Sparrow's Reviews > Divergent

Divergent by Veronica Roth
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
May 14, 12

bookshelves: girls-rule, reviewed, slaves, utopia-dystopia, young-adult, motherless-daughters
Read from May 12 to 14, 2012

One of the nice things about YA novels, and also one of their faults, is that they, almost universally have the skeletal feel of a story resting solely on plot. You’re almost never going to have a moment in a YA novel where you have to stop because the beauty and subtlety of the writing is too much. This is not absolutely true because I’ve read coming-of-age novels, and those probably count as YA, where I have had to put down the book for its beauty, but these genre-type stories are usually a rush of plot – kisses, deaths, revelation, and identity discovery. Divergent is no exception to that, and I have to say I like it for that. I like that type of story, even though it is not exactly beautiful or subtle. I kind of want Roth to go back and fill in the characters and dwell on the moments and even take out a few fights if she needs to in order to make the ones she includes more potent.

But, ah well. It’s still good.

There is one part in the book where Four says to Tris that another character, a sweet character, was cruel to her because he wanted her to be weak and frightened, but she was strong instead. I thought that was such a lovely thing to say. It was a brilliant way to explain violent cruelty, and I thought well done. You know, it is such a cliché in action stories for the characters to remind each other ask, not whether they have the guts to do something violent, but if they want to be the person they will become as a result of it. I thought this book did it well, though, and that it is an important thing to ask. Like, don’t ask, do you have the guts to kill, but do you want to be a killer. While the book addressed the idea of violence being cowardice pretty straightforwardly, it didn’t feel maudlin, and I liked it.

It was kind of funny the way the factions were set up in terms of good and evil, though, and the message felt very small-town American conservative. I think, actually, there is a note at the beginning that Roth wrote this while she was in college, so maybe her hatred for intellect is more bitterness about doing homework, but it felt very Republican “army good, college bad” at a lot of times - both Salvation Army and the military. But, then, with piercings, so more badass. And then there was the “If only they’d return to the founding documents” message that seemed like a good idea for them, but is troubling if we want to extrapolate it to American politics. Maybe I’m just mad because I for sure think that ignorance causes the most problems in the world, so I would probably be in the Erudite faction, and I DON’T WANT MY FACTION TO TURN EVIL!!

Anywho, it was a super fun read, and I read it late into the night. I thought the relationship between Tris and the boys was great, and all the characters felt like I could fill in actual characters, even though they were just skeletons. It has a lot of factual similarities to Harry Potter, but a spirit of its own. Really fun.
28 likes · Likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Divergent.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

05/14/2012 page 316
65.0% "It is crazy how many reading miles you can get out of me that are 85% fueled by wanting two characters to kiss."

Comments (showing 1-8 of 8) (8 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Sparrow It is! I actually had a copy someone sent me, so I was planning to read it anyway, and then when you brought it up, it motivated me to get it out. Really fun so far!

message 2: by Miriam (new)

Miriam I hate when my Faction turns evil.

message 3: by Jenn "Awww Yeaaahhh" (last edited May 14, 2012 06:30PM) (new) - added it

Jenn "Awww Yeaaahhh" Too much thinking is a bad thing. However, kung fu is awesome!

Wendy Darling Oh good, I'm glad you enjoyed it! Let's see what you think of Insurgent...

Sparrow Miriam wrote: "I hate when my Faction turns evil."

You're telling me!

And good call, Jenn.

That one has seemed to me like one I would hate, Thomas. What was the comparison you thought of between the two?

OMG, Wendy, I need to get my hot little hands on a copy. And the stupid library has zero copies and a bunch of holds. Sigh. I will find one, though. I have faith.

Sparrow Yeah, it is such a political book in its own way, I think. And I kind of feel like most things that teenagers read are political just by their nature of being read by a voter at a formative time.

I realize my shelves are kind of confusing now. My internal rules, known only to me, are that I don't put a book on the girls-rule shelf unless I've read it and think this girl does rule. And then I made the chosen-girls shelf for the conversation we were having at the Great and Terrible Beauty thread, and that has mostly books I haven't read.

Should I put Angelfall on the chosen-girls shelf? I took Divergent off of it because I felt like, even though she has a special power, so does almost everyone she cares about. She's not so much the only one who can save them, like Harry Potter and Luke Skywalker and Gemma Doyle from Great and Terrible Beauty.

message 7: by Sparrow (last edited May 15, 2012 09:48AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sparrow Sweet! I put it on the to-read. I love reading about girls who kick ass, and we are practically living through a renaissance of those now. Yay! Crushing intimate partner violence one example at a time.

Ahmad Ashkaibi A brilliant review. I couldn't agree more.

back to top