aPriL MEOWS often with scratching's Reviews > Speaker for the Dead

Speaker for the Dead by Orson Scott Card

by
3409532
's review
Aug 14, 11

bookshelves: favorites, science-fiction, metafiction
Read in August, 2011

A grown ups' book, a literary science fiction that has a lot of the Big Questions, by the end answered by Ender the best he can by his understanding of what's needed. Perhaps not satisfying for those who want a comic book hero but instead the kind of hero that has more living man as part of his character than a storybook person. He wants to be a husband, father, and someone who is building a home, not a military genius, not an adventurer, explorer or even a businessman. The title and job he takes on is penance for his perceived sin of genocide, which almost crushes his ability to survive. Being Speaker for the Dead is how he maintains self-respect and at the same time he hopes to evolve the human intellect past its instinct to murder the different. He preaches walking in the Other's shoes as the way to understand, but in a holistic way of seeing. If aliens have sentience, then they can maybe see how the Other may have the same aspirations all living intelligences must have. The Buggers, by this definition, were not only ahead of humans scientifically but also morally, but Ender destroyed them before understanding could be shared between races. Jane is proof flesh isn't necessary for evolved intelligence but she is metaphor for what is possible and a god icon at the same time. Lack of flesh means she can be as heartless as all superior gods are, but the key to growing a heart and caring is love for a man. Biblical references much! Ender is Jesus, his brother Peter and sister Valentine? Guessing is part of the joy of reading, so I leave that for rainy days. This book's planet, Garden of Eden? The Piggies are us, and they have a literal Tree of Life. If it wasn't classified as science fiction this book probably get more respect than it does, but it is late to the party to be part of official literature education. Nevertheless it's interesting and moving, even if the only new thing is being part of an unrecognized literature by the official literary establishment. People have been arguing for decades about what is Literature and what is simple entertainment. I think Literature has become too solipsistic and it needs to admit new genres as Speakers of the Dead.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Speaker for the Dead.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tym (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tym I like what you had to say about this book and really enjoyed it from a different perspective. I was raised mormon (as was/is Card) and so when I read this book I felt he pretty much lifted tons of things from the Book of Mormon and other mormon-recognized doctrine and so it greatly detracted from my enjoyment. I think I should give this a second read with a fresh and non-judgemental perspective.


aPriL MEOWS often with scratching Thank you. Please don't hesitate to recommend books to me that you really liked. I had no idea about the Mormon influence. While at present I've given up on all forms of Religion, religion is fascinating to me ever since I took some classes in Comparative Religions and World History. I've gone back to my ancestors' belief in a great spirit that infuses the universe, especially after I learned that brain surgeons can touch cell neurons in the brain which will cause the patient to feel someone like a god out there. Why do such cells exist? People need that feeling to survive, like enjoying ice cream? Or Someone out there wants to talk? Who knows? But I digress. Plus giving you the wrong idea, perhaps. Religious people would consider me sacrilegious and damned at worst, pagan at best. Actually I love ideas and thinking makes me happy. In my opinion the best idea novels today are in science fiction. I have subscriptions to both Analog and Asimovs, which are the best fiction periodicals still around, since philosophy, psychology, history and science as well as religious ideas are generously interwoven into most stories. I LOVE exploring how clever authors think! I also love satire and irony, so Terry Pratchett is an author in my top ten favorite writers.


message 3: by Tym (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tym lol just fyi I am no longer mormon though my family continues to practice. I def. do not think you are sacrilegious as I think nobody could possibly know for 100% certainty the answer to the "god" questions. Though I don't have a subscription I have a number of Analogs and Asimovs love 'em both! Philosophy, psychology, history, religion and science are some of my favorite topics. Terry Pratchett is a genius, have you read his collaborative effort with Neil Gaiman "Good Omens"? That is a masterpiece.


aPriL MEOWS often with scratching No, not yet. I started reading the Discworld books about 6 months ago in order and the next one to start is Small Gods. Each book is loaded with puns, quips and jokes so I like to go slow and enjoy them better. Neil Gaiman is another favorite! I certainly plan to read any book written by those two geniuses. Gaiman strikes me as more sad about people, and Pratchett seems to love people more, at least his books seem to find something lovingly comic in everybody, no matter how despicable. Whenever I feel bad about stuff I always reach for a Pratchett novel.


message 5: by Tym (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tym Pratchett is a great anti-depressant, and I see what you mean about Gaiman, he's a bit more world-weary as it were. I sadly haven't read the first couple Discworlds, money is tight at the moment so I am just taking what I can get.


back to top