I LOVED this book! It was such a fun read for me! I only read it in a couple of hours and it was a cute little story! I loved the characters especially Collin and Elizabeth! Addison, Nathan and Miche were also great people! Nathan was such an interesting person with an awful past! And I didn't expect to like him so much! Something else that was fun for me was that most of it took place in Murray, and I live like 1 block from where all the action occurred! My friend lives on Walden where Addison lived! I loved it! I also love that the author is LDS. One thing I didn't really like was that I read it at this time of year expecting to read a Christmas story and it wasn't really a Christmas story. It actually only mentioned Christmas a couple of times. It is kind of explained at the end but still the cover and stuff was misleading. One other thing i didnt really like was that before each chapter there was a passage from Nathan's diary and it gave away what was going to happen in the chapter! I found it annoying. But this was a GREAT story and I would recommend it to all!