LH Johnson's Reviews > Neversuch House

Neversuch House by Elliot Skell
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5230131
's review
Aug 21, 11

bookshelves: childrens-literature, fantasy

Neversuch House. A curious location, home to the Halibut family who live in a cloistered existence from the world outside. Everyone's pretty much fine with that until one day Omnia Halibut finds herself involved in a series of extraordinary events.

Hear that? She's involved in Extraordinary Events. You'll hear it several times during the book as the text can't quite resist telling you that there are Extraordinary Events going on and you should pay attention to them because they are Extraordinary Events (they're Extraordinary, don't you know?). I can't help but wonder how this was let through the editing process as all it did was make me think of a Series of Unfortunate Events - the Lemony Snicket books. A comparison is inevitable when the narrator keeps blinking banging on about Extraordinary Events and it's a comparison that sadly Neversuch House tends to lose.

And that's a shame because this book could have been a lot better. The conceit that there's this family which exist quite happily in isolation from the world is ripe for exploration. It could have led to something quite dark and intriguing but it doesn't. The house itself and the location is splendidly gothic and weird with hidden towers, rooms and mysteries everywhere. This could lead to so much but unfortunately we're just told about it and left with the distinct impression that this is all building up for a series of sequels.

So if they do become a series; less of the arch narration and self conscious style please? If you're going to be a fairytale, or a gothic fairytale, or a genre mashup hithertofore unseen; be it wholeheartedly. Because I think this is the problem. It is, as my Northern side would describe it, neither nowt nor summit. Neversuch House doesn't know what it wants to be. There are some glorious moments in it and some very visual moments that are a delight but they're rare. In between these moments is a lot of huff, a lot of puff and it's in these moments, the chapter upon chapter of padding and self-gratification that Neversuch House falls right down.
Likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Neversuch House.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Alison (new)

Alison Oh God. Quirky character names? check. Spooky Old House? check. Self conscious narration style? check. Thanks, I was pondering buying this; I won't and will order from the library instead. Then if the urge to throw it out of the window (as I suspect it will) overtakes me, I can simply return it.

Can I recommend The Incorrigible Children of Ashton Place by Maryrose Wood? It has the elements above, but is funny, suspenseful and a fantastic read!


message 2: by LH (new) - rated it 2 stars

LH Johnson It was spectacularly self-conscious and almost bordering on pastiche. Lots of they didn't think about doing something but gosh they should have done so as they'd have seen a shadow / eyes / somebody watching them!(Dum dum dum sound effects). I really hate direct narrative intervention when it directly comments on the characters and negates their impact as individuals. It's the literary equivalent of shooting yourself in the foot.

And yes, the character names did kill me a little bit. It got very smug at times.

Thanks, as ever, for the reccomendation! :-)


back to top