Kat Kennedy's Reviews > Dearly, Departed
Dearly, Departed (Gone With the Respiration, #1)
by Lia Habel (Goodreads Author)
by Lia Habel (Goodreads Author)
*This ARC was provided to me by the publishers via NetGalley. No money or favours were exchanged for this review.*
Somewhere along the way, zombies became hot.

No, not that kind of hot

This kind of hot!
Lia Habel has taken my two favourite genres, steampunk and zombies, and mixed them together. The results of which should have been a hundred times more fantabulous than anything humanity could ever have hoped to produce up until this point.

With the sole exception of Neil Patrick Harris. Oh! And Terry Crew's abs.
Habel has a lot of potential going for her. This novel had SO much potential. Unfortunately, it was let down in a few key areas. However, I'm assured by the powers-that-be that this was done on purpose to stop humanity from transcending to the next level of consciousness, so I guess that explains a lot.
Habel displays an easy talent for creating fun characters, a diverse world and interesting storyline. Unfortunately, a lot of this was lost through a few rookie mistakes. It was doubly frustrating because I really wanted to enjoy this novel.
First of all, there are five POVs in this novel and it switches between them all rather frequently. Look, there's nothing wrong with multiple POVs. Many people enjoy them. However, what you gain in adding to characterization, you lose in pacing.
Reading a novel is a little like driving a stick. You start in first gear and you move your way up to five as the intensity picks up and heads towards the climax (I so want to put a filthy joke in here, but notice I didn't. RECOGNIZE MY RESTRAINT!) Then you have to move down in gear for your denouement and eventual conclusion.
But POVs tend to equal an automatic change in gear - often downward and it takes the reader awhile to get back up to speed and progress upwards. They have to get mentally pulled out of the storyline they were just following, they have to readjust to the new setting, recall where the current POV last finished and pick back up from there. Most readers can do this without much difficulty - to a point. But too many of these and you have a jerky ride at best, or lose all momentum at worst.
Secondly, the beginning struggles to get past a few big info dumps which makes the first half of this novel cumbersome. Once Habel is finished setting up her world, despite the extraordinary amount of time she takes to do this, she shows a natural flare for storytelling. With explanations out of the way, Habel seemed free to actually pump the novel full of action and excitement - something I greatly enjoyed.
I suppose the biggest issue is getting past the squick factor of romanticizing reanimated flesh.

Oh c'mon, walking corpses have been dominating the catwalk for years! Right, Kate Moss?
Every time I thought I was okay with it, I realized I. Just. Wasn't.
Which, I guess, leads me to my last and final complaint because I found the relationship between the two main protagonists to be... uninspiring, if you know what I mean. And your proper enjoyment of the novel probably hinges on the following question. Do you want to imagine illicit zombie smoochies? And let's keep in mind that Habel's zombie lore isn't that different from normal zombie lore. They're still rotting dead people.
I mean, we're talking about a Chris Brown level of gross.

No, wait. That's insulting to the zombie.
If you can, then strap on your clockwork jetpacks and give this novel a try!
Somewhere along the way, zombies became hot.

No, not that kind of hot

This kind of hot!
Lia Habel has taken my two favourite genres, steampunk and zombies, and mixed them together. The results of which should have been a hundred times more fantabulous than anything humanity could ever have hoped to produce up until this point.

With the sole exception of Neil Patrick Harris. Oh! And Terry Crew's abs.
Habel has a lot of potential going for her. This novel had SO much potential. Unfortunately, it was let down in a few key areas. However, I'm assured by the powers-that-be that this was done on purpose to stop humanity from transcending to the next level of consciousness, so I guess that explains a lot.
Habel displays an easy talent for creating fun characters, a diverse world and interesting storyline. Unfortunately, a lot of this was lost through a few rookie mistakes. It was doubly frustrating because I really wanted to enjoy this novel.
First of all, there are five POVs in this novel and it switches between them all rather frequently. Look, there's nothing wrong with multiple POVs. Many people enjoy them. However, what you gain in adding to characterization, you lose in pacing.
Reading a novel is a little like driving a stick. You start in first gear and you move your way up to five as the intensity picks up and heads towards the climax (I so want to put a filthy joke in here, but notice I didn't. RECOGNIZE MY RESTRAINT!) Then you have to move down in gear for your denouement and eventual conclusion.
But POVs tend to equal an automatic change in gear - often downward and it takes the reader awhile to get back up to speed and progress upwards. They have to get mentally pulled out of the storyline they were just following, they have to readjust to the new setting, recall where the current POV last finished and pick back up from there. Most readers can do this without much difficulty - to a point. But too many of these and you have a jerky ride at best, or lose all momentum at worst.
Secondly, the beginning struggles to get past a few big info dumps which makes the first half of this novel cumbersome. Once Habel is finished setting up her world, despite the extraordinary amount of time she takes to do this, she shows a natural flare for storytelling. With explanations out of the way, Habel seemed free to actually pump the novel full of action and excitement - something I greatly enjoyed.
I suppose the biggest issue is getting past the squick factor of romanticizing reanimated flesh.

Oh c'mon, walking corpses have been dominating the catwalk for years! Right, Kate Moss?
Every time I thought I was okay with it, I realized I. Just. Wasn't.
Which, I guess, leads me to my last and final complaint because I found the relationship between the two main protagonists to be... uninspiring, if you know what I mean. And your proper enjoyment of the novel probably hinges on the following question. Do you want to imagine illicit zombie smoochies? And let's keep in mind that Habel's zombie lore isn't that different from normal zombie lore. They're still rotting dead people.
I mean, we're talking about a Chris Brown level of gross.

No, wait. That's insulting to the zombie.
If you can, then strap on your clockwork jetpacks and give this novel a try!
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Dearly, Departed.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 10/21/2011 | page 28 |
|
6.0% | "You mortals have no idea how hard it is to be beautiful! What with my almond shaped eyes and natural ringlets... it's tragic! Absolutely tragic!" 2 comments |
| 10/21/2011 | page 70 |
|
15.0% | "Yes, yes, protag is pretty - we get it. Move the fuck on!" 10 comments |
| 10/21/2011 | page 100 |
|
21.0% | "Like Bram, I iz dead. Dead bored that is! Hahahahaha! Enough." |
| 10/22/2011 | page 194 |
|
40.0% | "No. Fuck no. You do NOT have messy quarters when you're a soldier living in a military barracks. Not unless they do things differently in America." 3 comments |
Comments (showing 1-24 of 24) (24 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Elizabeth
(new)
Oct 24, 2011 05:51am
Sexy zombies? That's a big ick. Seriously. Ick.
reply
|
flag
*
It's funny that just about a year ago I was deeply disturbed by the idea of sexifying zombies, after hearing of I Kissed a Zombie, and I Liked It. And now my fears are coming true. This book plus Working Stiff. I am sure there is more to come.
Beth wrote: "Necrophilia will never be sexy. Ever."Does your definition apply to vampires, too? For some people it does, for some people it doesn't.
Elizabeth wrote: "Beth wrote: "Necrophilia will never be sexy. Ever."Does your definition apply to vampires, too? For some people it does, for some people it doesn't."
Unless they're the Christine Feehan-esque living ones, yeah. I actually put a book down a while back because I got squicked out by the main character sleeping with a vampire that was clearly described both as dead and also monstrous. I mean, the character is a necromancer, but I think that's liking your job a bit too much.
NEIL PATRICK HARRIS IS RIDING A UNICORN!!I'm sorry, I was completely unable to concentrate after that.
Great review. There is a good story under all the info she throws at the reader. For the record, I did like Working Stiff....
Kat, I had the exact same problems due to the changing POVs.Annoyed me so much that I have just taken a break from it.
Yeah, zombies aren't sexy because they are rotting corpses. Take away the rotting part and maybe I'll be cool with the idea. Oh, wait a minute, I think I just described vampires minus the cool supernatural abilities (super-strength, glamors, sexy blood drinking, seduction, and so on...). ...yeah, even after the whole rotting thing is taken out of the mix, zombies still aren't sexy. I mean, you've still got a mindless (lacking the ability to think rationally), cold, stiff (insert innuendo here) dead body that wants to eat your brains. Take away all these un-sexy roadblocks and you've no longer got a zombie on your hands.
I'm sorry but Sexy and Zombie will never go hand in hand. Unless you're into necrophilia.
(Just sayin'.)
Yeah, as Tatiana mentioned, we kind of saw zombie romances coming - but mostly viewed it as a sign of the apocalypse.I can't say it did anything for me, unfortunately.
Thanks, Kasha! It's a gifting!
Just read the part where there's kissing involved between zombie and non-zombie. Didn't do it for me, either.
Kat wrote: "Excellent, AH! You can still be my friend!" Yah! I really disliked this book for a while. It's gotten much better but the POV shifting is driving me insane.
I'm very disturbed by the zombie romance trend too. It creeps me out. I refuse to read any book with a romance that involves a zombie because I know it will ruin the book for me even if the rest of it is fantastic. Love the review.
Amazing review. Although I loved this book, I totally understand where you are coming from. It squicked me out a little too, but then I got past it and ended up loving the two of them. Funny thing was, I originally gave this book 4 stars. Months later I went back and bumped it up to 5 because I just could not get this book out of my head. So memorable to me. And the POV thing. There were a couple of POVs I couldn't care less about, so I know why you are saying. But this review was really funny anyway. So thank you for that.
Ya know I didn't really have a problem with them breaching zombie+hot in Warm Bodies. But...and that's a bit but, they had to make a huge change to the concept of what a zombie was, and create alot of symbolism. So I half expected there to be a zombie love boom... I just wasn't that impressed with Dearly Departed, too many things scrambled into one. Is it a steampunk? Dystopia? YA? Wait, gym uniforms or petticoats? Oh hot boy, meh he had a pulse at one point, good enough.






