Emily May's Reviews > Froi of the Exiles
Froi of the Exiles (Lumatere Chronicles, #2)
by Melina Marchetta (Goodreads Author)

Once upon a time...
I never would have thought a book could have me sobbing my heart out at four in the morning.
And then Melina Marchetta wrote On the Jellicoe Road.
I never would have thought I'd like traditional fantasy novels.
And then Melina Marchetta wrote Finnikin of the Rock.
I never would have thought characters could get any better than Finnikin and Isaboe.
And then Melina Marchetta wrote Froi of the Exiles.
I think that if Ms Marchetta were to ever write a bad novel, the earth would simply slip off its axis and the universe would implode because the natural order of things would have gone completely askew. Every time I stop and think "THIS IS IT. This is the pinnacle of literary perfection and books just don't get any better than this", Marchetta goes right ahead and releases the proof that I was wrong.
This book is just so much better than Finnikin of the Rock, and that sounds like I'm insulting the prequel - I'm not. I honestly loved everything about the story of Finnikin and Isaboe, I thought it was a fantastic beginning to this series, both well-written and pulse-pounding. But Froi is just more of what I like to read about. Finnikin is a nicer character than Froi, he had many sides and was interesting to follow through his adventures (because Ms Marchetta does not create poor characters), but it was exactly the complications of Froi's character - the battle to control his temper, the struggle to part with the horrors of his past - that made me love him so much more.
And Quintana! Oh Quintana, how I'm looking forward to getting more acquainted with you in the next book. I'm not going to spoil this wonderful character for anyone who is yet to read Froi of the Exiles, but she is fantastic and weird and I can't wait for Quintana of Charyn!!!!
I love how so many characters came into this book and I can remember very clearly the personalities of them all. None were wasted and everyone who was introduced had their part to play that was key to the overall story, not a single one will easily be forgotten. Like The Queen of Attolia was just so much more than The Thief, I felt that Froi of the Exiles was so much more of everything that made Finnikin of the Rock amazing. It was more exciting, faster-paced, funnier, nastier... even sexier. I got hot flushes at the mention of Froi's "wicked tongue"!
I don't really think anyone can say anything else about Melina Marchetta. I tend to mention her in most of my reviews because I find her talent for story-telling and creating a variety of complex characters just incredible. She astounds me. How else can I make you Marchetta virgins pick up her work? Let me know and I'll write it in my next review! I hope I've managed to do Froi some justice with this review and that it wasn't just a mess of adoring mushiness. But then, how do you review a perfect book? This is my crappy attempt.
by Melina Marchetta (Goodreads Author)
Emily May's review
bookshelves: ya-na, fantasy, 2012, fave-ya
Mar 30, 12
bookshelves: ya-na, fantasy, 2012, fave-ya
Read from January 29 to March 30, 2012

Once upon a time...
I never would have thought a book could have me sobbing my heart out at four in the morning.
And then Melina Marchetta wrote On the Jellicoe Road.
I never would have thought I'd like traditional fantasy novels.
And then Melina Marchetta wrote Finnikin of the Rock.
I never would have thought characters could get any better than Finnikin and Isaboe.
And then Melina Marchetta wrote Froi of the Exiles.
I think that if Ms Marchetta were to ever write a bad novel, the earth would simply slip off its axis and the universe would implode because the natural order of things would have gone completely askew. Every time I stop and think "THIS IS IT. This is the pinnacle of literary perfection and books just don't get any better than this", Marchetta goes right ahead and releases the proof that I was wrong.
This book is just so much better than Finnikin of the Rock, and that sounds like I'm insulting the prequel - I'm not. I honestly loved everything about the story of Finnikin and Isaboe, I thought it was a fantastic beginning to this series, both well-written and pulse-pounding. But Froi is just more of what I like to read about. Finnikin is a nicer character than Froi, he had many sides and was interesting to follow through his adventures (because Ms Marchetta does not create poor characters), but it was exactly the complications of Froi's character - the battle to control his temper, the struggle to part with the horrors of his past - that made me love him so much more.
And Quintana! Oh Quintana, how I'm looking forward to getting more acquainted with you in the next book. I'm not going to spoil this wonderful character for anyone who is yet to read Froi of the Exiles, but she is fantastic and weird and I can't wait for Quintana of Charyn!!!!
I love how so many characters came into this book and I can remember very clearly the personalities of them all. None were wasted and everyone who was introduced had their part to play that was key to the overall story, not a single one will easily be forgotten. Like The Queen of Attolia was just so much more than The Thief, I felt that Froi of the Exiles was so much more of everything that made Finnikin of the Rock amazing. It was more exciting, faster-paced, funnier, nastier... even sexier. I got hot flushes at the mention of Froi's "wicked tongue"!
I don't really think anyone can say anything else about Melina Marchetta. I tend to mention her in most of my reviews because I find her talent for story-telling and creating a variety of complex characters just incredible. She astounds me. How else can I make you Marchetta virgins pick up her work? Let me know and I'll write it in my next review! I hope I've managed to do Froi some justice with this review and that it wasn't just a mess of adoring mushiness. But then, how do you review a perfect book? This is my crappy attempt.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Froi of the Exiles.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 03/28/2012 | page 103 |
|
17.0% | "There's nearly 600 pages here and I can already tell it will never be enough..." |
Comments (showing 1-20 of 20) (20 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Cortney
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Jan 29, 2012 07:00pm
I'm hoping to get to the first book soon. I might just have to move it up on my tbr list.
reply
|
flag
*
Really excited for this one! I started reading Finnikin, got about 6% in, and then my Kindle broke, so I can't start reading at least until tomorrow (when they say it SHOULD come in).
I've been waiting for this for so long but it was nearly twice as much to get the aussie paperback than it was to get the US/UK hardback so I made myself wait a few months. I don't know how I lasted this long!
5 stars of course! I'm sure I will probably end up bumping it up to 5 stars when I reread it in September. :)
Emily wrote: "Thanks Eileen! Trust me, if you loved Finnikin I am confident you will love this :)"It's one of my favorites and I devoured the book. I have ordered Froi and hope to receive it soon. Haven't read On the Jellicoe Road which is a complete different genre, but good too, right? I have that one on my to-read-list too.
Oh yes, it's brilliant, probably my favourite contemporary novel. But it's very different to Finnikin of the Rock, I love how Melina Marchetta can dabble in different genres and still write a masterpiece.Just be prepared for sadness!
Cortney wrote: "Love Jellicoe Road! It's my favorite Marchetta book. I plan to read it again this summer."I'm torn... it's either Jellicoe Road or this, I can't decide. They're so different but both are amazing.
I think the best thing about Melina Marchetta's books is her characters, and I love that this book really explored each and every one of them.Oh, and this isn't a crappy attempt at all - I love this review Emily!
I completely agree, Alyssa. Her characters are so well-developed and they all have very distinct personalities. I don't know any other author who manages to create such a vast array of characters and make all of them memorable - even those who only make a brief appearance.And thank you! :)
I hate writing five star reviews with a fiery passion too, but this book wasn't it for me. Sure, I loved the darker Froi more than fairer Finnikin, but for a book so long, I wasn't convinced of Froi's and Quintana's connection. I guess I must wait for the third book to see that.
Luckily for me, I was completely convinced of their connection. Hopefully book 3 will deliver that better for you, and I am so excited to find out more about Quintana - she's such an interesting character.
Emily wrote: "Luckily for me, I was completely convinced of their connection. Hopefully book 3 will deliver that better for you, and I am so excited to find out more about Quintana - she's such an interesting ch..."She is that, but there's a huge risk there too. I trust Marchetta, but I'm still slightly nervous about how it's all handled.
I am no longer a Marchetta virgin because of your review, Emily! I admit that I didn't read any of her books before because YA contemporary literature is not my cup of tea. But Fantasy certainly is, and when I read both of your review on Finnikin of the Rock and Froi of the Exiles, I decided to give them a try. And you're right, Finnikin is a fantastic book! I haven't read Froi yet, but I expect that I will love it even more. Thanks for writing this review!

