Aaron Carlberg's Reviews > Heaven is for Real: A Little Boy's Astounding Story of His Trip to Heaven and Back
Heaven is for Real: A Little Boy's Astounding Story of His Trip to Heaven and Back
by Todd Burpo, Lynn Vincent
by Todd Burpo, Lynn Vincent
For a while now people have been asking me to read and comment on the book Heaven is for Real written by Todd (not making up his last name) Burpo. For some reason, because I am a pastor, people think I am going to love this book about a little boy who went to heaven and met Jesus. Then Jesus sent him back (like you put your unfinished cookies back in the oven when they aren't finished).
Well, here goes…and don't hate me for being honest. I did not like this book what-so-ever.
This book plays into our current climate of people going to SPEND (pick your amount of time) minutes/hours/seconds IN (pick your place) heaven/hell/purgatory/Burger King in AN EFFORT TO (pick your reason) grow your faith/make you feel good/make some money. It is not just the writing style of an adult trying to sound like a kid who sounds like an adult trying to sound like a kid, it is the poor theology that people are so willing to buy into.
First, let me just say that Todd Burpo sounds like a Christian, I am not questioning his faith. But a bit more discernment may be in order…and the fact that we do not build theology based solely on our experience (especially that of a 4 year old). As an example, scripture teaches that Jesus won our victory on the cross, he said our sins were paid for, "it is finished." Yet Jesus still has to fight (pg136-139)? If Jesus is all-powerful what is the point of him handing out swords and bows and arrows?
It seems much of the book is written to fit into a particular mindset and belief structure. Colten (the boy) will say something and the dad will interpret it with a verse that seems to make it all make sense…but it doesn't! When trying to describe Jesus, Colton is convinced that his style from the 1st century has never changed. He has brown hair, a beard, white robe with a purple sash (Jesus is the only one who gets to wear purple by the way), a crown, and red marks in the center of his palms (even though that is not where the nails would have gone) and on his feet (page 65-66.)
This goes on and on…from people getting wings to God and Jesus apparently sitting in their big chairs all day (except when Jesus is going up and down like an elevator)...oh, I almost forgot; all Angels also have to carry swords to keep Satan out of heaven (Page 133).
I do not just want to blast the book, but this is the problem with what Christianity has become…according to the book the reason Jesus died on the cross was so that we could go to heaven.
Question, is that why Jesus died?
Modern Christianity makes salvation all about us, when salvation is about Jesus. Jesus died because we were so awful, our sin so great, that we destroyed everything. Jesus' death pays for our sin not so that we could go to heaven but so we could be a redeemed people living redeemed lives in Jesus' name. Jesus rose from the dead conquering our enemies of Satan, sin, and death. Jesus' death and resurrection are about life, bringing heaven to earth in how we, as God's people, live this life.
Never once did Jesus, in the scriptures, talk about the goal being to get out of here and go somewhere else. The purpose of His coming was to restore relationship between God and us again by removing what stood in the way, namely our sin.
As Christians we must get away from the idea that Jesus died so we could get out of this place and watch it burn. Jesus died AND ROSE; the heart that Jesus had for this world should burn in us with a passion and intensity to see the lost know Him.
Heaven IS for real, but heaven is NOT the point. The point is Jesus…that is what we should remember.
Well, here goes…and don't hate me for being honest. I did not like this book what-so-ever.
This book plays into our current climate of people going to SPEND (pick your amount of time) minutes/hours/seconds IN (pick your place) heaven/hell/purgatory/Burger King in AN EFFORT TO (pick your reason) grow your faith/make you feel good/make some money. It is not just the writing style of an adult trying to sound like a kid who sounds like an adult trying to sound like a kid, it is the poor theology that people are so willing to buy into.
First, let me just say that Todd Burpo sounds like a Christian, I am not questioning his faith. But a bit more discernment may be in order…and the fact that we do not build theology based solely on our experience (especially that of a 4 year old). As an example, scripture teaches that Jesus won our victory on the cross, he said our sins were paid for, "it is finished." Yet Jesus still has to fight (pg136-139)? If Jesus is all-powerful what is the point of him handing out swords and bows and arrows?
It seems much of the book is written to fit into a particular mindset and belief structure. Colten (the boy) will say something and the dad will interpret it with a verse that seems to make it all make sense…but it doesn't! When trying to describe Jesus, Colton is convinced that his style from the 1st century has never changed. He has brown hair, a beard, white robe with a purple sash (Jesus is the only one who gets to wear purple by the way), a crown, and red marks in the center of his palms (even though that is not where the nails would have gone) and on his feet (page 65-66.)
This goes on and on…from people getting wings to God and Jesus apparently sitting in their big chairs all day (except when Jesus is going up and down like an elevator)...oh, I almost forgot; all Angels also have to carry swords to keep Satan out of heaven (Page 133).
I do not just want to blast the book, but this is the problem with what Christianity has become…according to the book the reason Jesus died on the cross was so that we could go to heaven.
Question, is that why Jesus died?
Modern Christianity makes salvation all about us, when salvation is about Jesus. Jesus died because we were so awful, our sin so great, that we destroyed everything. Jesus' death pays for our sin not so that we could go to heaven but so we could be a redeemed people living redeemed lives in Jesus' name. Jesus rose from the dead conquering our enemies of Satan, sin, and death. Jesus' death and resurrection are about life, bringing heaven to earth in how we, as God's people, live this life.
Never once did Jesus, in the scriptures, talk about the goal being to get out of here and go somewhere else. The purpose of His coming was to restore relationship between God and us again by removing what stood in the way, namely our sin.
As Christians we must get away from the idea that Jesus died so we could get out of this place and watch it burn. Jesus died AND ROSE; the heart that Jesus had for this world should burn in us with a passion and intensity to see the lost know Him.
Heaven IS for real, but heaven is NOT the point. The point is Jesus…that is what we should remember.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Heaven is for Real.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-16 of 16) (16 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Mikayla
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Oct 18, 2011 09:02am
In some ways I agree and disagree with this. I disagree with the fighting off Satan. The bows and having to fight Satan off makes sense. It says that Satan will be defeated and also that Jesus will return. But that hasn't happened yet. Satan isn't in hell yet. He has to be defeated. And since that hasn't happened it would make sense that he tries to get himself into heaven. In other ways I agree. Now a days people will just say their Christian, they believe in God and Heaven. But just because you say that and don't change your life doesn't mean anything. Accepting Him means changing your lifestyle. Not living for your self but living for God. And I think that's where people are going to get confused on this book. You can't just say one thing but not mean it.
reply
|
flag
*
We must be a people that have a biblical understanding and not a fiction (eg: this present darkness) or a Hollywood stylized (eg: Supernatural or Exorcist) perspective of the truth. Satan can't fight his way into heaven as if God was powerless to stop him and needs an army to protect Himself.If you look at the book of Job, Satan has access to heaven but it is under God's discretion. God is BIG, Satan is small...and he is defeated. It is not some future victory for us, it was accomplished at the cross of Christ.
Matthew 28:18 is clear that Jesus has all authority and Colosians 1:10-14 is clear to remind us that we have been delivered (past tense) from the domain of darkness.
Colosians 2:13-15 And you, who were dead in your trespasses and the uncircumcision of your flesh, God made alive together with him, having forgiven us all our trespasses, by canceling the record of debt that stood against us with its legal demands. This he set aside, nailing it to the cross. He disarmed the rulers and authorities and put them to open shame, by triumphing over them in him.
um..... i agree with you to some extent but seriously. some of the stuff your saying does not make much sense. the last part didn't even have anything to do with the book!
I can see how my review could be inferred that way; please know I was just rounding out the review in how most Christians tend to live their lives. I meant, in no way, to infer that Todd Burpo (or Colton) think all people should burn.I also think that the modern Christian push to ask "are you going to heaven" misses the point of the Christian life or the fullness that Jesus offers. The life of Christ is MORE than Heaven (heaven is simply a by product of God's gracious blessing), our goal isn't to leave the world behind...it is to glorify God and live the life He calls us to here and now bringing heaven to earth by our actions as He allows us to partner with Him in redeeming His creation. We are citizens of another kingdom, but are ambassadors here, to this place that God loves (which means we should love it as well).
I see where your coming from. But different people have their own experences with God and so on. Who are we to judge. This book touched my heart, not in a "i believe every word of it" since, but the heat renching lie story thats being told.
I loved your comments and wish I could hear some of your sermons. It appears your beliefs are similar to mine. Thanks for your thoughts.
Aaron wrote: "You can go to ourelement.org and listen to any messages you would like :-)"Thanks. I will.
Just wanted to clarify, my opinions on the book withstanding. Colton's understanding (or relaying) of why Jesus died doesn't state that it's so we can go to Heaven. His actual statement says that it is so that we can go see His dad. This was actually one of the points of the book that carried over in to good theology. Jesus' ministry and death and resurrection was intended to point our attention and worship to the father.
I don't think Burpo was trying to write a deep theological treatise. Why read so much into an innocent little book? My daughter picked this out for her grandfather and gave it to him yesterday for Father's Day. Dad lost his oldest daughter last year (ovarian cancer) and for the last two years he's been in and out of the hospital. --also he lived through a tornado destroying his house and lost a leg while being displaced from his home and living in a small apartment. Now he's lost all the toes on his remaining foot and doesn't know if he's going to be able to live at home after he leaves the hospital. He's very discouraged and depressed. This gift from his grandchild has encouraged him and so far I haven't found anything heretical in it. That's good enough for me. By the way--salvation is all about us. We're the ones Jesus died for. Our pain and suffering matters to him--our fear and doubt matters to him. The Holy Spirit--the Comforter--matters. My dad just lost a child and is facing his own mortality--right now being reassured that heaven is real is the point.
Katie, I know when things happen in our lives we want comfort and surety in a way we understand, but that doesn't always make it right. By making salvation about us we diminish the glory of God.What I mean by that is GOD is the most GOD CENTERED being in the universe. God is more concerned about His glory than He is about anything else. Out of God's love for His glory He saves people. I am stealing from John Piper here:
• Why does God save us? So the glory of His grace might be praised (Eph 1:6)
• Why did God create people and call them? For His glory (Is 43:7)
• Why did God harden pharaohs heart and deliver Israel? That His name might be declared throughout the earth (Exod 9:16)
• Why did God spare Israel when they continuously rebelled against Him? For His names sake (Ezek 20:14, 1 Sam 8:4-6)
• Why did God bring the Israelites back from Babylonian captivity? For His name (Dan 9:17)
• Why did God send His son for us? So that we might glorify God for His mercy (Rom 15:8-9)
Yes, God saves us. Yes, Jesus died for us...but it was because of our sin that He had to die. The American ideal of making everything about us has left us with a therapeutic gospel that resembles little of what Jesus taught or the Apostles proclaimed.
Believe me, I agree with you that Burpo was NOT writing a deep theological treatise, unfortunately he wasn't writing about what people need to know either...namely Jesus. Heaven is a present and future reality centered on the person of Christ, not us...that gives me great comfort because if God did everything to make me happy, my life (and the rest of the world) would have turned out to be a much darker place.
I do not doubt Burpo's love for Jesus at all, I simply wish people would let the scriptures speak for themselves rather than trying to put our own veneer, dictated by our feelings and experiences, over the top of them.
For God so loved the world that He gave his only begotten son that whosoever believed in him would not perish but have everlasting life. How can salvation not be about us? We are not meaningless. We are not cogs in a wheel. Jesus died for us--to save us. I'm so weak--I'm so unworthy but he died for me. For all of us. I am so amazed, astounded that the God of the universe cares about me, and this little boy in the book. Doesn't that boggle your mind? To say that He died for me and cares about having a relationship with me--how does that diminish his Glory? I never spoke about happiness--I spoke about encouragement. God cares for me and my dad, even in these dark times. He shows how he cares in a myriad of ways. In Christ, I can have hope and joy no matter what my circumstances. I totally agree that Jesus is the center. Furthermore, His glory can not be enhanced or diminished by what I say or do because it's full power, all the time! He doesn't need me, but hallelujah, he wants me.
I think, maybe, this has become an issue of semantics. In terms of communication people often times need to define their terms or they just go around in circles. First, I did not mean to imply that we are cogs in a wheel, but neither is Jesus. He is not a stepping stone to our own self-fulfillment.
Second, yes salvation is for us individually (to be lived corporately)...it is FOR US, but it is not ABOUT us. I don't know if you see the difference. FOR US means it is a gift bestowed upon us by a gracious God...ABOUT US would mean that we are the center of God's universe (which is clearly NOT the case).
My problems with the book come down to this view that holds that it is about us (just like the book 90 Minutes in Heaven, where heaven wasn't about Jesus, it was about the guy who died). We need to make sure we understand that Salvation is a gift given to us (it keeps us humble).
Also, just like it is not "about" us, our salvation is also not "about" heaven. Again, if so, it would make Heaven the point (as this book does). As I said, heaven is not the point, Jesus is...Jesus always is.
I agree that the problem is mainly semantics because I agree with everything you say here--clarifies it very much for me. Thanks for taking the time and for the good discussion. It is for us, not about us--nicely said and true.


