Stephen's Reviews > Killing Floor

Killing Floor by Lee Child

by
1413439
's review
Dec 20, 11

bookshelves: 1990-1999, mystery, crime, hardboiled-and-noir, kings-of-badassia, audiobook
Read from December 17 to 19, 2011 — I own a copy

Jack Reacher is a walking, talking, 6’5” prescription-strength laxative guaranteed to cause scumbags to soil their skivvies. As hardboiled protagonists go, this guy is loaded with awesome and I was well and truly won over by the end of Lee Child's debut novel.

Reacher’s a former military police officer who is cucumber cool and carries himself with a calm, quiet stoicism that reminded me a lot of Shadow from Neil Gaiman’s American Gods(another favorite character of mine). In typical hardboiled fashion, Jack’s narration of the book’s events is muted and almost detached. This emotionally restrained tone is employed even when he’s describing scenes of grisly, gore filled carnage of which this book has plenty.

He keeps his feelings in check and doesn’t phase easily, even when scummy douchesacks intentionally strive to work themselves under his skin. That said, when the moment is right and Jack is required to muster his inner grim reaper against the human stains who have wronged him and his...man is it ever G-fucking-O time.

This guy can wetwork with the best of them.

PLOT SUMMARY:

Since leaving the army, Jack’s been doing the “Kung Fu” drifter/wanderer act across the U.S. of A. When he arrives at a blip on the map called Margrave, Georgia he finds himself immediately arrested for murder. Seems some gentleman had his head removed with a shotgun blast and Reacher finds himself as the prime suspect.

So after an eventful weekend in prison during which he redecorates the faces and figures of a handful of inmates, Jack is finally released from jail. At this point, the story takes a dramatic “you must suspend your disbelief” turn when the recent murder ends up having a very personal connection to Reacher. Furthermore, the murder seems to be only a tiny part of a massive conspiracy involving the entire town and the body count quickly begins to rise.

Game on.

From here, our giant bag of nut-crushing head-knockery becomes a one man Sherlock Schwarzenegger** and proceeds to hunt clues, piece together evidence and unleash a batch of industrial strength payback on a whole gaggle of bad guys.

**This is early Arnold and not the later model that comes with man boobs.

Game over.

THOUGHTS:

As you can probably glean from the above, I think Jack Reacher is pretty much THE MAN. What I liked most was that as big and strong as he is, this is no simple, brawn-sporting lug with low voltage wiring upstairs. He’s intelligent, shrewd and has a gift for being able to sift through and digest information while thinking on his feet both tactically and strategically. He’s the complete package, A large, clever anti-hero that knows how to get the job done and who has enough humanity inside him to make you want him to come out on top.

However....

Now that I have slobbered all over this review, I do have one major gripe and it is kind of a big’un. Put simply, the writing was painfully bad. The prose is stiffer than rigor mortis and the dialogue was accoutered with more “he saids” and “she saids” than a Hollywood gossip session.

For much of the first half of the book it was almost terminally off putting and greatly distracted me from the story. I thought I had struck out with this book and was not looking forward to doing my review as so many of my friends liked this.

But, as time went on, as the body count increased, as the stakes got higher and as Reacher’s badass quotient approached epic status, I found myself far more forgiving of the simple, “connect the dots” prose and clunky dialogue and realized I had been sucked headlong into the narrative. From then until the wrap up, I was fully on board.

It was like a mini Christmas miracle.

I fell right into the central mystery that was fresh and unique and more than worth the price of admission for me (despite having a few far-fetched plot components). When you add to that my increasingly bromantic bonding to Reacher and his “Billy Jack against the evil townies one man army” show, I was in hardboiled action Gagaville lovin me some story.

And thus….

Overall, a great main character and an interesting central story made up for some less than stellar prose and I ended up firmly liking this tale. I will certainly check out the next tale in this series as I would imagine the writing is only going to get better and the rest should stay at least as good.

3.0 stars. Recommended.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Killing Floor.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-49 of 49) (49 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Lady Danielle aka The Book Huntress I can't wait to read your review!


Stephen I will try and get it up today. I finished it and loved Jack Reacher as a character. Thought the prose was just servicable but will definitely continue the series as I am sure it gets better and Jack is THE MAN.


Lady Danielle aka The Book Huntress I'm keeping my eye out!


Wesley Sweet action! I hope you like these. If you enjoyed this one, we'll they only get better. I think there was one I had a problem with and that wasn't even that bad, I still liked it.


Stephen I definitely liked it and will be reading the sequels for sure.


Wendy Darling I'm glad you liked this, Stephen! It's fun to see Lady D, Wesley, and now you discovering how fun this series is.


Stephen It's nice to have these "nexus" books that we all have/will read since many of us read so many different books. I love getting ideas for new books that stretch my boundaries but it is also nice to be able to compare notes on books we have both read.

Speaking of that, I am just starting Anna Dressed in Blood and am really liking it so far. Would never have come across it if wasn't for you...well you and Emily May and Bonnie and Maja and Catie and Crystal and Crowinator and Kaethe and .......I figured it was time to join the club. ;)


Wendy Darling We all feed each other's addictions for sure. :) Hope Anna is good to you!


Wesley Yeah the writing does get better. Lee Child worked in Television, went on vacation, got home to a message that basically said "don't come back to work." So he wrote a book and this was it, lol.


message 10: by Bill (new) - rated it 1 star

Bill Great review! I had this on my to-read list back when it first came out, and I had gotten the impression that that the writing was sub-par. But a lot of people like this series so I've been kind of on the fence as to whether I should try him...maybe some day.


Stephen Wesley wrote: "Yeah the writing does get better. Lee Child worked in Television, went on vacation, got home to a message that basically said "don't come back to work." So he wrote a book and this was it, lol."

That is awesome. Nothing like turning lemons into lemonade. Looking forward to more of Reacher stories.


Stephen Bill wrote: "Great review! I had this on my to-read list back when it first came out, and I had gotten the impression that that the writing was sub-par. But a lot of people like this series so I've been kind of..."

I hear you, Bill. The positives outweighed the negatives for me and I figure the writing will improve the rest of the series is looking up.


Kelly-Jane REACHER.

This is me fangirling.


David Ottenstein I thought all of the Reacher novels were excellent! I think I forgave the prose issues much more readily because Reacher kicks some serious ass. The next ones are better, his writing does get some flow to it. 61 Hours is pretty incredible, and I think you'll love Tripwire.


Kelly-Jane Dave wrote: "I thought all of the Reacher novels were excellent! I think I forgave the prose issues much more readily because Reacher kicks some serious ass. The next ones are better, his writing does get som..."

61 Hours was AMAZING. I'm more than a little bit obsessed with Reacher - and you're right, serious ass-kicking going down.


message 16: by Chris (new) - added it

Chris Despite the accent and height difference, your review had me picturing Jason Statham in pretty much every movie he's ever been in...and that's good enough to land this on my "to read" list. Wonder how he'd do against Greg Rucka's Tara Chace? Kickassery would abound!


message 17: by Adam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Adam Sorry, Chris, if you want to see Jason Statham as an impossibly tough, resourceful, and merciless literary character, you'll have to wait for Taylor Hackford's "Parker," which I think is coming out next year.

We'll instead be seeing Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher in the upcoming "One Shot." It's odd casting until you realize that since Cruise's production company bought the rights to the novel, Cruise pretty much cast himself.

YEAH!

Tom Cruise says YEAH!


Stephen Kelly wrote: "REACHER.

This is me fangirling."


This fanboy salutes you.


Stephen Dave wrote: "I thought all of the Reacher novels were excellent! I think I forgave the prose issues much more readily because Reacher kicks some serious ass. The next ones are better, his writing does get som..."

Looking forward to his next adventures in asskickery.


Stephen Chris wrote: "Despite the accent and height difference, your review had me picturing Jason Statham in pretty much every movie he's ever been in...and that's good enough to land this on my "to read" list. Wonder ..."

I haven't read Greg Rucka's Tara Chace books. Sounds like I might have to remedy that.


Stephen Adam wrote: "Sorry, Chris, if you want to see Jason Statham as an impossibly tough, resourceful, and merciless literary character, you'll have to wait for Taylor Hackford's "Parker," which I think is coming out..."

Say it isn't so Adam...please say it isn't so.


message 22: by Adam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Adam Stephen wrote: "Adam wrote: "Sorry, Chris, if you want to see Jason Statham as an impossibly tough, resourceful, and merciless literary character, you'll have to wait for Taylor Hackford's "Parker," which I think ..."

Sorry, Stephen. Today ain't April Fool's Day.


Stephen Damn, damn, damn, damn, DAMN!!!!!!!


message 24: by Leon (new) - rated it 4 stars

Leon Aldrich This novel, like Kathy Reich's "Deja Dead" almost went into the unread pile.

I saw so many positive reviews and was desperate to find another John Sanford, Michael Connelly, David Morrell...

That I kept reading. Within a few pages, I was caught up in the story. I finished the novel in one sitting.


Lady Danielle aka The Book Huntress I haven't read the books, but the Queen and Country comics are pretty great.


Lady Danielle aka The Book Huntress And don't get me started on how wrong it is that Tom Cruise is playing Reacher!


Stephen Lady Danielle "The Book Huntress" wrote: "And don't get me started on how wrong it is that Tom Cruise is playing Reacher!"

It is a crime of epic proportions.


message 28: by Richard (new)

Richard Stephen wrote: "Lady Danielle "The Book Huntress" wrote: "And don't get me started on how wrong it is that Tom Cruise is playing Reacher!"

It is a crime of epic proportions."


I don't even *like* these books, and I think it's an outrage that should have all involved in making the decision up before the International Court of Justice on charges of Malignant Douchetardness.


message 29: by Adam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Adam Honestly, I don't even think Tom Cruise's height and physical appearance is the most wrong thing about him being cast as Jack Reacher. His acting style and attitude are just all wrong.

It could end up being an OK movie if they deviate from the basic formula of the books and really change the character. That happens plenty of times with film adaptations, and it's not always the worst choice.


message 30: by Jana (new)

Jana Great review! I've heard from other people also that Child's earlier writings can be difficult at times, but I know so many people who love him. Nancy Pearl, author of Book Lust, suggests starting with The Enemy (#8). It's on my to read shelf & I'm excited about meeting Jack!


message 31: by Leon (new) - rated it 4 stars

Leon Aldrich Jana wrote: "Great review! I've heard from other people also that Child's earlier writings can be difficult at times, but I know so many people who love him. Nancy Pearl, author of Book Lust, suggests starting ..."

Oh no...We're not allowed to read books out of sequence (criminal).


message 32: by Jana (new)

Jana Leon wrote: "Jana wrote: "Great review! I've heard from other people also that Child's earlier writings can be difficult at times, but I know so many people who love him. Nancy Pearl, author of Book Lust, sugge..."

You'll have to take that up with Nancy. :-)


Stephen Richard wrote: "I don't even *like* these books, and I think it's an outrage that should have all involved in making the decision up before the International Court of Justice on charges of Malignant Douchetardness."

Hear, hear...


Stephen Jana wrote: "Great review! I've heard from other people also that Child's earlier writings can be difficult at times, but I know so many people who love him. Nancy Pearl, author of Book Lust, suggests starting ..."

I think I am physically incapable of reading a series out of order. It is a sickness with me. I am glad to hear that the book continue to get better.


message 35: by Leon (new) - rated it 4 stars

Leon Aldrich It could be me alone, but doesn't Stephen write up the best damn reviews?


Stephen Leon wrote: "Oh no...We're not allowed to read books out of sequence (criminal)."

What he said.


message 37: by Adam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Adam I pretty much never read series fiction out of sequence, except for Lee Child's books. For better or for worse, each one really stands on its own.

To make a TV analogy, if most other series fiction is like "Battlestar Galactica," "Lost," or "Justified," then Lee Child's Jack Reacher series is like "The A-Team," "Have Gun, Will Travel," or "Kojak." And I don't think anyone has ever felt compelled to watch "The A-Team" in order ... I hope.


message 38: by Keri (new) - rated it 5 stars

Keri Well actually Lee's book can be read out of order, because his books don't follow a sequence. He writes one book where Jack is still an MP, but is wrote after Killing Floor. There are later books where Jack meets up with his brother. His very latest book The Affair takes place just before he gets out of the service and further explains why he chooses to get out. Lee also doesn't date Jack as far as age goes. You can figure out his age, but you have to find the clues buried within the books. Some of my favs are Killing Floor, Tripwire (top of the list, because of evile Hobie) Persuader and One Shot and few others. Lee can be hit or miss for me. Also I had already put to rest the fact that Tom Cruise is going to play Jack, but I put to the group, since we are only getting 1/2 the man, shouldn't we just get to pay 1/2 the price to go see it? *rimshot* :-)


message 39: by Wesley (last edited Dec 22, 2011 03:22pm) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Wesley @Keri ,agree completely on Cruise, I'm highly disappointed about that. The height thing is a big deal. I mean Lee Child made Reacher the same height as him. This is sole character that represents Lee Child as an author, the whole operation is just a big rug burn. If Reacher was a jet pilot then sure, but he's not or is he?????? Almost like I can do anything you can do but Reacher can do it better, ha. ;)


message 40: by Chris (new) - added it

Chris I thought Reacher was supposed to live off the grid, call no attention to himself, and blend into his surroundings (until he kicks ass, of course). And they cast Tom Cruise? Noooooooooooo! I don't even dislike him as an actor most of the time, but he does NOT blend in!


Stephen You are right about Reacher, Chris, and you are right about Cruise. It is simply a bad casting choice.


message 42: by Adam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Adam Well, it's not like a 6 foot 5 inch, 250-pound man naturally blends into his surroundings very well, either.

Everyone thought Tom Cruise was a terrible choice to play Lestat in Interview With the Vampire, but I thought he did a good job.

I don't know if he'll do a good job as Reacher, but he could ... they'll just have to radically change certain aspects of the character. Instead of being big enough to break any opponent, I'll bet Reacher will be more of a Jason Bourne-type. A fast, deadly martial artist.


Stephen Adam wrote: "Everyone thought Tom Cruise was a terrible choice to play Lestat in Interview With the Vampire, but I thought he did a good job..."

I have to agree with you on that one, Adam. I was a big opponent to Cruise playing Lestat, but I think he did a really good job with the role. I will try and remain optimistic.


Susan Johnson Adam wrote: "Well, it's not like a 6 foot 5 inch, 250-pound man naturally blends into his surroundings very well, either.

Everyone thought Tom Cruise was a terrible choice to play Lestat in Interview With the ..."

Bite your tongue, Adam. Cruise is a foot shorter and a 100 lbs. lighter than Reacher. It makes me cry that Child sold out so big time. I love Reacher and the thought of Cruise playing the tole makes my toes curl.


message 45: by Adam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Adam I don't disagree with you, Susan. I was just saying that the film of "One Shot" might end up being OK, just very different from the book.


Cathy DuPont Very entertaining review!


Katrina I was wondering who he reminded me of! Shadow! You hit the nail on the head there!


Lindy Jaw dropping review...will have to look your others up!!!!


Drrowdyd I just got this book and I can only hope it's half as fun to read as your review was.


back to top