Jacob's Reviews > Railsea
Railsea
by China Miéville (Goodreads Author)
by China Miéville (Goodreads Author)
Jacob's review
bookshelves: 2012, mieville, i-own, sci-fi-fantasy-etc
May 31, 12
bookshelves: 2012, mieville, i-own, sci-fi-fantasy-etc
Read from May 15 to 27, 2012
May 2012
Are those moldywarpe bones towering over New Crobuzon?
Now there's a thought. But it ain't true, sorry. This ain't a Bas-Lag book. It's more fun than that.
Sham Yes ap Soorap ("Call me Sham") is just a mediocre doctor's assistant aboard the Medes, a moletrain hunting the railsea for, well, you get it--& its one-armed captain is on the lookout for the biggest moldywarpe ever: Mocker-Jack, the great white mole himself!
Yeah, it's kinda like Moby-Dick-with-trains, only it's not, too--far as I know, Ishmael & Ahab didn't go looking for the end of the (rail)sea, & there weren't angels either. Or were there? I haven't read it yet.
Sorry, this review has derailed a bit (har!), but you get the idea: there's a boy named Sham, & he discovers something strange in a wrecked train: somewhere out there, the many many tracks that crisscross the dangerous earth (full of big beasties, antlions & earwigs & moles, oh my) just end--the railsea just stops!--& what lies out there past the edge of the maps where trains don't go is a secret many many trainfolk would kill to find out.
& it's by China Miéville!
& it's got illustrations of giant beasties!
& it's full of ampersands!
& it's a YA novel. I was skeptical when I first heard about it, but quickly converted--it's too fun & playful & adventurous to dislike. It might be one of China's best books in years, too--not that The City and the City or Embassytown weren't also great, but this one is just wicked fun. Which might say something about expectations, since I was skeptical of all those titles (Railsea especially) that turned out great, & the one that excited me most a few years back (Kraken) turned out to be less than good. So I think I should stop judging Miéville's books before they come out, & focus all my time on reading (& enjoying) them as they come.
So, when's the next one? I'm waaaaiting.
Are those moldywarpe bones towering over New Crobuzon?
Now there's a thought. But it ain't true, sorry. This ain't a Bas-Lag book. It's more fun than that.
Sham Yes ap Soorap ("Call me Sham") is just a mediocre doctor's assistant aboard the Medes, a moletrain hunting the railsea for, well, you get it--& its one-armed captain is on the lookout for the biggest moldywarpe ever: Mocker-Jack, the great white mole himself!
Yeah, it's kinda like Moby-Dick-with-trains, only it's not, too--far as I know, Ishmael & Ahab didn't go looking for the end of the (rail)sea, & there weren't angels either. Or were there? I haven't read it yet.
Sorry, this review has derailed a bit (har!), but you get the idea: there's a boy named Sham, & he discovers something strange in a wrecked train: somewhere out there, the many many tracks that crisscross the dangerous earth (full of big beasties, antlions & earwigs & moles, oh my) just end--the railsea just stops!--& what lies out there past the edge of the maps where trains don't go is a secret many many trainfolk would kill to find out.
& it's by China Miéville!
& it's got illustrations of giant beasties!
& it's full of ampersands!
& it's a YA novel. I was skeptical when I first heard about it, but quickly converted--it's too fun & playful & adventurous to dislike. It might be one of China's best books in years, too--not that The City and the City or Embassytown weren't also great, but this one is just wicked fun. Which might say something about expectations, since I was skeptical of all those titles (Railsea especially) that turned out great, & the one that excited me most a few years back (Kraken) turned out to be less than good. So I think I should stop judging Miéville's books before they come out, & focus all my time on reading (& enjoying) them as they come.
So, when's the next one? I'm waaaaiting.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Railsea.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 05/15/2012 | page 1 |
|
0.0% | "Hello, my lovely." |
| 05/15/2012 | page 15 |
|
3.0% | "Slightly annoyed by all the ampersands, & slightly charmed as well." 1 comment |
| 05/15/2012 | page 25 |
|
6.0% | "This one is actually pretty fun. Mieville's books are many things (good things, of course), but I'd be hard-pressed to label any of them "fun."" |
| 05/15/2012 | page 59 |
|
13.0% | "...although "fun" feels like a wrong word to use for a Mieville book, even a fun one. Playful? Adventurous? Not rollicking, at least not yet, but...oh, hell, I'll stick with fun." 5 comments |
| 05/17/2012 | page 101 |
|
23.0% | ""There were times, Sham felt, when the captains regretted there being only two types of limb they could lose to their obsessions." Enjoying this verymuchso. Huh? What's that? John Who? Irving? Never heard of him." 5 comments |
| 05/22/2012 | page 164 |
|
37.0% | "& here we are, the reason for all the &s. & now the word spelled out just looks funny." |
Comments (showing 1-30 of 30) (30 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Daniel
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Aug 19, 2011 05:40am
Good gravy, how the heck is Mieville keeping up with this yearly output?
reply
|
flag
*
I have no idea--but I'm glad he is.No details yet, but the Amazon makes it sound like another YA book:
Look for Similar Items by Category
Books > Children's Books > Action & Adventure
Books > Children's Books > Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror > Science Fiction, Fantasy, & Magic
I still haven't read Un Lun Dun...
Interesting. To be honest, "Un Lun Dun" took the wind out of my enthusiasm for Mieville, and I took a three-year break from his books before finally picking up "The City and the City" and "Embassytown," both of which I really enjoyed. If this is YA, I hope it's something removed from "Un Lun Dun."
Oh, I thought you hadn't noticed or were ignoring it, so I just deleted it out of pique. Oops. Reposting!
Oh shit! I suck! I don't get updates for the wall posts as often because goodreads sucks ass about the updates. I only noticed it maybe yesterday, then I spaced out getting back to you.
I love that you loved this, Jacob. I hope C loves it as much as she loves photos of the author. I think it's not for me though. :-( I'm sad. I totally want in on the Mieville love.
i don't think it's any more visceral than embassytown in terms of grossness... it might work for you.
Embassytown? Not Perdido Street Station? That's the grossest I've read. But the taste of gross may be different for all of us.
yeah, i would say embassytown for sure. railsea is way toned down. it is supposed to be YA after all.
But there really isn't anything particularly gory/squicky about Railsea. Some deaths, sure, but the violence is downplayed quite a bit. Sham rescues little birds from arena fights! He has a pet bat!
Joel wrote: "i just don't want to accidentally recommend another book with dragon cannibalism to elizabeth."See, Elizabeth, how concerned everybody is for your poor drywall?
Poor Joel. He recommends this perfect book for me and I can't get past the first scene because of the cannablism, even though the rest of the book looks great.I do thank you all for protecting my walls; my landlords thank you as well.


