Ann's Reviews > Eat, Pray, Love
Eat, Pray, Love
by Elizabeth Gilbert
by Elizabeth Gilbert
Reading the title and the premise of this book will mislead you greatly as to what you are going to find inside.
This book is not uplifting or spiritual in any way. Elizabeth Gilbert is going through life unaffected by anything except her own whims. She is so selfish and self congratulating, trying to disguise it as self depreciating and humble. Her writing style isn't so bad, it's the content. She continuously looks out at the world and how it is affecting her, not accepting responsibility for creating all of the unfortunate situations in her life that led up to her traveling to the three I's.
Although she said nothing about her ex husband except that he was completely unreasonable and hated her (I wonder why), I still felt sympathetic for him. She gave no convincing reason for leaving him other than that she was sad.
She spent her time in Italy eating and congratulating herself on not having sex with a good-looking Italian man.
She spent her time in India "meditating" although it sounded more like complaining to me. (She does add a nice little bit about how she's glad she's not slaving away in the fields in the excruciating heat like some of the native women she sees.)
She spent her time in Indonesia feeling superior to the natives who apparently want to take you for all they can. She also decides to end her sexual sabbatical when she meets a slightly older gentleman from Brazil who caters to her self absorption and vanity.
In the end all she seems to have learned is that selfishness brings happiness, so if we can all leave our obligations behind and follow every whim and fancy, we fill finally find "god" or at least some form of euphoria. I think she's got it backward, there is something to be said for taking care of yourself first, but that is all she ever worries about. She is perfectly able to live her life however she sees fit, I am just irritated she put it in a book under a different guise and I fell for it.
This book is not uplifting or spiritual in any way. Elizabeth Gilbert is going through life unaffected by anything except her own whims. She is so selfish and self congratulating, trying to disguise it as self depreciating and humble. Her writing style isn't so bad, it's the content. She continuously looks out at the world and how it is affecting her, not accepting responsibility for creating all of the unfortunate situations in her life that led up to her traveling to the three I's.
Although she said nothing about her ex husband except that he was completely unreasonable and hated her (I wonder why), I still felt sympathetic for him. She gave no convincing reason for leaving him other than that she was sad.
She spent her time in Italy eating and congratulating herself on not having sex with a good-looking Italian man.
She spent her time in India "meditating" although it sounded more like complaining to me. (She does add a nice little bit about how she's glad she's not slaving away in the fields in the excruciating heat like some of the native women she sees.)
She spent her time in Indonesia feeling superior to the natives who apparently want to take you for all they can. She also decides to end her sexual sabbatical when she meets a slightly older gentleman from Brazil who caters to her self absorption and vanity.
In the end all she seems to have learned is that selfishness brings happiness, so if we can all leave our obligations behind and follow every whim and fancy, we fill finally find "god" or at least some form of euphoria. I think she's got it backward, there is something to be said for taking care of yourself first, but that is all she ever worries about. She is perfectly able to live her life however she sees fit, I am just irritated she put it in a book under a different guise and I fell for it.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Eat, Pray, Love.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Janette
(new)
Jun 26, 2008 06:34pm
Thanks for the review. I love the fact that I can get everyone's review on this site before I waste my time reading the book. It sounds like you are not alone in your distaste. I’m sorry you won’t be at book club so you can commiserate with others over the lost hours of your life.
reply
|
flag
*
I also agree with everything you said. I found parts of the book entertaining and interesting, but was left feeling very unsatisfied with the fact that she had really made little progress except to justify to herself that she was not a bad person for leaving her husband. She needed to be healed, perhaps, but sleeping with the Brazilian guy after she had vowed to stay celibate really bothered me. If her spiritual evolution meant leaving behind men, she should have stuck to her guns. Plus, she just sort of ditches the healer altogether.I think I was too kind in my rating. Perhaps I will change it after your poignant review. Gracias!


