Jeffrey Keeten's Reviews > The Prague Cemetery

The Prague Cemetery by Umberto Eco

by
3427339
's review
Jun 09, 12

Read from November 23 to December 17, 2011

In the 1980s I read The Name of the Rose and Foucault's Pendulum and came away from those books knowing that I had been exposed to a brilliant mind. The complexity of the writing and the layers of plot turned many readers away, but I found it so refreshing to have a writer that demanded more from his readers and more importantly had faith in his readership. These are books that need to be read many times and each time the reader will develop a better understanding of the writer's intentions.

Photobucket

This brings me to The Prague Cemetery. Typical of an Eco book it took me a little while to settle in and fine tune my thoughts to pay proper attention and to relax so that Eco could take me where he wanted me to go. This book is set in 19th century Europe and explores the underlying conspiracies that surround a series of wars/conflicts that instead of being the work of a group is the nefarious dealings of one man. This man is Simone Simonini. He is a murderer, double agent, triple agent, but more importantly he is the man that can provide the documentation that proves that one side of a conflict is justified in their quest for power. In other words he is a master forger.

He finds his calling while apprenticed to a lawyer named Rebaudengo. He learns the fine art of providing the "missing" paperwork for a baptismal record that would allow an inheritance to be obtained or the "missing" will of a family patriarch who may have perished unexpectedly.

Rebaudengo explained. "What I produce are not forgeries but new copies of genuine documents that have been lost or, by simple oversight, have never been produced, and that could and should have been produced."

Simone becomes so good at the craft that he realizes that the only person between him and a very lucrative income is his mentor Rebaudengo. The proper paperwork miraculously is produced that exposes a "fraud" perpetrated by Rebaudengo and he is swiftly convicted and sent to prison.

Simone is the type of gentleman that governments find uses for and he is greedy enough not to be worried about the consequences of his actions. He becomes a forger, mercenary for hire. He provides documents that fan the flames of racism and cultism that leads to genocide and in one case the temporary toppling of a foreign government. He steals from his employers and from his agents working both sides of the equation to net as much money as possible for himself. He is a man without a moral compass except in the case of Abbe Dalla Piccola. Piccola became an inconvenience for Simone during one of his clandestine missions and Simone as he tended to do when cleaning up a problem, killed him. Simone becomes, unknowingly to himself, so out of sorts over the murder of Piccola that Piccola is actually resurrected in his own mind creating for a time a split personality. Simone becomes more aware of the Abbe as they begin sharing a diary and the missing time that Simone is experience is revealed in the dairy entries made by the Piccola personality.

The book is liberally sprinkled with sketches of the characters involved really evoking a Victorian Dickens feel to the novel. I found this book much more accessible than other Eco novels and actually laughed out loud a couple of times.

Back in 2000 I had planned to meet Umberto Eco. He was touring for Baudolino and was planning to come to the West Coast. Unfortunately due to health reasons he only finished his East Coast engagements and did not come to California. I had spent my last lira appropriating a copy of The Name of the Rose for him to sign, which now would be worth around $800 signed by the author. Well I may not have an $800 copy, but I am still glad that I bought Rose when I did, as even unsigned, The Name of the Rose is going for a couple of hundred dollars. I did pick up a copy of Baudolino from an East Coast bookseller flat signed by Mr. Eco.


BaudolinobyUmbertoEco


Flat signed is preferred by collectors because the book was actually in the hands of the author. A book plate, signed by the author, does not have the same value to collectors.












Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Prague Cemetery.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-17 of 17) (17 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Stephen (new) - added it

Stephen Great review, Jeffrey. I am looking forward to this one.


Jeffrey Keeten Thanks Stephen, the book is creating some controversy. I found the book tongue and cheek and obviously the intention was to show the most ridiculous things that people believe and yet with disastrous consequences.


message 3: by Stephen (new) - added it

Stephen The Name of the Rose is an all time favorite of mine and yet it is the only Eco I have read to date. Sad, I know. Which book would you recommend first, Foucault's Pendulum or this one? I have both.


Jeffrey Keeten Prague is a lighter read. Foucault will be more difficult, but ultimately more rewarding.


Jeffrey Keeten Prague is a lighter read. Foucault will be more difficult, but ultimately more rewarding.


message 6: by Stephen (new) - added it

Stephen Jeffrey wrote: "Prague is a lighter read. Foucault will be more difficult, but ultimately more rewarding."

Exactly the kind of guidance I was looking for. Thanks, Jeffrey.


message 7: by Hend (new) - added it

Hend U have read a lot of amazing books!!


Jeffrey Keeten Hend wrote: "U have read a lot of amazing books!!"

Thanks Hend. I hope to read many, many more.


message 9: by Hend (new) - added it

Hend :)
Me TOO...


message 10: by Traveller (new) - added it

Traveller Mmm, I wonder why his apparent pre-occupation with 'conspiracies'. Or haven't I read enough of his work yet? I recently picked up his The Island of the Day Before, at a used bookstore, but now I'm a bit sorry that I did... seems like a dud.

Have you by any chance read it?


Jeffrey Keeten Traveller wrote: "Mmm, I wonder why his apparent pre-occupation with 'conspiracies'. Or haven't I read enough of his work yet? I recently picked up his The Island of the Day Before, at a used bookstore, but now I'..."

I have not read TIOFDB, but I had a buddy who is an Eco fan say it was a dud. I have a copy and will probably still read it someday, but I don't feel any hurry. This one was more playful than his other work.


message 12: by Traveller (new) - added it

Traveller Argh, it's a hardcover, a big thick thing. Perhaps I should just return it to the store, unread. At least doing so will free up space. :P

...but. Gee, you know what it's like with us bibliophiles. An Eco is an Eco, even if it's a dud Eco. :(


Jeffrey Keeten Traveller wrote: "Argh, it's a hardcover, a big thick thing. Perhaps I should just return it to the store, unread. At least doing so will free up space. :P

...but. Gee, you know what it's like with us bibliophiles..."


Exactly an Eco is an Eco and my reaction to the book could be totally opposite from my friend. There are a finite number of Eco's and he is what 80 or something now, so there probably won't be many more. If I were you I'd read other Eco's first.


Steve aka Sckenda I love the two works that you mentioned that you had read, Jeffrey: Foucault's Pendulum and Name of the Rose. I own Baudolino but have not read it. I love the labyrintine (sp?) plots. I think I read Rose 3 times. Could you elaborate on what you mean by flat-signed? Where do you want the writer to sign for maximum value? or did I miss it somewhere in the comments? Great review...AGAIN! (as Forest Gump would say)


Jeffrey Keeten Steve wrote: "I love the two works that you mentioned that you had read, Jeffrey: Foucault's Pendulum and Name of the Rose. I own Baudolino but have not read it. I love the labyrintine (sp?) plots. I think I re..."

Writers will sign where writers want to. I like to have them sign on the title page as you can see Umberto signed Baudolino in the picture in my review. When the writer signs without an inscription it is called flat signed. Collectors prefer this to having a book say inscribed to Ernest or Bosephus. I have books inscribed to me, but most of my books are flat signed. Sometimes the writer wants to write more and that is really cool when that happens. Sometimes they draw little sketches which add value as well.


Steve aka Sckenda Jeffrey wrote: "Steve wrote: "I love the two works that you mentioned that you had read, Jeffrey: Foucault's Pendulum and Name of the Rose. I own Baudolino but have not read it. I love the labyrintine (sp?) plots...."

So by "inscribed" you mean using the book owner's name? And that's not good. But other personal remarks increase value? Well, not sure I see the logic yet. Also I was confused cause I don't know difference between book plate and title page, so I will have to google. I misunderstood, I thought your image of your signed copy was saying that it was not as valuable b/c it was flat- i.e. a just a signature, nothing personal and that he had signed it in wrong place. I totally misunderstood. THe world of collectibles is new to me. THanks for schooling me at little.


Jeffrey Keeten Steve wrote: "Jeffrey wrote: "Steve wrote: "I love the two works that you mentioned that you had read, Jeffrey: Foucault's Pendulum and Name of the Rose. I own Baudolino but have not read it. I love the labyrint..."

Ahh there is so much to know grasshopper. Many hours of waxing on and waxing off is ahead of you. Sometimes the publisher's send bookplates to authors to be signed which are then adhered in the books before being sent out to be consumed by the public. I want to know that a book has actually been in the hands of an author. I want to be able to dust Baudolino for prints and find Eco's. Now that all said, a signed book plate is still better than no signature at all.

Books are more valuable if they are inscribed to a famous person. For instance I have Ralph Beer's book The Blind Corralsigned by Ralph Beer to Edward Abbey. A book that is maybe worth $100 just signed by the author, but with that inscription (For Edward Abbey and Desert Solitaire a book that made a difference.) is now worth probably in the neighborhood of $250 because it is considered an association copy. It resided in Edward Abbey's library.


back to top