with Cornwall.
