Tamra's Reviews > Ender's Shadow
Ender's Shadow (Shadow, #1)
by Orson Scott Card
by Orson Scott Card
I am ashamed to admit that I've never finished the Ender's Game original set. But I did read Ender's Shadow, which I think most people really liked. I didn't mind it, but I have some serious reservations.
First, the original story is better. This re-telling isn't near as fun. It takes longer to get to the GOOD story, though it is interesting to see the background on this kid.
Most of what I disliked, though, is that this re-interpretation is NOT what Card originally had in mind when he wrote Ender's Game. The character that exists in Ender's Shadow is NOT the same character that is in Ender's Game. Sorry. I won't give it to you so easily. And not only that, but you have to re-interpret Ender, too, and I'm not willing to do that, either. In Ender's Shadow we get Ender's softer side, his insecurities. Suddenly, a scene where Ender consoles Whatever-the-main-character's-name-is turns into him consoling Ender. Not buying it.
I wouldn't re-read it, and I would rather have done without it, actually.
First, the original story is better. This re-telling isn't near as fun. It takes longer to get to the GOOD story, though it is interesting to see the background on this kid.
Most of what I disliked, though, is that this re-interpretation is NOT what Card originally had in mind when he wrote Ender's Game. The character that exists in Ender's Shadow is NOT the same character that is in Ender's Game. Sorry. I won't give it to you so easily. And not only that, but you have to re-interpret Ender, too, and I'm not willing to do that, either. In Ender's Shadow we get Ender's softer side, his insecurities. Suddenly, a scene where Ender consoles Whatever-the-main-character's-name-is turns into him consoling Ender. Not buying it.
I wouldn't re-read it, and I would rather have done without it, actually.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Ender's Shadow.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-7 of 7) (7 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Collin
(new)
Sep 19, 2008 08:02am
I just re-read Ender's Game, and I can definitely agree that the two Beans (Game and Shadow) are not the same character. Also, I'd like to point out that he's a minor character in Ender's Game.
reply
|
flag
*
Thank you for that validation there. I think it's obvious, really, so I'm glad you agree. If you didn't agree, you'd just be wrong. :)
The PARENTS aren't even the same. He changed Ender's mother and father into these super smart geniuses who know everything.
Nail on the head Tamra. The manipulations and contrivances to build up Bean and make him suddenly important, probably more important than Ender really debased this for me. It makes it all look like an empty money grab.
