Sandy's Reviews > Lies, Inc.

Lies, Inc. by Philip K. Dick

by
6043535
's review
Aug 17, 11

Read in March, 2011

Of all the sci-fi novels by cult author Philip K. Dick, "The Unteleported Man"--in its later, expanded version known as "Lies, Inc."--has the most complicated publishing history. Those who are interested in the minutiae of this nearly 40-year saga are advised to seek out Paul Williams' afterword in the currently available Vintage edition. In a nutshell, let's just say that "The Unteleported Man" first saw the light of day in the December '64 issue of "Fantastic" magazine and then in one of those cute little "Ace doubles" in 1966. It wasn't until 1983 that the expanded edition appeared, incorporating 100 pages (around 30,000 words) of Dick's manuscript that had been previously rejected by Ace editor Don Wollheim, but with some missing sections still. The Vintage edition now in print reinstates Dick's original vision of the book...or, at least, as much as he could arrange before his untimely death in 1982. The result is one of Dick's most challenging books, those extra 100 pages (pages 73 - 173 in the Vintage edition) having served as a bone of contention among Dick's fans for years now.

In the novel, we meet a young man with the unusual name of Rachmael ben Applebaum. His family's interplanetary shipping business has recently been made obsolete by the one-way teleportation device of the outfit whimsically known as Trails of Hoffman, Ltd. With this new device, colonists can make the 18-year journey to the distant planet of Whale's Mouth in a mere 15 seconds. The only catch: They can't return the same way. Rachmael, suspicious of just what might be going on on Whale's Mouth, decides to venture there the old-fashioned way, proposing to make the 18-year trip by himself. But what he finds when he ultimately DOES reach the colony world certainly pulls the interstellar rug out from under him...and the reader! Those 100 pages of Whale's Mouth material, absent from the original novella, comprise some of Dick's most way-out speculations on the nature of objective reality; as brilliant as they are hopelessly frustrating, they represent Dick at his most extreme. Incorporating a very hallucinogenic LSD trip, hypnotically induced "para worlds" AND a time-warping device, this section is somewhat difficult (to put it mildly!) to get a handle on, and can almost be seen as one big psychedelic red herring. Skipping those 100 pages (in other words, jumping from page 73 to 173) and reading just the original short novel may be more satisfying for many readers, but even read this way, some mind-warping dilemmas spring up as regards time paradoxes. I have read "Lies, Inc." twice now and continue to be baffled by it. The Byzantine plottings of the two warring factions and the significance of the initial computer snafu on page 3 remain elusive to this reader. I can almost barely put the darn thing together in my head, but please don't ask me to explain it out loud. Let's just say that Dick fans who thought the plottings of "The Simulacra" and "The Penultimate Truth" to be complex, and those who thought the drug-induced reality bending of "The Game-Players of Titan" and, especially, "The Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch" to be a bit headache inducing, are really going to be in for some tough sledding here!

But perhaps I am being a bit too harsh. Although I do agree with British critic David Pringle when he calls the novel one of Dick's "least satisfactory books," and with Dick biographer Lawrence Sutin when he says that the novel is "damn weird," I still maintain that even a failure of a novel from P.K. Dick is more fascinating and readable than a "success" by many others. "Lies, Inc.," though ultimately largely incomprehensible, remains eminently readable and entertaining. It exhibits the influence of the then hugely popular spy craze, features an excellent acid trip depiction, contains what might be the first use of the word "psychotronic" (sorry, Michael Weldon!) and foresees the unification of Germany a good 25 years before the actual event. (If only Dick's prediction of a Federation of Semitic Peoples could come to pass!) And yet...is it a mistake on Dick's part that on page 85, the "white-oak blonde" is referred to as Gretch (Borbman), and then on page 92, she becomes Sheila Quam? Or is this just another cerebrum-twisting aspect of the acid trip in the para world undergoing a time warp? Take two Excedrin, read the novel and get back to me....

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Lies, Inc..
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-7 of 7) (7 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Kat  Hooper I'm glad to read your review. I was starting to think I had lost 20 IQ points since starting this book...


Sandy Trust me, Kat...it wasn't you. Ol' P.K. was messing with all of us in this brain warper of a novel!


Kat  Hooper Phew! I need those IQ points!


message 4: by Charlotte (new) - added it

Charlotte Great review. I am about 70 pages from finishing and was growing frustrated with character name swaps and story inconsistencies. I've read a ridiculous amount of PKD and this is the first time I wondered what the heck was going on without the feeling of assurance that it would all wrap up in an amazingly unexpected twist. I'm used to the drugs, his paranoia and use of simulacrum. But this was feeling like a manuscript in a blender.

Love the backstory. I am always amazed that PKD ever got published and is still largely in print. Just goes to show that great sci-fi is hard to find.


Sandy Thanx very much for the kind words, Charlotte! Indeed, of the 25 or so Dick novels that I have read, this is the only one that left me feeling less than satisfied. And please do not expect things to wrap up neatly with this one. Just hold on and go with the flow (as they used to tell hippies who were experiencing a "bad trip"!).


message 6: by Henry (new)

Henry Avila Umpteenth great review of a weird tale,Sandy!


Sandy Thanks as always, Henry. And they don't come much weirder than this one!


back to top