Kat Hooper's Reviews > Dream Castles: The Early Jack Vance, Vol 2

Dream Castles by Jack Vance
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2177891
's review
Feb 29, 12

Read from December 12, 2011 to February 12, 2012

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT Fantasy Literature.

Jack Vance is my favorite author, so another collection of Vance's works by Subterranean Press is a welcome treat! Dream Castles: The Early Jack Vance Volume Two, edited and lovingly introduced by Terry Dowling and Jonathan Strahan, collects ten of Vance's works:

"The Dogtown Tourist Agency" (originally published in Epoch, 1975) -- Miro Hetzel, a private investigator whose "fees are calculated subjectively," goes to the planet Maz to discover how a client's competition is creating a better but less expensive product. While there, he gets caught up in the doings of a couple of strange alien cultures.

"Freitzke's Turn" (Triax: Three Original Novellas, 1977) -- Another Miro Hetzel SF mystery set in the Gaean Reach. This time Miro must track down the outrageously pompous villain Dr. Faurence Dacre, who got revenge on the man who married his girlfriend by... oh, I can't tell you. It's just so wonderfully hilarious that you must find out for yourself.

"Dream Castle" (Astounding Science Fiction, 1974) -- After getting fired because he tried to save his clients money, a builder starts his own company and decides to steal his former employer's customers by offering them something even better.

"Golden Girl" (Marvel Science Stories, 1951) -- This is a sad story about the loneliness of exile. Like Robinson Crusoe, but with an alien as the protagonist.

"Sulwen's Planet" (The Farthest Reaches, 1968) -- Two distinguished and arrogant linguists fight over the discoveries to be found on crashed alien spaceships.

"Cholwell's Chickens" (Thrilling wonder Stories, 1952) -- A bored rich young woman who was abandoned in a tavern on a far-off planet decides to go back and find out who her parents were. After a few days of investigation, she discovers that she does indeed have some family, but they're not anything like what she was expecting. This was a bizarre little story with some fun twists, and one of my favorites in the collection. Most of Vance's protagonists are men, so a female is a nice change of pace in this story.

"A Practical Man's Guide" (Space Science Fiction Magazine, 1957) -- Ralph Banks is a practical man who edits a practical magazine. He's very good at sorting through all the letters he gets and sifting out the crackpots' ideas. But he just can't help but try out the latest one that crosses his desk. "A Practical Man's Guide" is short and amusing.

"The Narrow Land" (Fantastic Science Fiction Fantasy, 1967) -- Here Vance develops a strange world with an amphibious alien race. This is the story of how the alien Ern become conscious, fights to survive in the world he was born into, discovers the history of his race, and plans for its future. Really nice world-building.

"The Enchanted Princess" (Orbit Science Fiction, 1954) -- A film producer becomes obsessed with the vibrant princess he sees in a movie and the blind girl at he meets at a children's clinic. Could they be the same person? I liked the ideas in this story.

"Son of the Tree" (Thrilling Wonder Stories, 1951) -- Joe Smith is working his way across the universe in search of the man who his girlfriend is obsessed with. As he's closing in on him, he gets stuck on a planet of peaceful Druids who worship a very big tree. Things get funny when the Druids try to export their culture to a neighboring planet of warriors.

Each of these stories feels very much like Jack Vance -- clever and competent protagonists, bizarre alien races, sparse and witty dialogue, a lofty but frugal writing style. I enjoyed most of them for this reason.

If you're new to Jack Vance, Dream Castles isn't a bad place to start, but it isn't the best place either. These stories are entertaining, but they hardly begin to reach the heights that Vance can attain. It's like starting off for the top of the mountain and deciding to stop halfway up. This isn't Jack Vance's best work, but even so, mediocre Vance is something to be admired. Fans who don't own these stories in another collection will definitely want to read these. The best ones are "Freitzke's Turn," "Cholwell's Chickens," "The Enchanted Princess" and "Son of the Tree."
4 likes · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Dream Castles.
sign in »

Reading Progress

12/29/2011 page 177
48.0%
show 3 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-6 of 6) (6 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Mohammed I pre-ordered this few days ago from local bookstore. Its a given for JV fans like you and me. I have read Miro Hetzel in Galactic Effacuator but the other stories are new to me. Im glad they went for his SFF stories and not another mystery collection. Vance greatness is not the early mystery writer.


Kat  Hooper I have a couple of his mystery collections, but haven't read them.

I hope you like this, Mohammed!


Mohammed Kat wrote: "I have a couple of his mystery collections, but haven't read them.

I hope you like this, Mohammed!"


I have Dangerous Ways mystery collection that i bought when it was new last year. Havent read it yet.

I will read this book instantly when i get it. I have yet to read a Vance story i disliked even if his earliest 40s,50s SF short stories is weaker than his mature ones.


Mohammed I just finished this and i agree with you completely Those stories that you thought were the best ones. I found The Narrow Land interestibg but i found th start to be weak.


message 5: by Kat (last edited Sep 06, 2012 08:14PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kat  Hooper I'm glad we're in agreement, Mohammed! That's cool!

BTW, Jack Vance's family is producing his novels in ebook format. You can find them at www.JackVance.com.


Mohammed Kat wrote: "I'm glad we're in agreement, Mohammed! That's cool!

BTW, Jack Vance's family is producing his novels in ebook format. You can find them at www.JackVance.com."



What was your thoughts about Son of the tree i wonder? It was an early but very later,mature Vance style. Comptent hero, alien like human cultures. The Druids i thought was interesting in that they were similar to political religion countries where the masses are controlled with their faith. Little tyranny,very Orwellian.

Only bad thing about this collection was i had read the two Miro Hetzel stories before and so i read only 8 of the stories in the collection as new reads:P


back to top