Catie's Reviews > This is Not a Test
This is Not a Test
by Courtney Summers (Goodreads Author)
by Courtney Summers (Goodreads Author)
Catie's review
bookshelves: for-review, read-in-2012, ya, paranormal
Apr 26, 12
bookshelves: for-review, read-in-2012, ya, paranormal
Read from January 23 to 24, 2012
4 1/2 stars
Because I’m a fancy creative post writer, I thought I’d start this off with a quote from someone whose opinion I really trust:
“Can you imagine what she's going to do with zombie survival?!! I bet it's going to be gruesome. :D”
You know what? I really do love the sound of my own voice. You are so, so right, me of approximately five months ago.
Of course, this is Courtney Summers so the “gruesome” part of this book doesn’t arrive with the zombie apocalypse; it takes place within the grasping, desperate, damaged minds of the survivors. Which I think is a common thread in all the best zombie novels, really. Zombies are compelling in that they speak to some of our deepest fears; for example, that our bodies could become vacant killing machines, piloted by something other than ourselves. It’s a complete loss of free will. But in some sense, zombies can easily be a stand-in for any mass disaster or plague. What’s most compelling is the reaction of the human survivors to the zombies.
This book has one of the best opening chapters I’ve read in a really long time. It is completely subtle but also utterly horrifying and absorbing. We are introduced to the main character Sloane in one brief, emotionally intense snapshot. Her life is a confining, meaningless misery and now that her sister is gone, she doesn’t see the point in continuing. She’s just about to finally let go when something happens – a shattering window, a crazed woman, a mad rush of humanity outside. And then we are pushed forward in time by seven days, as Sloane and five other survivors find shelter in their high school. What happened in those seven days was ugly and brutal, but we are not shown the details fully. We are given a front row seat to the more interesting part – the aftermath.
I’ve long admired Courtney Summers’ writing, because she really has a talent for getting in deep with the darker emotions and portraying them with such stark honesty that it’s impossible not to be affected. But in this book I feel like she’s really grown as a writer, finding that perfect balance between subtlety and story-telling. She hits us with bright pieces of emotion and action, but she never fills in all the blanks. It's subtle but evocative enough that we are compelled to contribute – we have to put ourselves into the story. She can lead us down the path, but we have to use our own emotions and experiences to make the final steps. I think that’s one of the hallmarks of a great writer – because in the end, no writer can complete a story alone. No writer can describe an emotion with such perfection that someone who’s never felt it before will suddenly understand it. The best writers lead us to our own emotions, and the best stories are collaborations between writers and readers. I think that Courtney Summers really masters that with This Is Not a Test.
And of course, this woman writes my favorite kind of endings – dark but ambiguously hopeful, with realistic growth in the main character – perfection.
Perfect Musical Pairing
Florence + The Machine – Never Let Me Go
That’s right, I’m pulling out all the stops for this book! No less than Florence will do. This song, to me, is about giving up on everything, completely, only to realize that you’ve survived anyway.
And now I need to make an announcement. Attention everyone: this is not a test. Go crazy for this book. Bloggers: it’s time to light up the super special ARC signal in the sky. Courtney Summers fans: do whatever you have to do - crack each other’s heads open and feast on the goo inside if you must. Just get this book. This is not a test people!
Also seen on The Readventurer.
Because I’m a fancy creative post writer, I thought I’d start this off with a quote from someone whose opinion I really trust:
“Can you imagine what she's going to do with zombie survival?!! I bet it's going to be gruesome. :D”
You know what? I really do love the sound of my own voice. You are so, so right, me of approximately five months ago.
Of course, this is Courtney Summers so the “gruesome” part of this book doesn’t arrive with the zombie apocalypse; it takes place within the grasping, desperate, damaged minds of the survivors. Which I think is a common thread in all the best zombie novels, really. Zombies are compelling in that they speak to some of our deepest fears; for example, that our bodies could become vacant killing machines, piloted by something other than ourselves. It’s a complete loss of free will. But in some sense, zombies can easily be a stand-in for any mass disaster or plague. What’s most compelling is the reaction of the human survivors to the zombies.
This book has one of the best opening chapters I’ve read in a really long time. It is completely subtle but also utterly horrifying and absorbing. We are introduced to the main character Sloane in one brief, emotionally intense snapshot. Her life is a confining, meaningless misery and now that her sister is gone, she doesn’t see the point in continuing. She’s just about to finally let go when something happens – a shattering window, a crazed woman, a mad rush of humanity outside. And then we are pushed forward in time by seven days, as Sloane and five other survivors find shelter in their high school. What happened in those seven days was ugly and brutal, but we are not shown the details fully. We are given a front row seat to the more interesting part – the aftermath.
I’ve long admired Courtney Summers’ writing, because she really has a talent for getting in deep with the darker emotions and portraying them with such stark honesty that it’s impossible not to be affected. But in this book I feel like she’s really grown as a writer, finding that perfect balance between subtlety and story-telling. She hits us with bright pieces of emotion and action, but she never fills in all the blanks. It's subtle but evocative enough that we are compelled to contribute – we have to put ourselves into the story. She can lead us down the path, but we have to use our own emotions and experiences to make the final steps. I think that’s one of the hallmarks of a great writer – because in the end, no writer can complete a story alone. No writer can describe an emotion with such perfection that someone who’s never felt it before will suddenly understand it. The best writers lead us to our own emotions, and the best stories are collaborations between writers and readers. I think that Courtney Summers really masters that with This Is Not a Test.
And of course, this woman writes my favorite kind of endings – dark but ambiguously hopeful, with realistic growth in the main character – perfection.
Perfect Musical Pairing
Florence + The Machine – Never Let Me Go
That’s right, I’m pulling out all the stops for this book! No less than Florence will do. This song, to me, is about giving up on everything, completely, only to realize that you’ve survived anyway.
And now I need to make an announcement. Attention everyone: this is not a test. Go crazy for this book. Bloggers: it’s time to light up the super special ARC signal in the sky. Courtney Summers fans: do whatever you have to do - crack each other’s heads open and feast on the goo inside if you must. Just get this book. This is not a test people!
Also seen on The Readventurer.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read This is Not a Test.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 01/24/2012 | page 128 |
|
40.0% | "I wasn't even going to start this but then I thought...eh, might as well glance at the first few pages.... And then I accidentally read 40%. Woops." 8 comments |
Comments (showing 1-32 of 32) (32 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Meg ♥
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 24, 2012 10:43am
Just got this, too. Must be pretty great if you accidentally read half!
reply
|
flag
*
So, you are in fact aware of the post/review kerfuffle courtesy of MS. I thought you were better than all of us and was ignoring all the controversy. Guess not;)
I haven't read a Courtney Summers book yet (I know), but this sounds good. PS. Does the ARC signal sound anything like the raptors in Jurassic Park?
Thanks Noelle - I hope you like it!Haha, yes I am aware Tatiana. I haven't been really following it on goodreads but a friend sent me a link to MS' blog and I read her post. AND, I read Kat's hilarious spoof of it the other day.
You should check her out Maggie. I think that you would like her. And actually I was picturing like a glowing book worm in the night sky - like the batman signal but for book nerds.
LOL, that glowing book worm would be perfect.Great review, Catie.
I'm so excited for this one :)
Although I fear I may have exhausted all my zombie songs on Ms Grant.
*frets*
Well, fret no more because really the zombies are such a minor part of this book. It's the PEOPLE you've got to worry about. MWA HA HA HA HAAHAHAHAHAAHA*chokes*Excuse me.
This is such an awesome review Catie! I really really can't wait to read it now. My to read next list keeps changing all the time, guess I'm going to have to squeeze this in somewhere. Btw best opening quote ever! :)
Thanks Jasprit! You should definitely try to squeeze it in. Haha, it was quite brilliant, wasn't it? ;)
Thanks so much Reynje and Suzie! I hope you get to read it soon, Rey. She has other books that are very good too - in the mean time ;)
Ha! Thanks Kelly!I enjoyed your review very much as well. Have you read any other Courtney Summers? You'd probably like them if you loved this one.
Read 'em all :) I do think this one is her knock-out, though. It does the best of what her other titles do and takes it up a notch with the zombie element. Brrrrrutal!
I thought this was her best yet too! Although I do love all of the other ones. I hope this one blows up all over goodreads and book blogs when it comes out.
Catie wrote: "I thought this was her best yet too! Although I do love all of the other ones. I hope this one blows up all over goodreads and book blogs when it comes out."Ditto! It's unlike anything out there right now story-wise, and the writing is superb.
Catie wrote: "I thought this was her best yet too! Although I do love all of the other ones. I hope this one blows up all over goodreads and book blogs when it comes out."It was so interesting to read a sympathetic character outta Summers, too!
Haha, I've completely sympathized with every one of her characters. But...I'm kind of a prickly person on the inside so that probably makes sense. ;)
Catie wrote: "Haha, I've completely sympathized with every one of her characters. But...I'm kind of a prickly person on the inside so that probably makes sense. ;)"hah! I thought Sloane was the EASIEST to sympathize with ;) I mean...how can you not?
I'm looking forward to reading this one again when it's out in June.
I love this book! I love your review! I love zombies! I love Courtney Summers! And this -- I love what you say here: " The best writers lead us to our own emotions, and the best stories are collaborations between writers and readers.":)
Thanks Trudi! I love your review so much too. I love what you said about the constant presence of the zombies, and the quiet. The beginning and ending sequences are so intense as a result!







