Gaeta1's Reviews > Major Pettigrew's Last Stand

Major Pettigrew's Last Stand by Helen Simonson

by
3385613
Beware of the endearing story populated by charming and quirky individuals, particularly if they happen to live in English villages.

Helen Simonson left the country life in the UK a good quarter of a
century ago, and her perception of the goings-on in rural England seem to have frozen when she left for the university. Actually, I don't think the UK she portrays in this novel--and certainly Major Pettigrew--really existed even back then. I met a fair amount of British officers when my husband was serving in England, and I can't think of any middling-grade officer who would insist on being called by his rank. It's all too Colonel Blimp-ish--what era did this guy serve in--the Boer War or Northern Ireland? But Ms Simonson is an equal-opportunity panderer--let's give the Americans the clueless class-bound Brits (whose obtuseness defy reality) and for our cousins across the pond, the crass loud American; that way everyone can feel smug and superior. Then, to keep the reader from falling asleep over the endless ruminations over the damned Purdy guns ( a clumsily created symbol of an England that only exists in the writer's mind) just throw in a slapstick panto-like dinner dance production, and an absurd melodramatic finish. It's fitting that the author's vocabulary is all over the place--half British and half American--which suits this odd mish-mash of a book.

N.B. I originally had the book ranked as an inoffensive three star read, but my annoyance, instead of fading into a it-wasn't-that-bad lull, has only sharpened into a growing dislike of this insufferably twee tale.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Major Pettigrew's Last Stand.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-22 of 22) (22 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Hannah (new) - added it

Hannah I couldn't make if very far before I gave up entirely. Glad to know I was justified in putting this in the *did-not-finish* shelf.


Gaeta1 Ah, well, it was a book group read, and I always finish them--even the amazingly tedious Sophie's World.


Jeannette Have either of you read "A Guide to the Birds of East Africa" by Nicholas Drayson? I think it is the book that Maj. Pettigrew should have been.


message 4: by Hannah (new) - added it

Hannah Jeannette wrote: "Have either of you read "A Guide to the Birds of East Africa" by Nicholas Drayson? I think it is the book that Maj. Pettigrew should have been."

I haven't.
I know you enjoyed it, though, didn't you?


message 5: by Hannah (new) - added it

Hannah Gaeta1 wrote: "Ah, well, it was a book group read, and I always finish them--even the amazingly tedious Sophie's World."

I should probably be like this, but there's too many other books to be read for me to bother with one that doesn't engage me. I'm sure I've missed some "late blooming" gems by bailing too soon. Oh well :)


message 6: by Gaeta1 (last edited Oct 21, 2011 04:06pm) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Gaeta1 @ Hannah: Remember Nancy Pearl's axiom: for those under 50 years a reader should read 50 pages to give a book a chance; subtract one page for every year the reader is over 50 as time's running out.


Gaeta1 @ Jeannette: Haven't read "Birds" but there's been a lively discussion about this book in my "52 Countries" group and I'm now interested.


Jeannette I was one of the people who suggested it to Chrissie. It's not as weighty as what she normally reads, but she did give it 3 stars.

I really enjoyed it, and it is not just about birdwatching! lol


Jeannette Gaeta1 wrote: "@ Hannah: Remember Nancy Pearl's axiom: for those under 50 years a reader should read 50 pages to give a book a chance; subtract one page for every year the reader is over 50 as time's running out."

I don't follow this axiom, exactly, but I do agree with Hannah about bailing on books.


Gaeta1 That's what she said--a misleading title to be sure!


Jeannette It took me a while to convince her on that point! lol The birdwatching contest is a great vehicle for telling the story.


message 12: by Hannah (new) - added it

Hannah Gaeta1 wrote: "@ Hannah: Remember Nancy Pearl's axiom: for those under 50 years a reader should read 50 pages to give a book a chance; subtract one page for every year the reader is over 50 as time's running out."

I've heard that. Sounds reasonable. I usually try for 100 pages, but for some books that's not always possible :P


message 13: by Judy (new) - rated it 4 stars

Judy Uh oh this was on my list. Do you think it would be any better on audiobook?


Gaeta1 A lot of people liked this book; it's a cute comfort read. It was the military officer angle that was so wrong that really got to me. I know of a few people in my old book group that enjoyed listening to this on audio. I tried and hated the narrator's speaking patterns--he almost seemed to have an impediment--but there's nothing more subjective than how a listener responds to a voice.


Jeanette Awesome review! You said it much better than I could have.


Gaeta1 Thanks--but I've read many of your reviews, and you could have done an even better job.


Jeanette You are so generous to say that. :-) I think a lot of people are better at reviewing books they hated than I am, simply because they bothered to finish the book.
btw, I love the names of the shelves this book is on. They could serve as a review all by themselves.


Jeannette I went back to see the shelves; they certainly are a review in themselves. :)


Gaeta1 I loved your comment of bogus-tude for Before I Go to Sleep. I thought: well, that's the final word and I certainly don't need to throw my two-cents worth in. (Though of course, the NHS would never have allowed such a thing) My shelves are my mini-reviews. I must put more positive shelves in, though mean ones are more fun and often easier to write.


message 20: by Judy (new) - rated it 4 stars

Judy Gaeta's shelf names kick butt! :-)


Gaeta1 Thanks!


Jeanette Gaeta1 wrote: "I loved your comment of bogus-tude for Before I Go to Sleep."

Thanks. When the dictionary fails me, I like to improvise.


back to top