Linda Smith's Reviews > Shanghai Girls

Shanghai Girls by Lisa See

by
5993811
's review
Aug 08, 11


This book was very disappointing. I went into it eager to learn about this point in history and this should have been a good book considering the premise of the story. I think it started out well and the family and events in China held my interest and seemed well-defined. Still, the tragedies never felt that compelling, and even what should have outraged me when they arrived in the US, never had the impact they would have if better written. I should have gotten angry, I should have cried, I should have felt more for the characters. The book evolved into a long narrative that just seemed to state dates and facts without any depth and then finally reveals what was the obvious plot point all along. Did we ever know the Uncles? Vern? The girls friends? Sam? NO, only as Pearl and May see them, not a real people. I would like to have read this story (a good one) written by a different author. And I agree with the other reviewer who stated that the abrupt ending seems to just be setting up a sequel. Think I'll pass on that if it does happen.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Shanghai Girls.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Andrea I recommend reading Dreams of Joy, the sequel. Far fewer descriptions of war and rape. More character, warmth, and fascination. The characters have real depth and you can feel compassion for them. She picks a few characters to settle on so it's not a barrage. It makes Shanghai Girls start to seem like a real book. I waited a long time before reading Dreams of Joy because I was so disenchanted with Shanghai Girls. But it's totally worth it.


Rachel I completely agree with you. I found that the writing really took away from the story. When reading through their tragedies I felt more voyeuristic than anything else...it was the strangest thing.


back to top