Rochelle (Books Like Stars)'s Reviews > Fathomless

Fathomless by Jackson Pearce

by
2174645
's review
Sep 07, 12

bookshelves: 2012-releases, bea-2012, books-i-read-in-2012
Read from September 03 to 06, 2012

Jackson Pearce has once again created a unique twist of another retelling story. This time it's The Little Mermaid. As with the two other books in this series, Fathomless features more of the Reynolds siblings. This time it's the three and only girls, triplets, who have the powers to see the future, present and past. One night, Celia, the youngest and the seer of the past helps Lo, an ocean girl living beneath the waters just off the coast of Georgia save Jude, a young musician, from drowning. Since then, their lives have become interconnected and it's up to Celia to find a way to keep Lo on dry land and remember her former self, Naida, the human girl she used to be.

As always, I really enjoyed Jackson Pearce's writing. This retelling was kind of different from the Hans Christian Andersen story we all know. Lo and her under-the-sea sisters (not really related) used to be human but are now trapped in the ocean though they can't recall the events that led to this fate. They are beautiful and grow more so the longer they stay in the water. They're not really "mermaids", they're not half girl/half fish; they have legs and just chill on a sunken ship waiting for the day the angels come and take them to the sky. They've all tried to sing and seduce men to drown and win back their souls but all have failed. Lo has forgotten who she once was and when Celia and Lo touch, it reveals that her real name is Naida (if you read Sweetly, you know exactly who she is). Celia meets with Lo/Naida more and more, trying to get her to become Naida again fully and never return to the sea. The Lo/Naida "dual/deul personality" aspect drove me crazy. It's not the book's fault, I've never been a fan of the "another person is living inside me" thing. It's an over-the-top concept that just turns me off when I find it pop up in my books. I loved Jude, he was cute, funny and I think the author did a great job portraying his love triangle with Celia and Lo/Naida. She showed how he could equally be attracted to them both in a non-douchebag way. Celia's sisters were okay but kind of annoying sometimes. I feel like all their powers should've been incorporated more into the ending. And of course the Fenris make an appearance, as they do in every book.

Out of all three books, Fathomless has the least action. It's also the fastest one I've read. I was extremely anxious to read about the love triangle that featured two girls after one boy (which I hardly see in books) but there wasn't a lot of adventure/action like in Sisters Red. It also lacked the entrancing prose that Sweetly had where you just wanted to eat the pages. I love this series but Fathomless was the weakest installment. But I still liked it a lot. It was a fun read and if there's a Fairytale Retellings part four, I will definitely be devouring that one too.

Cover Story: Though I love the cover, it's a bit misconstruing seeing how these "ocean girls" have no tails or fins.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Fathomless.
sign in »

No comments have been added yet.