Lady Jaye's Reviews > Dead Witch Walking

Dead Witch Walking by Kim Harrison

by
4507434
Er...ok. So this is not going to be a complimentary review, as you've probably already guessed by the rating.

I am a character-driven reader. I don't necessarily have to love a character to bits, but if I can get behind him/her, then I will come along for the ride, and be willing to overlook a lot of things, like faulty plotting. If I don't like the character, well, then I enjoy the book less, and become somewhat cranky. I notice choppy plotting/not-very-good writing.

I am not a plot-driven reader, but sometimes, really good storytelling will keep me interested even when I dislike the characters.

This book failed on both fronts. I wanted to slap Rachel, the main character, almost from the beginning, and was praying someone would shoot her dead and put me out of my misery. I didn't see much likeable/ interesting/ redeemable about her. She was not intelligent - and since every other person was dumber than she was, it made for a rather stupid cast of characters. The secondary characters were also boring and annoying in turns.

Um... the story. It was published in 2004, (I'm guessing) in the infancy of UF. I don't know if it would have been considered cutting edge/excellent in it's time, but now that the genre has taken off, it is just bad prose and bad plotting.

And bad editing/copy-editing. There were some glaring errors I caught several times.

I do not think I will be reading more of the books in this series; it's not for me. I might try other books Kim Harrison has written, but probably later.

I don't recommend this one.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Dead Witch Walking.
sign in »

Reading Progress

02/27/2012
3.0%
02/29/2012
8.0% "Slooow going"
show 1 hidden update…

Comments (showing 1-19 of 19) (19 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tara (new)

Tara that bad, huh??


Lady Jaye I didn't like it at all.


Hbeebti I had bought almost all the books thinking that I would enjoy them. I think I had 1-6 or 8, IDK.. Anyway I didnt enjoy the series myself. I just struggled with the characters. Maybe later I might try again but at this point nope.


Lady Jaye Oh no! I hate it when that happens!


message 5: by Dee (new) - rated it 1 star

Dee I didn't like this one either in fact I couldn't even finish it (which is very rare for me not to finish a book) and I only gave it 1 star....will be honest and say it put me off reading this author :(


Lady Jaye I continued because I read it for a challenge, Dee. :/
Did you ever try any more books by her?


message 7: by Dee (new) - rated it 1 star

Dee no I couldn't bring myself to try anything else of her's again. I know some really like her books but this one really put me off.


Hbeebti Thank goodness Im not the only one. lol... Thankfully I took the books to a used book store and got credit for them , so that I could get something else.


message 9: by Dee (new) - rated it 1 star

Dee Hbeebti wrote: "Thank goodness Im not the only one. lol... Thankfully I took the books to a used book store and got credit for them , so that I could get something else."

That's lucky....I do hate spending my hard earned money and books that I don't end up reading!


message 10: by Lisa Kay (last edited 3 de Mar 06:34) (new) - added it

Lisa Kay Lady Jaye wrote: "She was not intelligent - and since every other person was dumber than she was, it made for a rather stupid cast of characters."

LMAO! Okay, I'll stay away. Loved your review, Lady Jaye!


Lady Jaye Thanks, LK :)


message 12: by Regina (new) - rated it 2 stars

Regina LJ I gave it a similar rating -- I think my review was something like - thank god this is over.


Lady Jaye Lol. I saw. I agree wholeheartedly. It truly was a relief to finally finish and not have to go back!


message 14: by D.G. (new) - rated it 1 star

D.G. Totally agree with you on this one, LJ.


message 15: by Maya (new) - rated it 1 star

Maya I am reading this one and the beginning is starting to get on my nerves -.- It's just too slow...


message 16: by Shari (new) - rated it 3 stars

Shari  Stacy I just finished the first book, and I think Rachel is dumber than Stephanie Plum, which is saying something. Yet this is not supposed to be farce as the Evanovich novels are. I sure like Mr. and Mrs. Jinx though..


message 17: by Lady Jaye (new) - rated it 2 stars

Lady Jaye Shari wrote: "I just finished the first book, and I think Rachel is dumber than Stephanie Plum, which is saying something. Yet this is not supposed to be farce as the Evanovich novels are...."

Hahaha!


message 18: by BamaGal (new)

BamaGal  Good review. This one has been on the tbr pile forever, I think now I'll just leave it there...


message 19: by Lady Jaye (new) - rated it 2 stars

Lady Jaye BamaGal wrote: "Good review. This one has been on the tbr pile forever, I think now I'll just leave it there..."

You're welcome :D


back to top