Althea Ann's Reviews > Hominids

Hominids by Robert J. Sawyer
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Nov 04, 2011

it was ok
Read from October 29 to 30, 2011

I read this as part of my "reading all the Hugo winners" goal.
All I have to say is: This book was up against China Mieville's 'The Scar' - and THIS won? WHAT?
Sorry, but this is just not a very good book.

The premise is that, due to an accident that occurs during a quantum physics experiment, a Neanderthal scientist from a parallel universe where humanity is the race that went extinct, finds himself stranded in our world.
There's plenty to work with there, lots of potential. However, that potential is not realized.
The book is written in the style I like to refer to as "late 20th-century Mainstream Bestseller." However, this breezy beach-read style is broken up by extended awkward and unbelievable dialogues. Sawyer's point is to show the problems of our society by contrasting it with his imaginary Neanderthal society. Unfortunately, his way of doing this is to get two characters stuck in a room together and make them talk at length, in a very stilted, artificial manner about the topic at hand.
So we get to hear polemics on religion, gender relations, overpopulation, etc, etc. I absolutely agree with some of Sawyer's opinions, I disagree strongly with others. Whether or not I agree with his points is not relevant, the problem is that the topics are introduced and discussed in such a clunky fashion.

Also, as a woman, I felt that Sawyer showed a significant lack of understanding of women in general. His depiction of the reactions of a female character who is raped read like they come straight out of some psychology text, without ever genuinely getting inside her head or creating empathy. I also objected to his depiction of a gender-separatist society that apparently has developed because women are so bitchy due to PMS that men have to live separately from them. I will admit the actual existence of PMS (supposedly it occurs in 2 to 5% of women), and maybe Neanderthals could potentially be more susceptible to it. But yeah, Sawyer's depiction of women in general rubbed me the wrong way.
7 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Hominids.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

03/13 marked as: read

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

David >> His depiction of the reactions of a female character who is raped read like they come straight out of some psychology text

That's almost exactly what I thought. And it (the rape) didn't seem to have anything to do with the rest of the story.

message 2: by Lis (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lis Carey Near the end of the book, Ponter's Neanderthal family concludes that the real reason for the sexual separatism is not PMS, but sexually frustrated men. I'm not sure that's much better, though.

back to top