Maja 's Reviews > As I Wake

As I Wake by Elizabeth Scott

by
4551536
's review
Oct 02, 11

bookshelves: amazing-writing, reviewed-in-2011, sci-fi, dystopia, ya, cover-lust
Read on October 01, 2011

I look down at the ground and close my eyes.
After a moment, I open them. I see my bare toes on the road. I am here.
I am not dreaming. This is me. This is my life. But it doesn’t feel right.
It doesn’t feel like mine, it still feels like a dream I’m in, that I’ve been put in.


This is one of those books that will inspire a polarized reaction. Some of you will love it. Most of you will probably hate it. It’s odd in so many ways – not to everyone’s taste for sure – but here’s a small help: if you enjoyed Wake by Lisa McMann, you might enjoy As I Wake, too. I for one adore authors who are brave enough to write something completely different, especially in YA.

The most obvious thing that sets this book apart from others I’ve read recently is the writing style. It is very unusual, almost too bare at times. Parts of it read like poetry, and in those parts the author used not only words, but space as well. She often put each short sentence on a new line, thus giving her story a rhythm that is highly unusual in prose, but that makes it very easy to read.

The story is equally unusual: Ava suffers from complete memory loss, a condition the doctors attribute to a brain inflammation they somehow failed to notice. They decide she’s healthy enough to be sent home with a woman claiming to be her mother. Ava does her best to fit into her old life, but when her memories start coming back, they don’t make any sense at all. She remembers being a girl that looks like the Ava she is now, but not quite. She remembers living in a tightly controlled society, working for the State Antiterrorism Taskforce as a listener, spying on those who represent a potential threat to the government. The world she remembers is one where your every move is monitored, your every word is recorded, and you can get publicly executed for doing something as simple as falling in love, unless, of course, it’s government-approved. What’s more, she remembers the people around her, but as slightly different versions of themselves. She remembers seeing her friend Olivia clubbed to death for having an affair with another girl, but here Olivia is, alive and well and attending high school together with everyone else.
Then a boy shows up, and Ava starts remembering other parts of her previous life: a forbidden love, the constant danger and running from her past.

The Ava I’m supposed to be doesn’t know her.
But the Ava I am does.
I am here, in this world, in this life.
But I don’t think I’m from here.
I don’t think I belong here.
I close my eyes.


Books about memory loss seem to be very popular lately, but I do believe that Elizabeth Scott offered a story that is new and original. I’m not exactly sure what this novel is: dystopian, science fiction, a combination of both or something else entirely, but I know that I liked the end result a lot. It’s unlike any other book I’ve read this year. Besides, I finished it in no more than two hours, which I know some of you will appreciate.

Favorite quote:
He is nothing to look at, and yet I can’t stop looking at him. There is something beautiful in how his face is made, how all the tiny flaws blend together into something more perfect than perfection could ever be.

3.5 stars

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read As I Wake.
sign in »

Reading Progress

10/01/2011
41.0% "Wow. This book is so weird, but in a good way. I think. I have no idea what's going on. :)"

Comments (showing 1-40 of 40) (40 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Giselle (new)

Giselle Wow this sounds pretty cool!


Maja Coming from a lady who *coughs* hated Wake *coughs*.

I'm kidding, it is pretty cool. ;)


message 3: by Jasprit (new) - added it

Jasprit Great review Maja, I've had problems in the past finding good books about memory loss, looking forward to reading this :)


message 4: by Giselle (new)

Giselle Maja wrote: "Coming from a lady who *coughs* hated Wake *coughs*. "

One of the worst books ever written!! That's my story and I'm sticking to it!


Maja Hmm, I just finished Before I Go to Sleep. Not entirely my thing, but I think a lot of people will like it. Others that come to mind are Persistence of Memory and The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer, although I haven't read that one yet.


Maja Giselle wrote: "Maja wrote: "Coming from a lady who *coughs* hated Wake *coughs*. "

One of the worst books ever written!! That's my story and I'm sticking to it!"


:D Somehow I doubt that you'd like this one! Definitely download a sample first. ;)


message 7: by Giselle (new)

Giselle Wake it was mostly the way it was written. Diary style. I don't really remember the book very well I just remember being very bored with it.

Mara Dyer I am DYING to read. I'm waiting for my copy to arrive in the mail. I've been waiting about 18 years already. *sigh*


Maja I'm trying to keep my expectations low, but I'm afraid I'm not doing a very good job.


message 9: by Giselle (new)

Giselle So far I've heard great reviews on blogs. They say it's very creepy! :D


Maja Seriously? Creepy?! Just what I need right now.


message 11: by Heidi (new)

Heidi I just got this last night and wasn't sure what to think of all the negative reviews. Sounds like a smart thriller that may be a bit out of place in the YA genre.


Maja No, I really don't think so. It's just a slightly more complicated 'us against the world' story, but beautifully written.

The negative reviews don't surprise me at all. I know most people won't like this one.


message 13: by Heidi (new)

Heidi Well I will read it.


Maja Good! Can't wait to hear what you think!


message 15: by Surin (new)

Surin I really like the strange writing style from the few excerpts that you posted in your review! And the premise sounds quite interesting too. Gonna add this in my to read list! Thx for the review Maja.


Maja I really hope you'll end up liking it at least as much as I did. :)


Wendy Darling That was fast! I'm glad you liked it.


Maja You know I love this kind if thing! The writing really surprised me. :)


Wendy Darling It's by the author of Living Dead Girl, which I really, really liked. The funny thing is, she's mostly known for light-hearted YA and I still haven't read any of those yet!


Maja Was the writing in Living Dead Girl unusual as well? I only put this on my tbr because Nomes wrote such a wonderful review. That's why I didn't remember it.


Wendy Darling No, that was written like a traditional novel. (You know me and my fascination with imprisonment stories.)

I actually really disliked Wake too and I'm suspicious of gimmicky writing tricks, but I have this on my list because I like the author. And of course, the premise sounds cool. :)


message 22: by Maja (last edited Oct 01, 2011 10:17am) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maja Disliked Wake?!? *gasps*
Houston, we have a problem!


Wendy Darling I am with Giselle on that one. :)


Maja *faints* I refuse to think about that. I was just considering preordering her new book. That's how much I love her.

Hey what's with Galley Grab this month? Did they finally give up?!


Wendy Darling I know, I was going to post another snarky update about it, but I decided to wait since I'd already done one a week ago.


Maja Too bad. They have some upcoming releases I really want. :(


message 27: by Lisa O. (new)

Lisa O. I join the Wendy/Giselle faction on Wake!
So I'm not sure I would like this one either...


Maja Khmp. I shall now go to my room and pout. :D


message 29: by Lisa O. (new)

Lisa O. There there


message 30: by Giselle (new)

Giselle Yay to other Wake-haters.


Wendy Darling We have overcome you, Maja. The anti-wake movement is swelling.

Hey look--we're trolls! But I guess we should be doing that on her Wake review then.


Maja I guess you need to be a linguist to understand... :D :D


message 33: by Donna (new) - added it

Donna  The Happy Booker Oh wow, this one is new to me, but it sounds like the kind of crazy dystopian setting that I love. I did read Living Dead Girl but never worked out how I felt about it enough to write a review. I'm definitely putting this on my to-read list though.


message 34: by Lora (new)

Lora I have a soft spot for Elizabeth Scott, and your comparison to Wake has me really intrigued. I was going to skip this one, but now I'll definitely try it! Awesome review, Maja:)


Maja Thank you, darling. You might not like it, but there's a small chance you'll adore it, so I guess that makes it worth a try. :)

Donna, a friend of mine compared this book to a dream, and that's exactly what it's like. I really enjoyed it.


message 36: by HellyBelly (new) - added it

HellyBelly This sounds really interesting. On my to-read-soon-list it goes!


Maja It is very interesting, but it's also very confusing. :)
I'm still trying to figure out some details about the ending.


Jessica Awesome review! I just started this tonight...I am hoping I am one of the ones that love it lol.


Maja Thanks so much, Jessica. I hope you'll write a review once you're done.


Maja Thanks so much, Cillain. I hope you'll end up liking this, it really is beautifully written.


back to top