Gloria Mundi's Reviews > Veronika Decides to Die

Veronika Decides to Die by Paulo Coelho

by
4600483
's review
Aug 12, 11

bookshelves: insane-in-the-membrane, 1001-books, snoozefest, wtf, curiouser-and-curiouser, back-from-the-dead
Read from August 06 to 11, 2011

Veronika is a 24 year old Slovenian woman who one day decides to kill herself, apparently because (1) "everything in her life was the same and, once her youth was gone, it would be downhill all the way" and (2) everything is wrong with the world and she feels powerless to make things right. After she takes an overdose of sleeping pills, Veronika wakes up in a mental asylum and the remainder of the book is, basically, a series of interactions between Veronika and a number of the inhabitants of the asylum, including a young schizophrenic named Eduard, who mainly stands around mutely and masturbates while Veronika plays the piano. Veronika (what else!) inexplicably falls in love with him, after she similarly inexplicably regains her joie de vivre.

I suppose, that tells you pretty much everything you need to know about Veronika, and certainly Coelho does not add much else in terms of characterisation. Some reviewers have pointed out that to create realistic characters or believable plot is not the point of this book and certainly not Coelho's intention. I guess one really has no choice but to agree with this as it is patently obvious that this is not so much a book as a meditation on insanity with characters and plot which are merely vehicles to convey the author's thoughts on the subject and encourage the reader to reflect on the same and to explore how they may feel/behave/think in similar circumstances.

Paulo Coelho himself makes a brief and pointless appearance at the beginning of the book to tell you that it is based on his own experiences as a mental patient and proceeds to bash you over the head with his message, which is that everyone is crazy, insanity and genius are two sides of the same coin and we should all let our inner freak out and stop trying to conform.

As a reader, I find this approach supremely unsatisfactory. For some reason, I tend to be much more receptive to the message when I can actually bring myself to care about the story or the characters, however unsympathetic they may be. I am sometimes able to forgive lack of plot or character development if the book is particularly informative or beautifully written or manages to turn me on or makes me think about a subject in a new and interesting way. Unfortunately, this book did none of that. Veronika fails even as a placeholder because her actions are so absurd and incomprehensible that I was completely unable to relate to them or to put myself in her shoes. So all that was left was the message and I had absolutely no patience for Coelho's particular brand of preachy self-help pop-psychology.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Veronika Decides to Die.
sign in »

Reading Progress

08/06/2011 page 43
18.0% ""It was her first normal day in the mental hospital." Not sure if Coelho means to be funny here or if it's just accidental."
show 1 hidden update…

Comments (showing 1-10 of 10) (10 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Amalie I like this one but I can be biased since I'm a fan. I can read him as long as he doesn't try to be too preachy. Did you know this is loosely based on Coelho’s experiences in mental institutions?


Gloria Mundi Yes, he makes that very clear in the book itself. I've only read the Alchemist before which I hated so I am biased as well but trying to keep an open mind.


message 3: by Tatiana (new)

Tatiana The way you describe him, this Eduardo must be the weirdest love interest I've come across in a while;)


message 4: by Gloria (last edited Aug 12, 2011 07:04am) (new) - rated it 1 star

Gloria Mundi It's Eduard (sorry, no "o" at the end, that was a typo). Yes, I suppose one might enjoy the story for the bizarre elements, but it was all too ridiculous for me. I guess the point was to show the freeing/healing positive aspect of love as up till then it was a destructive force forcing people to conform and go insane (parents loving but not understanding their children, mainly).


Morrigan Gloria, I feel the same way about this book. It took me months to read The Alchemist, largely cause it was a plotless amalgamation of quotes. I decided to give him another chance with this book. Same issue, different title. No plot or character development.


Gloria Mundi Oh, I read the Alchemist before as well, so should have known what to expect.


message 7: by Sujan (new) - added it

Sujan Aryal Lucky you guys! We don't even find books here in Nepal.


message 8: by Alanna (new)

Alanna Summarized, eloquently, my dissatisfaction with this book.


Pamela I envy you for being the type of person who doesn't have to go through crucial and fatal thoughts on life. And yet I pity you for being one of those people who cannot understand the depth people muster in committing suicide.

Also, I should point out to you that this is pretty much a nonfiction book, if Paulo Coelho speaks the truth.

Still, it seems that this book isn't for you. This book has been marked as a philosophy book, so if you picked this up thinking you'll get a story with a good plot, then that is your own fault for thinking that way and expecting things from it that you only expect in fictitious books. As such, you shouldn't expect a good plot line in life either.


Becky I agree with Pamela. Thus was a philosophical book and meant to be read as such. Also it was not Eduard who masterbates it was Veronika and if you missed that you missed the while philosophical value if the moment. It was not sexual as much as the regaining of freedom of expression and life. This book makes you think about insanity and normal in a whole new light.


back to top