Shawna's Reviews > It's All Greek to Me

It's All Greek to Me by Katie MacAlister

by
1802746
's review
Jan 05, 12

bookshelves: contemporary-romance, hero-daddy-warbucks-wealthy, hero-bad-boy-playboy, katie-macalister, hero-or-heroine-exotic, sports-romance-hot-jocks, heroine-bluestocking-unconventional, heroine-curvy-plump-not-stick-thin, heroine-plain-jane-ugly-duckling, heroine-naïve-virgin-like-a-virgin, heroine-i-wanna-bitch-slap-annoying, heroine-chaperone-governess-teacher, heroine-odd-spinster-wallflower, cheez-need-some-wine-please, brothers-sisters-cousins-family, hero-entrepreneur-mogul-tycoon, hh-author-writer-quill-mighty-sword, hh-musician-rocker-singer-popstar, blah-meh, pregnancy-fertility-baby-kids-drama, steam-3-hot, hero-alpha‎, hh-disfigured-injured-scarred-ill, 2012-reads, 2stars-or-less, enemies-to-lovers-opposites-attract, hero-attractive-handsome-heartthrob, hh-across-the-tracks, i-read-library
Read on January 05, 2012

1 star – Contemporary Romance

I’m usually a generous reviewer and rarely rate a book less than 2 stars, but this is an absolute Greek tragedy train wreck. I’ve never read anything by this author before, so I don’t know if fluffy and silly to the point of utterly ridiculous is her usual style or if this is just a disappointing exception. I think the author was aiming for light, humorous, and sexy, but it really missed the mark for me.

The first chapter is annoying with one of the most unromantic scenarios for the H/h meeting in any romance that I’ve read. And the hero, Iakovos, and heroine, Eglantine “Harry”, (yes, those are really their names) speed from animosity toward each other in the first chapter to sex in the third chapter, and the plot (or lack thereof) and dialogue are pour some wine cheesy.

Here’s an example of the strong cheese factor.

(view spoiler)[At one point, the hero doesn’t believe that he’s the father of the heroine’s twin babies because he was informed by a doctor that damage from an accident when he was seventeen that resulted in a prosthetic testicle also rendered him sterile. But have no fear, for this hero managed to overcome his affliction with Greek god sperm and impregnate the virtuous heroine...and with twins! (hide spoiler)]*Eyeroll*

I don’t relish giving low reviews because I recognize that authors put a lot of passion into their books. Unfortunately, this was too silly and borderline lazy and it just didn’t work for me. I really struggled to finish and ended up skimming the second half. Sadly, I can’t even say “it was ok” to give 2 stars, so a rare 1 star from me, it is. :(


Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read It's All Greek to Me.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-23 of 23) (23 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tammy (new)

Tammy WOE!! I've never seen you give a book less than 3 stars, Shaunna.


Tai the Lioness ahhh that sucks!


message 3: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Bummer! If you gave it one star it must be a doozy :(


message 4: by Anita (new)

Anita I marked this one to read but after seeing other people's bad reviews and now yours- glad i didnt buy it


message 5: by MelissaB (new)

MelissaB Ha! This must be bad if you give it 1 star! Nice review Shawna.


message 6: by Vicki (new)

Vicki Shawna I tried to read this one about a month ago...all I can say is thank goodness it was a library book and I didn't pay for it! I didn't even bother rating it, I just took it off my TBR HAHA!


Shawna LOL, Ladies! It's definitely a bummer. The premise sounded like a good Harly, but alas, it just fizzled. Luckily I got it from the library 'cause I'd have been ticked if I'd paid $7.99 for it.


message 8: by Bridget (new)

Bridget Thanks for saving me the effort - you took one for the rest of us!!


Tai the Lioness thanks for taking one for the team girl! i would have fallen prey, and i dont have library access so it would have been a wallet loss!


Shawna YW, LOL! I hate giving low ratings 'cause I feel bad for the author and don't want to negatively influence someone who might enjoy it. But this really fell flat for me.


message 11: by Kristen (new)

Kristen Very honest and informative review, Shawna. I hate giving one stars too.


Shawna Thanks, Kristen! I feel bad rating a book so low, but this was one of those times where it just didn't do it for me.

There seems to be quite a few positive reviews for this, so maybe others who've read her books before knew better what to expect or something. Ah well...C'est la vie.


message 13: by southpaw285 (new)

southpaw285 Wow. I don't think I've ever seen you do this. At least I know to avoid this one.

Thanks for the heads up.


Lady Danielle aka The Book Huntress Sometimes it happens. We are on the same page with the rare 1 starring, but if the shoe fits....


Shawna Southpaw, Luckily it doesn't happen often.

Danielle, Sadly, the shoe fit (for me at least) with this one.


Lady Danielle aka The Book Huntress I hope you enjoy your next read more!


Shawna I just read and enjoyed A Breach of Promise, which helped clean the slate. :)


message 18: by Splage (new)

Splage Wow, you are one of my "positive polly's", always see and point out the good in a book ( I am a "negative Nelly", positive polly is a much better) I am so glad I didn't pick up this book because I really loved the title. Great review.


message 19: by Shawna (last edited Jan 08, 2012 05:52am) (new) - rated it 1 star

Shawna Thanks, Splage! LOL! I soooo don't feel like a "positive polly" sometimes (most of the time), but I guess I tend to be when it comes to books. LOL some more!

I liked the title, cover, and premise, which made it all the more disappointing.


message 20: by Lynsey A (new)

Lynsey A Good review, Shawna. Those names are absolutely ridiculous! How did the author get "Harry" (really, for a female) from, what was her name? Eglatine?
Gack!


Shawna Thanks, Lynsey! LOL, I agree! The "Harry" nickname for the heroine made absolutely no sense. It's funny you said "Gack" 'cause the heroine can't pronounce the hero's name and calls him Yacky the whole book. I just kept thinking "Yuck" and "Yucky".


message 22: by Lynsey A (new)

Lynsey A OMG! That is even worse! She calls him "Yacky" the entire book! How did you even finish it??


Shawna LOL! My OCD wouldn't let me quit, but I did seriously skim the second half. Once I invest time in a book, it's really hard (near impossible) for me to DNF it. But I think I need to make that a goal for myself 'cause books like this aren't worth it.


back to top