Benny Wilkinson's Reviews > Cryptonomicon
Cryptonomicon
by Neal Stephenson
by Neal Stephenson
Benny Wilkinson's review
bookshelves: shelf-b, protagonist-male, protagonist-multi, read-2011, theme-historical
Jan 22, 12
bookshelves: shelf-b, protagonist-male, protagonist-multi, read-2011, theme-historical
Read from November 08, 2011 to January 21, 2012
Spread across two different time periods, the second world war and a present-day setting in line with the book's release in the late nineties, Cryptonomicon is a fictionalised history of cryptography and also a modern techno-thriller. It's told primarily from the viewpoints of four characters:
1) Lawrence Waterhouse - A genius cryptographer with a knack for spotting patterns, who attended university with Alan Turing shortly before the second world war. When the Enigma code is cracked Lawrence's main occupation is creating plausible reasons for why the British are able to anticipate the Nazi's every move without revealing that they've cracked the code. He is almost incapable of viewing anything without breaking it down into patterns and systems, a unique approach that makes for some excellent chapters, with Lawrence's decision that he needs to seduce and marry a specific woman based on how thoughts of her are impacting his work being a particular highlight.
2) Bobby Shaftoe - A former Marine in the second world war, left psychologically damaged by a major traumatic incident that leaves him unhinged enough to be the perfect man to carry out Lawrence's plans. He is sent on bizarre missions deep into enemy territory that seemingly undermine the Allies or otherwise make no sense at all, but carries them all out without question. At one point his team smuggles barrels and crates full of waste - used cigarettes, old newspapers and even faecal matter - to an isolated building in Italy, so they can give the impression that spies have been there for months. The sheer insanity of the tasks he is assigned make for some of the more hilarious moments in the book.
3) Goto Dengo - An Imperial Soldier in the Japanese army during the second world war, who befriends Bobby after they get into a fight. He undergoes a major crisis of faith when he realises the undefeatable imperial army is losing the war, and his shock that the Americans would identify their weaknesses and find solutions is a wonderful moment. His is mostly a sad story due to his belief that his lack of faith in the Empire is a personal flaw, and after his unit is defeated he becomes so lost as he tries to find purpose again, before being assigned to a secret project that he doesn't expect to survive.
4) Randy Waterhouse - The sole present-day main character, a talented programmer in several communications and internet projects around the Phillipines. His storyline draws upon all the others, connected through their descendants (Randy himself being Lawrence's grandson), their friends and colleagues, or building upon their work. Aside from Goto he is the one who was most sure about his place in the world and his potential, only to have most of those preconceptions demonstrated to be spectacularly wrong. Where Goto is almost destroyed by this change Randy embraces it, finding he didn't care about those things as much as he thought it did and welcoming the new choices available to him.
With multiple characters there's always a danger that some will be considerably better than others, making a switch away from them frustrating, or creating a sense that the plot is dragging from the need to tell four largely separate stories at once. I never had that sense with Cryptonomicon. There was a little disappointment most times a character's chapter came to an end, but that would be prove true with the next character, and on and on. All four characters are excellent, and those are only the viewpoint ones, as each is supported by an abundance of great characters.
It's a surprisingly funny book and made me laugh out loud plenty of times. It's also incredibly well written at points, as there were many times where I was genuinely impressed with what I'd just read and wanted to save those excerpts. Paragraphs like a description of the human body or the depression of the natives of Finland are either just marvellously written or also very funny. Even when Stephenson moves into detailed technical explanations of cryptographic concepts it's still interesting. Cryptonomicon is a long book but is never dull, telling a fascinating story (or even multiple fascinating stories) with lots of excellent characters. I really enjoyed it.
1) Lawrence Waterhouse - A genius cryptographer with a knack for spotting patterns, who attended university with Alan Turing shortly before the second world war. When the Enigma code is cracked Lawrence's main occupation is creating plausible reasons for why the British are able to anticipate the Nazi's every move without revealing that they've cracked the code. He is almost incapable of viewing anything without breaking it down into patterns and systems, a unique approach that makes for some excellent chapters, with Lawrence's decision that he needs to seduce and marry a specific woman based on how thoughts of her are impacting his work being a particular highlight.
2) Bobby Shaftoe - A former Marine in the second world war, left psychologically damaged by a major traumatic incident that leaves him unhinged enough to be the perfect man to carry out Lawrence's plans. He is sent on bizarre missions deep into enemy territory that seemingly undermine the Allies or otherwise make no sense at all, but carries them all out without question. At one point his team smuggles barrels and crates full of waste - used cigarettes, old newspapers and even faecal matter - to an isolated building in Italy, so they can give the impression that spies have been there for months. The sheer insanity of the tasks he is assigned make for some of the more hilarious moments in the book.
3) Goto Dengo - An Imperial Soldier in the Japanese army during the second world war, who befriends Bobby after they get into a fight. He undergoes a major crisis of faith when he realises the undefeatable imperial army is losing the war, and his shock that the Americans would identify their weaknesses and find solutions is a wonderful moment. His is mostly a sad story due to his belief that his lack of faith in the Empire is a personal flaw, and after his unit is defeated he becomes so lost as he tries to find purpose again, before being assigned to a secret project that he doesn't expect to survive.
4) Randy Waterhouse - The sole present-day main character, a talented programmer in several communications and internet projects around the Phillipines. His storyline draws upon all the others, connected through their descendants (Randy himself being Lawrence's grandson), their friends and colleagues, or building upon their work. Aside from Goto he is the one who was most sure about his place in the world and his potential, only to have most of those preconceptions demonstrated to be spectacularly wrong. Where Goto is almost destroyed by this change Randy embraces it, finding he didn't care about those things as much as he thought it did and welcoming the new choices available to him.
With multiple characters there's always a danger that some will be considerably better than others, making a switch away from them frustrating, or creating a sense that the plot is dragging from the need to tell four largely separate stories at once. I never had that sense with Cryptonomicon. There was a little disappointment most times a character's chapter came to an end, but that would be prove true with the next character, and on and on. All four characters are excellent, and those are only the viewpoint ones, as each is supported by an abundance of great characters.
It's a surprisingly funny book and made me laugh out loud plenty of times. It's also incredibly well written at points, as there were many times where I was genuinely impressed with what I'd just read and wanted to save those excerpts. Paragraphs like a description of the human body or the depression of the natives of Finland are either just marvellously written or also very funny. Even when Stephenson moves into detailed technical explanations of cryptographic concepts it's still interesting. Cryptonomicon is a long book but is never dull, telling a fascinating story (or even multiple fascinating stories) with lots of excellent characters. I really enjoyed it.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Cryptonomicon.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 01/14/2012 | page 832 |
|
91.0% | |
| 12/21/2011 | page 609 |
|
66.0% | "No Bobby here, lots of Lawrence and Randy and a spot of Goto. One chapter was all about how Lawrence perceives the world and relationships, and another was Lawrence viewed from somebody else's perspective. Both were hilarious. Randy, meanwhile, is slowly integrating into the Shaftoe clan and learning their odd behaviours." |
| 11/24/2011 | page 569 |
|
62.0% | "Lawrence is in love, and the way he analyses his feelings is very amusing. Bobby's back in action after a lot of downtime. Goto has a new purpose. Randy's been on a treasure hunt, and it's his story that I'm the least sure of. I can see where Lawrence and Bobby are going but I still can't peg Randy's path yet. There's still a lot of book left to go though." |
| 11/23/2011 | page 506 |
|
55.0% | "It's still tough to pick a favourite character. Lawrence is casually brilliant and bemused by war and the world in general. Bobby is just crazy and broken but somehow manages to find himself in situations and with people that are at least as crazy and broken as he is. Randy is perhaps the easiest to relate to, being close enough to the real world to be threatened by it but distant enough to not let it get to him." |
| 11/19/2011 | page 431 |
|
47.0% | "After his absence in yesterday's block, Bobby is back in full swing for this bit, at some points making me laugh out loud. Lawrence only had a brief presence, Randy and newcomer Goto making up the rest, both going through some big moments." |
| 11/18/2011 | page 372 |
|
41.0% | "No Bobby in this chunk, time spent instead looking at the Nipponese side of things, their outrage at the way the American troops identify their own failings and change tactics, with some very funny passages. Some interesting ideas on Randy's end as well, like Van Eck phreaking." |
| 11/17/2011 | page 310 |
|
34.0% | "The book presents an interesting problem: When you've cracked enemy codes and have access to all their intelligence, how do you act upon that intelligence without giving away that you've cracked those codes? Figuring out ways to deceive the enemy is Lawrence's main occupation, coming up with seemingly insane plans for Bobby to enact. It's bizarre but plausible." |
| 11/11/2011 | page 253 |
|
28.0% | "Each of the three main characters has a strong story of their own. Each time a chapter ends and it switches to one of the others I'm a little disappointed to be putting that character on hold, only to feel the same at the end of the next chapter." |
| 11/10/2011 | page 192 |
|
21.0% | "Though they've not met Bobby and Lawrence have a direct connection by this point, one plotting how to spread false information and the other tasked with spreading it. Randy's connection is more distant, and right now his role seems to be showing how the efforts of the other two eventually led to his career." |
| 11/09/2011 | page 125 |
|
14.0% | "All three characters are settled into the places they need to be now. It's been funny so far in addition to interesting. Lawrence is clueless about anything other than patterns, Bobby damaged by all he's seen and Randy incredibly cynical." |
| 11/08/2011 | page 62 |
|
7.0% | "Another chunky book, so we'll be here a while. Three main characters have been established so far, Randy, Lawrence and Bobby, across a couple of time periods. No idea where it's going yet, outside of the general themes." |

