Jerri Miller's Reviews > Red Sings from Treetops: A Year in Colors
Red Sings from Treetops: A Year in Colors
by Joyce Sidman, Pamela Zagarenski
by Joyce Sidman, Pamela Zagarenski
1. Picture Book- Concept
2. An interesting spin for a concept book, the author takes the reader on a journey through the four seasons giving them a chance to experience color in many different ways.
3. a. Text and Illustrations
b. I was a little confused by this book if I can be totally honest. I felt as though the book was too wordy or poetry like for a concept book. I had a hard time following or keeping my interest and I am an adult. Because of this I do not think that the text did the book any justice. I can’t imagine using this book with small children. I do not feel as though this is the best way to introduce, reinforce, or teach the concept of color. I believe that concepts need to be given to children in a realistic way, one in which the children can relate the concept to something he already has knowledge about, something concrete. I was also a little disappointed in the illustrations as well. There could have been so much more the illustrator could have done with the pictures of this book. When I think of a concept book on color, I think of pictures that are bursting with colors and very bold and bright. These illustrations left me unsatisfied.
c. The first page is a good example of the “wordiness of this book”. It says, “In SPRING Red sings from treetops: cheer-cheer-cheer, each not dropping like a cherry into my ear. Red turns the maples feathery, sprouts in rhubarb spears; Red squirms on the road after rain.”
4. If I were to use this book, then I would use it as a basic storybook. I may use it to coincide with the color concept in order to brainstorm ideas of what types of things are the different colors.
2. An interesting spin for a concept book, the author takes the reader on a journey through the four seasons giving them a chance to experience color in many different ways.
3. a. Text and Illustrations
b. I was a little confused by this book if I can be totally honest. I felt as though the book was too wordy or poetry like for a concept book. I had a hard time following or keeping my interest and I am an adult. Because of this I do not think that the text did the book any justice. I can’t imagine using this book with small children. I do not feel as though this is the best way to introduce, reinforce, or teach the concept of color. I believe that concepts need to be given to children in a realistic way, one in which the children can relate the concept to something he already has knowledge about, something concrete. I was also a little disappointed in the illustrations as well. There could have been so much more the illustrator could have done with the pictures of this book. When I think of a concept book on color, I think of pictures that are bursting with colors and very bold and bright. These illustrations left me unsatisfied.
c. The first page is a good example of the “wordiness of this book”. It says, “In SPRING Red sings from treetops: cheer-cheer-cheer, each not dropping like a cherry into my ear. Red turns the maples feathery, sprouts in rhubarb spears; Red squirms on the road after rain.”
4. If I were to use this book, then I would use it as a basic storybook. I may use it to coincide with the color concept in order to brainstorm ideas of what types of things are the different colors.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Red Sings from Treetops.
sign in »
