Jenre's Reviews > Swordspoint

Swordspoint by Ellen Kushner

by
2620867
's review
Sep 01, 11

bookshelves: fantasy, romance, m-m
Read in August, 2011

This was a book which several people had recommended to me, plus I'd heard a good buzz about it. It was written in the 1980's so it's been around a while.

The story follows Richard De Vier who makes his living as a swordsman for hire to noblemen or women who need satisfaction for a slight or problem. He lives in the very dangerous Riverside with his obviously higher born lover, Alec. During the story Richard is offered two jobs and he accepts one and rejects the other, leading to unforeseen consequences.

I have to admit that this book didn't work too well for me. I didn't like any of the characters and even the honourable Richard and very flawed (and possibly part insane) Alec left me a little cold. I also really didn't like the plot which involved political machinations mainly led by the character of the duchess whose icy smiles and deviousness made me want to smack her hard around the face. The other characters, who were all mainly male, were mostly dupes in her political and social games and that drove me nuts, although I get the impression it was supposed to be amusing. She didn't even get her comeuppance by the end. That's not to say that other people won't like it, especially if you like comedy of manners and characters who twist the actions of others to meet their own ends. Having said that the world-building was very good with the characters and setting of Riverside being particularly effective. The writing too flowed well. I just didn't like the plot or the main characters.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Swordspoint.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Arielle If I had to make list of my favourite literary characters Alec and Richard would come on top of the list. Maybe not in the first place, but close – they fit into my favourite archetype - a mad genius and his down to earth lover/guardian. On the other hand I would not even fleetingly thought about heroes from Nightrunner series - Alec and Seregil irritated me the whole two volumes ... because I give up at beginning of Traitor's Moon.


Jenre It's funny how characters affect people in different ways, isn't it? I just didn't connect with Alec & Richard - possibly because of the way Alec uses Richard's natural wish to protect by deliberately goading others into attacking Alec so Richard would then kill them for Alec's malicious pleasure - but love Seregil and Alec. Intellectually, I can see why many readers loved this book and the characters, but they just left me cold. Different strokes, etc :).


Sagajo Iloved both pairings but I think Alec and Richard got to me more. Alec and Seregil is a more peaceful couple? It's more them against the world.


Jenre I think you are right there, Sagajo. Alec and Seregil work as a team whereas there's a constant tension between Alec and Richard, especially as Richard has to walk on eggshells to gauge Alec's moods all the time in case he suddenly has one of his manic phases.


back to top