mark monday's Reviews > Catching Fire

Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins

by
131922
and now let's play the wildly popular RPG

ADVANCED HUNGER & GAMES 2.0: CATCHING FIRE EDITION

Our Players

Katniss

Photobucket

HIT POINTS: 25
ALIGNMENT: Chaotic Good
SYMBOL: Middle Finger
STRENGTH: 15
INTELLIGENCE: 10
WISDOM: 5
DEXTERITY: 20
CONSTITUTION: 15
CHARISMA: 25
FIGHTER: 10th Level Archer
ASSASSIN: 9th Level Assassin
SPECIAL ATTACKS: Resentful Attitude
SPECIAL DEFENSES: Defensive Attitude

SUMMARY OF PLAYER SKILLS:

despite the inherent restrictions of living in a YA novel, Katniss is a remarkably well-developed and complex character. although she's drawn from the familiar tough girl/outsider/square peg template, Collins resists softening her - her temper, her understandable but often misdirected suspiciousness, her frequent inability to empathize with others are never underplayed. her appearance at the end, where she appears to be slipping into depressive, semi-crazy, unreasoning mulishness, is very well-done and psychologically astute.

i also love how her strengths are so nonchalantly illustrated - she is something special, but never a superwoman. her character's changes and growth and weaknesses and skills are carefully gradual and feel real - the reader is made to truly understand her, all of her. two sequences in Catching Fire particularly impressed me. the first one comes almost mid-way: Katniss' slow, painful revelation about the nature of oppression and the need for revolution, at one point moving from fear for her sister's safety and potential death if revolution occurs to understanding of her sister's life as a kind of living death already, if revolution does not occur. a great example of realistic character development that highlights Collins' sophisticated yet pleasingly transparent and straightforward writing style.
_________________________

Gale

Photobucket

HIT POINTS: 15
ALIGNMENT: Chaotic Good
SYMBOL: Pouty Scowl
STRENGTH: 20
INTELLIGENCE: 15
WISDOM: 5
DEXTERITY: 15
CONSTITUTION: 10
CHARISMA: 20
FIGHTER: 9th Level Ranger
SPECIAL ATTACKS: Che Guevera Eyes
SPECIAL DEFENSES: Come Hither Eyes

SUMMARY OF GAME STRUCTURE:

i love how Gale’s appearances bookend the first two novels. it is an elegant way to illustrate this character’s importance to both Katniss and the narrative itself – Gale sees two different kinds of Katniss in each novel; his reactions to her are different as well, and despite his own somewhat static characterization, it is through Gale that the reader is able to truly mark Katniss’ changes in status and mind and spirit. even better, by saving him for the beginning and end, he gets put out of the way for the duration of most of each novel’s action. although Katniss wastes a rather inordinate amount of time obsessing over him for a good portion of both novels, once she’s in the arena, time spent mooning over her backwoods boyfriend is happily curtailed. i really like how Collins divides the time Katniss spends on each of her love interests; the romantic elements of the novel are as sharply structured as the novel itself, with its neat division into (1) the tour of districts and the burgeoning of revolution, (2) back home in District 12 and accepting the need for action (or, perhaps, flight), and (3) the game itself.

just a few words for the game itself: AWESOME AWESOME AWESOME. the game that takes up much of the final third of the novel is my other favorite thing in Catching Fire. the tension and danger, the pacing, the confusion of who should trust who and what did that person mean when they said that, the puzzle of what is happening in each deadly and differentiated section, the clock-like structure of the arena, and the immense difference between this game and the game depicted in Hunger Games... awesome! almost as awesome: the interview with the contestants, Katniss & Peeta's new look, Cinna's rebellion. really, i could go on and on.
_________________________

Peeta

Photobucket

HIT POINTS: 15
ALIGNMENT: Lawful Good
SYMBOL: Big Spoon
STRENGTH: 15
INTELLIGENCE: 20
WISDOM: 15
DEXTERITY: 5
CONSTITUTION: 10
CHARISMA: 20
FIGHTER: 9th Level Bread Baker
BARD: 10th Level Public Speaker
SPECIAL ATTACKS: Debilitating Guilt-Trip
SPECIAL DEFENSES: He Actually Loves You

SUMMARY OF GAME PLATFORM:

i don't know how popular the character of Peeta is, probably because i am far from being a young adult - but i think his characterization is another wonderful achievement. it is not such an easy task to make A Good Person and Voice of Your Conscience without turning that character into a two-dimensional Marty Stu. Collins is able to accomplish this with ease (and this is a character whose every other line is practically I Love You Katniss), in scenes where mawkish sentimentality and eye-rolling cliché are conspicuously, happily absent. her handling of Peeta's character is a hallmark of Collins' overall success. she writes of a dire world, one full of death and despair and undying love and family tragedy and trials & tribulations both romantic and violent. and she does it in way that is clean, polished, graceful, direct, and terrifically moving.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Catching Fire.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-28 of 28) (28 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Stephanie (new) - added it

Stephanie I just got my copy of this yesterday. I haven't read the first one yet in the series. But I will soon. I can't wait!


Stephen Great idea for this review, Mark. Love it.


mark monday Stephanie, read it! read it soon!

thanks Stephen. you should steal my idea for one of your own reviews. i'm sure i've stolen many of yours, so it'll just be payback!


Stephen Thanks, I may just take you up on that.


message 5: by Stephanie (new) - added it

Stephanie It's on my Janurary TBR list. I can't wait to talk about it.


message 6: by K. (new) - rated it 4 stars

K. Haha, I made the same joke with Gale and Peeta's names, except I did Oprah's BFF instead of weather.


message 7: by Kay (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kay LOL, Mark! Very apt review, especially your analysis of Gale's function in the novel. Other than being the foil to Peeta's constant change and evolution (which I think is clearly illustrated just by Collins's characterization alone), as well as the third side of the love triangle, Gale's purpose in the novel and how his character adds substance to the story is something I've yet to determine. To me, he pales in comparison to Haymitch and Cinna.


mark monday i agree, Gale's characterization pales in comparison to Katniss & Peeta, and even supporting characters like Haymitch & Cinna. right now i am seeing him purely as an interesting plot device; my sympathies are entirely with Peeta.

but i am hoping that the third novel will allow him to grown into his character and become a lot more interesting. i guess i'll find out!


Eileen Very creative review, Mark! I've read all three books, can't wait to see how you feel about the ending.


message 10: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday thanks Eileen! i may have to move my timetable up in reading Mockingjay - i usually wait many months in between books when reading series. i first read Hunger Games last year and just read Catching Fire. not sure if i can wait til next summer to read Mockingjay!


message 11: by Robert (new)

Robert Delikat Wow, outstanding, Mark. I enjoyed your review more than my entry into the series. I am not a HG fanboy. When looking for new reads, I use other Goodreaders' reviews and rankings of HG as one of my acid tests for whether or not I buy into their reviews of other books. They like and rank HG highly, I look askance at their other highly rated choices. It's maybe dumb, I know. However, I have run controlled experiments and it has worked for me most of the time [insert smiley face here]. Your intelligent review has renewed my interest and I just might have to read book II.
PS, no review will EVER get me to read another Stephenie Meyer.


message 12: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday thank you Robert.

and i am very happy to support your lifelong ban on Stephenie Meyer!


message 13: by Mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

Mark Have just read this one Mark and you capture it beautifully


message 14: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday thanks! i'm looking forward to reading what you think about it. just read your nice review of Hunger Games.


message 15: by Mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

Mark Cheers. have just put it up


message 16: by Kat (new)

Kat Lowe Hello Kitty??? (heh-heh)


message 17: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday Hello Katniss!


message 18: by Alex (new) - rated it 3 stars

Alex the D&D stats cracked me up lol.


message 19: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday glad you enjoyed it!


Kasia S. Every single one of your reviews is a masterpiece!!


message 21: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday wow, thank you! that is an awesome thing to read. much appreciated!


Ronyell Awesome review!!!


message 23: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday thanks Ronyell!


Ronyell You're welcome!


message 25: by Steve (new)

Steve Mark, I just finished the first one, and I loved it. Katniss is such a great character. This review is wonderful. What a great idea.


message 26: by mark (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday thanks Steve, glad you enjoyed it!


message 27: by Dan (new) - rated it 3 stars

Dan Schwent The hit point totals seem low to me


message 28: by mark (last edited Nov 14, 2012 11:10am) (new) - rated it 4 stars

mark monday now keep in mind that this is coming from a person who has only played d&d once when he was 12 (although i did pore over the monster manual about a thousand times)... but i thought the max was 25 hit points? and so Katniss actually gets the max.


back to top