Baba ♥♥♥ Marcus, Tyler, Tate, Dan, Ty, & Hunter's Reviews > Dirty
Dirty
by Megan Hart
by Megan Hart
Baba ♥♥♥ Marcus, Tyler, Tate, Dan, Ty, & Hunter's review
bookshelves: erotica-erotic-romance
Aug 13, 11
bookshelves: erotica-erotic-romance
Read in August, 2011
4.5 stars. CONTAINS SPOILERS!
"All men have the stars, but they are not the same things for different people."
- by Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, "The Little Prince" -

78...
What would you reply when the woman you're falling for is telling you that she's had sex with 78 men? Judge her?
The heroine, Elle Kavanagh, is a junior vice president of corporate accounting. She prefers having casual sex and one night stands. In fact, she doesn't do relationships and intimacy. It's been more than three years since she slept with a guy. Enter Dan Stewart...He's a lawyer. Dan and Elle meet at an expensive candy store. The interest is instantaneous, and she expects to have sex with him but nothing happens. When they meet again, however, she doesn't leave anything to chance. And Elle gets more than she bargained for with Dan, as he agrees to her no dating policy. Instead of dating they call their interludes "appointments". Both of them agree to not getting serious. No attachments, just casual sex.
I've never felt more convinced than at this moment that writing a story in first person POV could be that perfect. It fit. Irrevocably. Wow, this was a very intense, emotional, and riveting story! This is NO comfort read. Actually, it really hurt reading this book and it was sad, but on the other hand there's also a lot of hope. Granted, I have to admit that in the beginning there's no such hope at all. However, as the story unfolds I felt that there's hope for Elle to overcome the pain, shame, and guilt, hope to be able to lead a "normal" life again, hope to find happiness and to be loved.
Also, the writing is excellent as well as beautiful even though the subject matter is the opposite of beautiful. As it is it's very ugly. There's a lot of depth here and you'll find well developed characters. The author has written a very thoughtful and thought-provoking story, and I appreciated it how Ms. Hart was pointing out the psychological effects.
Elle was repeatedly raped when she was a teen. Elle is deeply hurt and very seriously messed up. Shame and Elle are no strangers to each other, and she feels guilty what happened in the past. Elle is thinking constantly. All the time. What's going on in her head is called "white noise" and she can't just turn it off.

She has a lot of baggage to deal with and as the story unfolds, I was doubting rather often if she would really be able to overcome her pain and to just let go of the past. I don't know if I can explain it properly but sometimes it felt kinda surreal. Elle tells her story and the reader (at least my humble self) gets the impression that her body is cut off of her mind. She is "real" but at times it seems like she's telling someone else's story. Elle is very detached, quiet, and reserved, and she is not used to smile or to laugh a lot. Elle has this kink to count anything she's seeing. It helps her to calm down and she shields her mind and body by counting or doing maths. It is like a body armor.
The sex scenes are well-written, erotic, sensual, and hot!
I had a minor problem with Dan. The heroine offered a few hints regarding her issues, and he should have known that something was very wrong with Elle. When a woman refuses to kiss on the lips, when she doesn't like being hugged, and when she refuses to let a man go down on her because it's "ugly" then he must know that something isn't quite right. He knew that she had big issues with intimacy. Why didn't he insist much more to have a talk with her? Granted, he tried and Elle didn't let him in. But please, you have to try harder, just be more tenacious.
"Still staring at the woman in the mirror, I hung up the phone. She looked as if she was going to cry. I felt bad for her, that woman with the dark hair, the one who only ever wore black and white. The one who might have been pretty if she'd only take care of herself, if only she weren't smarter, if only she didn't earn more money. I felt sorry for her but envied her, too, because she, at least, could cry and I could not."
"All men have the stars, but they are not the same things for different people."
- by Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, "The Little Prince" -

78...
What would you reply when the woman you're falling for is telling you that she's had sex with 78 men? Judge her?
The heroine, Elle Kavanagh, is a junior vice president of corporate accounting. She prefers having casual sex and one night stands. In fact, she doesn't do relationships and intimacy. It's been more than three years since she slept with a guy. Enter Dan Stewart...He's a lawyer. Dan and Elle meet at an expensive candy store. The interest is instantaneous, and she expects to have sex with him but nothing happens. When they meet again, however, she doesn't leave anything to chance. And Elle gets more than she bargained for with Dan, as he agrees to her no dating policy. Instead of dating they call their interludes "appointments". Both of them agree to not getting serious. No attachments, just casual sex.
I've never felt more convinced than at this moment that writing a story in first person POV could be that perfect. It fit. Irrevocably. Wow, this was a very intense, emotional, and riveting story! This is NO comfort read. Actually, it really hurt reading this book and it was sad, but on the other hand there's also a lot of hope. Granted, I have to admit that in the beginning there's no such hope at all. However, as the story unfolds I felt that there's hope for Elle to overcome the pain, shame, and guilt, hope to be able to lead a "normal" life again, hope to find happiness and to be loved.
Also, the writing is excellent as well as beautiful even though the subject matter is the opposite of beautiful. As it is it's very ugly. There's a lot of depth here and you'll find well developed characters. The author has written a very thoughtful and thought-provoking story, and I appreciated it how Ms. Hart was pointing out the psychological effects.
Elle was repeatedly raped when she was a teen. Elle is deeply hurt and very seriously messed up. Shame and Elle are no strangers to each other, and she feels guilty what happened in the past. Elle is thinking constantly. All the time. What's going on in her head is called "white noise" and she can't just turn it off.

She has a lot of baggage to deal with and as the story unfolds, I was doubting rather often if she would really be able to overcome her pain and to just let go of the past. I don't know if I can explain it properly but sometimes it felt kinda surreal. Elle tells her story and the reader (at least my humble self) gets the impression that her body is cut off of her mind. She is "real" but at times it seems like she's telling someone else's story. Elle is very detached, quiet, and reserved, and she is not used to smile or to laugh a lot. Elle has this kink to count anything she's seeing. It helps her to calm down and she shields her mind and body by counting or doing maths. It is like a body armor.
The sex scenes are well-written, erotic, sensual, and hot!
I had a minor problem with Dan. The heroine offered a few hints regarding her issues, and he should have known that something was very wrong with Elle. When a woman refuses to kiss on the lips, when she doesn't like being hugged, and when she refuses to let a man go down on her because it's "ugly" then he must know that something isn't quite right. He knew that she had big issues with intimacy. Why didn't he insist much more to have a talk with her? Granted, he tried and Elle didn't let him in. But please, you have to try harder, just be more tenacious.
"Still staring at the woman in the mirror, I hung up the phone. She looked as if she was going to cry. I felt bad for her, that woman with the dark hair, the one who only ever wore black and white. The one who might have been pretty if she'd only take care of herself, if only she weren't smarter, if only she didn't earn more money. I felt sorry for her but envied her, too, because she, at least, could cry and I could not."
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Dirty.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 08/12/2011 |
|
62.0% | "Wow, a great book!! This is NOT a light story. I'm looking forward to post my review..." | |
| 08/13/2011 |
|
98.0% | "Very good!! Review to come...I hope I can post it this evening. First, I'll go out inline skating... :)" |
Comments (showing 1-50 of 51) (51 new)
message 1:
by
Karla
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Aug 12, 2011 07:48pm
I'm looking forward to reading your review. Just the book description sounds good always love hearing what you have to say.
reply
|
flag
*
Karla wrote: "I'm looking forward to reading your review. Just the book description sounds good always love hearing what you have to say."No comfort read here. It hurts to read this book, excellent writing, though. Absolutely riveting!
Great review...one of my favourite, read again (more than twice lol) Megan Harts....just a thought can you tag your review with spoiler, re 4th paragraph....
Thanks Adrienne. I won't hide anything here but I'll add "contains spoilers". I think it was rather easy to see that this woman had serious issues about sex. And that somebody hurt this woman very badly (like sexual assault/rape). No need to hide anything here. And I didn't write who raped her.
Baba wrote: "Karla, there's something like an epilogue to Dirty...Reason Enough! I'll read it."<Sweet...I marked it. Thanks!
Ignore my other comment...I see you have already read it. Great review! I will add it to my list now :)
I loved this book Baba. I am still in emotional recovery mode after reading this book. This is a wonderful review that I am now able to enjoy since I finally finished this book.
Samantha wrote: "I loved this book Baba. I am still in emotional recovery mode after reading this book. This is a wonderful review that I am now able to enjoy since I finally finished this book."Yes, I just saw your rating and commented. Glad you loved it. It's a very special read. And thanks heaps for your lovely comment, Samantha!
I didn't realize you had read this! I finished "Broken" last week and liked it so much I decided to try another one of Ms. Hart's book. I absolutely loved this book. Poor Elle, she was so tortured and filled with so much self hatred. I loved how the book was not entirely on just her and Dan. All the additional relationships surrounding her ( coworkers, neighbor, brother, mom) were just as important in the overall plot.
Roya wrote: "I didn't realize you had read this! I finished "Broken" last week and liked it so much I decided to try another one of Ms. Hart's book. I absolutely loved this book. Poor Elle, she was so tortured..."I haven't read Broken and I have to be honest, I don't intend to give it a go. Megan Hart is a hit or miss for me and I just think that Broken might not be a book for me. Dirty was quite special and very interesting. What you mentioned about the additional relationships is true. It enhanced the story nicely.
Omg.. I totally agree with your review. I just finished reading dirty last night and can't stop thinking about. I picked this book up right after finishing reflected in you, and I thought that book was good. But you're right dirty was such a well written book. I can't believe I even had tears down my cheeks... I have to say this book is amazing
Cherry wrote: "Omg.. I totally agree with your review. I just finished reading dirty last night and can't stop thinking about. I picked this book up right after finishing reflected in you, and I thought that book..."Yeah, I think it's a story that will stay with you for awhile. Nothing fluffy about it but so worth the read. Glad you liked it too, Cherry.
Awesome review, B! Yep, this will be one of my next reads...the details about the heroine speak to me on a certain level.
Vallsykes wrote: "Awesome review, B! Yep, this will be one of my next reads...the details about the heroine speak to me on a certain level."Thanks, V! I hope you'll like it. I'll be on the lookout for your review. :)
Gina wrote: "Excellent review Baba, this is on my TBR list. I want to read it!"Thanks, Gina! Hope you'll enjoy it too. :)
Does this book have a sad ending or a happy-for-now? It sounds very intense and with the horror Elle suffered it can't be easy to rose tint her ending.
Anna (Bobs Her Hair) wrote: "Does this book have a sad ending or a happy-for-now? It sounds very intense and with the horror Elle suffered it can't be easy to rose tint her ending."The ending is not sad but you should read the novella Reason Enough after Dirty. It's their HEA. :D
Thanks, Baba! I commented on your review of the novella. When people suffer this kind of trauma, especially when used in a romance, I need to see a credible resolution.
Anna (Bobs Her Hair) wrote: "Thanks, Baba! I commented on your review of the novella. When people suffer this kind of trauma, especially when used in a romance, I need to see a credible resolution."It's been a while since I read the novel but I *think* the resolution was quite well done? :)
Well damn Baba I wish I read your review before I started the book :((( great review btw and you're right, definitely not a comfort read :S
Blacky wrote: "Well damn Baba I wish I read your review before I started the book :((( great review btw and you're right, definitely not a comfort read :S"Thanks, Blacky. Yes, if you can't handle a somewhat depressing storyline then this book will not work out for you. :)
Baba wrote: "Blacky wrote: "Well damn Baba I wish I read your review before I started the book :((( great review btw and you're right, definitely not a comfort read :S"Thanks, Blacky. Yes, if you can't handle..."
Yeah, I know :( I guess I'll have to try different stuff until I find what works for me I guess :D I'm fussy that way hahahah
Baba wrote: "Blacky wrote: "Well damn Baba I wish I read your review before I started the book :((( great review btw and you're right, definitely not a comfort read :S"Thanks, Blacky. Yes, if you can't handle..."
Doesn't Megan Hart tend to write somewhat bleak erotics? I haven't read her work The word about her is that the stories are exceptional, but there aren't rainbows in Romancelandia for the characters.
Anna (Bobs Her Hair) wrote: "Baba wrote: "Blacky wrote: "Well damn Baba I wish I read your review before I started the book :((( great review btw and you're right, definitely not a comfort read :S"Thanks, Blacky. Yes, if you..."
Megan Hart is either hit or miss for me, Anna. I haven't read Broken coz I think it would be too much for me to handle. I think I liked another of her books but one or two stories were really disappointing. It's true, though, her stories are not fluffy at all.
Louise wrote: "Great review Baba!:) if my dark side creeps me in I'm gonna read this one hahaha:)"Thanks, Louise! Well, I guess you need to be in the right frame of mind to read this book, that's for sure. :)
Steph wrote: "Great review, Baba. I'm now going to try and write mine. I really loved this book too :)"Thanks, Steph! I'll be on the lookout for your review. Glad you "enjoyed" it.
Georgia wrote: "Amazing review Baba! Well said and well written!! I loved it!"Thank you, Georgia! Megan Hart is a hit or miss for me. This one certainly delivered. :)
Steph wrote: "I don't think mine's quite as good as your's hun. But it'll do. LOL"Don't belittle yourself, Steph. I liked & commented. :)
okay I was wondering if I should try this. . .and then I see you've read it. lol. That made it go up high on my list
Kenya wrote: "okay I was wondering if I should try this. . .and then I see you've read it. lol. That made it go up high on my list"Lol There are some mixed reviews but I loved it. It's different but a good different. Enjoy!
Kenya wrote: "I'm a bit sick, plus....I like the fact that it's called Dirty!"But there's nothing dirty about the MCs.








