Bob's Reviews > A First-Rate Madness: Uncovering the Links Between Leadership and Mental Illness

A First-Rate Madness by S. Nassir Ghaemi
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Oct 28, 11

Read from October 24 to 27, 2011

When you look at the problems that face world leaders, especially in times of crisis, you might think, "You have to be crazy to want to do that job." To psychiatrist Nassir Ghaemi, being "crazy", or, more precisely, having some form of mental illness may be just what is needed for some leaders to be able to accomplish great things during times of great need.

Ghaemi examines, in varying details, the lives of people whom he believes had some form of mental illness in their lives. The people examined are Franklin Roosevelt, John F. Kennedy, Abraham Lincoln, William T. Sherman, Ted Turner, Martin Luther King, Mohandas K. Gandhi, and, as an example of how things can go terribly wrong, Adolf Hitler.

The author's theory is that people with certain forms of mental illness, especially bipolar disorder or clinical depression, have certain abilities that help them in times of crisis. These disorders are not something you would ordinarily want to have. But, in a time of crisis, a bipolar personality, for example, has the ability to accomplish more than someone who is mentally healthy. (It's important to note that not everyone suffers from mental illnesses in the exact same way. Some are more severe than others. Also, some don't have every symptom.)

A person with depression may have more empathy to those who are suffering. Gandhi and King are the examples used by Ghaemi to illustrate this point. King's bouts with depression are hard to identify, although Gandhi's are more easily identified.

Kennedy and Hitler are presented as two men who took different courses in life because of how they were treated medically. Ghaemi believes that both Kennedy and Hitler suffered from some form of bipolar disorder. Kennedy's mental health was further complicated by a dangerous hormonal imbalance known as Addison's disease.

Hitler was treated by various Nazi physicians with dangerous concoctions of anabolic steroids as well as intravenous doses of amphetamines. These treatments served to make a dangerous mental condition into a horrific one.

Kennedy was sick most of his life and preoccupied with death. He also was preoccupied with sex. Kennedy was also treated with steroids, some of them anabolic. For much of his life, there was little rhyme or reason to their use. Around 1962, Kennedy's medical treatment became more regulated, which Ghaemi believes led to a far more successful presidency for Kennedy.

Ghaemi makes a good case for showing how people with forms of mental illness can make decisions better during crises, they show more empathy, and they can be more creative. The problem is that most people would never knowingly choose someone to be a leader if they knew that he or she suffered from a mental illness. And, in peaceful times, a mentally ill person could be the last person you want in charge.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A First-Rate Madness.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by David (new)

David I wonder if Kennedy's medical issues could account for his disastrous performance when meeting Khrushchev in Vienna in 1961.

message 2: by Bob (new) - rated it 4 stars

Bob The author mentions that specifically. As well as the Bay of Pigs.

back to top