Michele Weiner's Reviews > A Thousand Lives: The Untold Story of Hope, Deception, and Survival at Jonestown
A Thousand Lives: The Untold Story of Hope, Deception, and Survival at Jonestown
by Julia Scheeres (Goodreads Author)
by Julia Scheeres (Goodreads Author)
This is not a great book. The biggest surprise to me was the extent to which Jim Jones revealed his insanity and depravity long before he took his whole kit-and-caboodle to Guyana. What makes people ignore all evidence and believe impossible things? People let Jones split up their families, take their money, and abuse them, and still they stayed. They watched him fake healing and mistreat members. Very few left the temple. Why?? It's not so simple as a mere lack of education or sophistication. Many temple members were educated. There were nurses, teachers, a partially-trained doctor and some educators among the illiterate and elderly. I guess some people have their own reality distortion fields (see Steve Jobs) which enable them to discount any experience or belief that doesn't comport to their heart's desire---be it a divine Father building a Utopian socialist heaven on earth or the possibility of making an iPad. The last couple paragraphs of the book were a plea to the reader to try and understand that the majority of temple members were good people. But I have trouble with that concept. So many of them abandoned family and conventional morality to live with somebody else's husband or leave their own kids with others--so many watched their children beaten and tortured, watched their spouses be humiliated or sexually used and did nothing. I have a big problem respecting that.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Thousand Lives.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-8 of 8) (8 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Julie
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 12, 2012 12:28am
Read some books on the psychology of mind control, brainwashing, indoctrination, cults, and Stockholm Syndrome to truly understand these issues before taking such a blame the victim mentality.
reply
|
flag
*
It seems to me that the myriad of questions it left you with is only affirming that it actually is a great book. It's not about respecting what these people did, but about understanding the human condition and the forces that motivate our actions.
Thanks for taking the time to respond. I don't think it was a great book, but I respect your opinion.
I took a look at this book and decided against reading it - I read the first of the first chapter and end of the last chapter. My feeling is that if the author wanted you to sympathize with the people at Jamestown then the book would have to be pretty convincing story. My bias going in was that there was no way she was going to convince me to be sympathetic. My answer to Julie and Warren would be - if part of the job of the book was to help me understand their position and why it happened, I shouldn't have to read about Stockholm Syndrome. That is what I expect the book to discuss for me. Also, to me, the book didn't sell itself as a book that would raise questions - in fact, I expected a book that would answer questions... why were these people making the choices they made. If the book didn't answer these questions or sell me on the sympathy, I would have been horribly disappointed as well.
I am a psychologist and I understand the dynamics of the thing. If I wrote this kind of a book, rather than asking for sympathy for those who abandoned their moral training and gave up their autonomy in order to belong or to feel protected by a strong man, I would talk about how to make sure you or your child doesn't end up in that place. It's known, after all, and it would have given the book a higher purpose.
The book was just meant to tell the story. I don't take it as anything more or less. It humanized the victims. You wonder how people get into this stuff? Religion is a powerful thing. It started as a social justice, civil rights based religion. The folks were welcomed in at a time when our culture marginalized them. Come on folks, put it historical/cultural context. Once they were coerced, they couldn't get out. Even current rchristian based religions encourage the practice of giving much of your income to the cause.
Michele Weiner, I understand the dynamics & agree with you, but then countered it with her declaration of what she was going to write and why. So had to be satisfied with that. I understand the dynamics b/c I come from a 50s/60s Pentacostal background and it's real. Diabolical and real.
